Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[jpappy789]

Let's see Me, Mad, Jpap, and LC are the only males in the game right?

I know I'm not a pirate, and LC hasn't given mereason to suspect he is one. I was concerned about JP's lack of input, but that has increased recently....

TY, I feel better about my vote!

I am feeling better with this info, not so much chance anymore...I am thinking that jm was captain and they in fact put her up as the lynch but with cookes protection and then switched mad to captain. If jm ended up survinvg the next lynch would be jm but mad would have the upperhand as he originally voted jm...with this new info I am starting to like this scenario.

 

[jpappy789]

I vote to plank mad

 

[Madcrawdad]

You're always so helpful aren't you Mad? Gee, such an idea had never thought to occur to me. If only I had your chivalery available to me when I was the Grinch and the idea had never occured to me to play the innocent confused newbie. ::eyeroll:::

I'm obviously not unaware of the technique Mad, and anyone that played the Grinch game with me knows that. Now how about you try to be really useful and just flash everyone your mafia tattoo.

Well, in your mind you've got it all figured out. I won't bother to mention the overanxious newbie, then. Usually a newer player who thinks they've solved everything, and rashly charges in headfirst, only to be proven wrong time and time-again.

I voted for Mad for more than he said. He is smart enough not to address each point but rather gloss over the thoughts on purpose. He brings me into it because I too voted for Beth the first night and JM the second...but what he doesn't mention is that I've NOT been the perfect mix of players. Why? Because I've pretty much been an obnoxious loudmouth because I felt my role required it more and more.

Haven't addressed each point? What should I have said? Would you feel better had I said wrong, wrong, wrong to each one? You're chasing invisible butterflies....

.

 

[Madcrawdad]

First of all, I know I've been playing the part of a very obnoxious person lately but bear with me for a moment and listen with an open heart and perhaps you'll understand why.

I know for a fact that the thief is a female and that she is listed as one of "suspected innocents" here. For those that have figured out my role you'll know why I can know that for a fact.

The appropriate player was given their name and I've been given a yes confirmation that the thief was bribed for information. I have every reason to believe that what I've said to you recently is true. The only missing factor for me is the Gov's confirmation via a vote.

What I think the purchased information confirmed is that the captain started as female and is now male. The thief had access to the Captain's names (both original and new). The thief had also investigated someone else and discovered they were not a pirate.

With that information..who do you now think is the Captain?

Oh, that seals it, then... It must be me? Take a closer look a Hooked Newbie and LChap. I really like HN.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Oh, that seals it, then... It must be me? Take a closer look a Hooked Newbie and LChap. I really like HN.

Awww... I really like you too.


:laugh:

 

[jpappy789]

First of all, I know I've been playing the part of a very obnoxious person lately but bear with me for a moment and listen with an open heart and perhaps you'll understand why.

I know for a fact that the thief is a female and that she is listed as one of "suspected innocents" here. For those that have figured out my role you'll know why I can know that for a fact.

The appropriate player was given their name and I've been given a yes confirmation that the thief was bribed for information. I have every reason to believe that what I've said to you recently is true. The only missing factor for me is the Gov's confirmation via a vote.

What I think the purchased information confirmed is that the captain started as female and is now male. The thief had access to the Captain's names (both original and new). The thief had also investigated someone else and discovered they were not a pirate.

With that information..who do you now think is the Captain?

Based on that info the thief is either mal or meems.

And I guess the gov hasnt voted at all, or voted to "confirm"... if that means switching to mad or something like that...

 

[Grins]

Let's see Me, Mad, Jpap, and LC are the only males in the game right?

Right...and I've said as much as I dare right now so those that are not pirates are going to have to read between the lines of what I've posted and figure it out before the pirates win.

I realize that there are innocents here that I have had times pointed a finger towards and been aggressive with when responding. I just ask again that you consider the value of what I had to protect and realize that there are only so many of your roles I've been able to learn thus far.

I am feeling better with this info, not so much chance anymore...I am thinking that jm was captain and they in fact put her up as the lynch but with cookes protection and then switched mad to captain. If jm ended up survinvg the next lynch would be jm but mad would have the upperhand as he originally voted jm...with this new info I am starting to like this scenario.

I'm just hoping that people read it and make their own decisions based on what I listed as a fact.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grins
You're always so helpful aren't you Mad? Gee, such an idea had never thought to occur to me. If only I had your chivalery available to me when I was the Grinch and the idea had never occured to me to play the innocent confused newbie. ::eyeroll:::

I'm obviously not unaware of the technique Mad, and anyone that played the Grinch game with me knows that. Now how about you try to be really useful and just flash everyone your mafia tattoo.

Well, in your mind you've got it all figured out. I won't bother to mention the overanxious newbie, then. Usually a newer player who thinks they've solved everything, and rashly charges in headfirst, only to be proven wrong time and time-again.

I voted for Mad for more than he said. He is smart enough not to address each point but rather gloss over the thoughts on purpose. He brings me into it because I too voted for Beth the first night and JM the second...but what he doesn't mention is that I've NOT been the perfect mix of players. Why? Because I've pretty much been an obnoxious loudmouth because I felt my role required it more and more.

Haven't addressed each point? What should I have said? Would you feel better had I said wrong, wrong, wrong to each one? You're chasing invisible butterflies....

I might be proven wrong about theories Mad, but not about the fact I listed. That much is true and thankfully one thing I've not had to guess about in this game.

Oh and I love butterflies..especially the pretty little blue ones.

 

[Grins]

Oh, that seals it, then... It must be me? Take a closer look a Hooked Newbie and LChap. I really like HN.

Will do, but as I don't have the ability to talk to a certain someone I do consider their voice important in it. Whether they have spoken yet or not I'll leave it up to the rest of you to figure out because at this point I'm sure not going to say.

 

[Lady G]

Sorry, guy's I have been gone all day, went and got my gold sevs YAY!!!! My mom is going to be in town any time now, so I do not have much time.

Ok, so the Capt. is a guy huh. I don't know really what to do at this point. I feel most strong about Blue being a pirate. When it comes to the guy's, well..I know you feel Mad is the capt. myself I'm not sure...he really has done nothing in my eyes to make me feel that way.

Jpap, well I was very worried about him for a while, then he started posting and I changed my thoughts on him, Lchap..well I am have a hard time with him, my gut is really telling me pirate..his post have been so back and forth..but then that happens sometime, I of all ppl know this. Yet I can't help but getting that pirate twinge when reading many of his posts.
HN-sorry I do not trust him at all, yes he has posted many posts that seem helpful..but there are those that make me wonder, he started the Beth train with being the first to vote her...I believe he was the first to vote Mad also. Everyone always seems to follow whatever he says, in most games...him and Ice which if they are on our side, YES they are GREAT to agree with and follow. The problem is I know how well he is at fooling ppl. As soon as he voted mad, I seen the votes go on him...same as with Beth, sorry if that worries me but it does.

 

[jpappy789]

So you consider Hn captain then?

The problem I have with that is...based on what I have gathered about grins, I am assuming that she knows quite a lot of players roles. She knows the theif or at least the info, the gov, and I think watchman but of course I am just assuming this stuff. She has been after blue, mad, DD, and you. I there is obviously a reason why others have not been mentioned.