Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[Lady G]

Well, I'm off for lunch and a few other RL things...be back on later.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Mad-you also jumped on board because you figure that my reactions were all scumtell, well to be honest I haven't been grilled like that before and I didn't know how to handle it, I took it a little personal. I have explained my actions, but if you still want to vote for me thats fine.

Beth, you've played this games a few times now, so you know that the object of the game is to lynch scum. On Day 1, you've appeared the scummiest... Even you agree that your actions look scummy. The fact that you admit to looking scummy, but claim that it's not what it looks like is noted. The problem is, though, that in this game the pirates will lie when caught. My vote stands.

 

[mee-mee]

Here JL votes for RB (just because RB won't say who brains2 was), not substantial enough evidence. IMO...

Until rbishop tells us who was brains2, he should walk the plank.

I vote to have rbishop walk the plank.

I also think we should tie Beth to his ankles.

And just because of my roleplaying you decide to go after me in past games. And you did go after me harshly. Personal attacks they felt like. But, why do them at all. You said something earlier about someone doing personal attacks on someone else.

Maybe you should read more of the games. Mee-mee is a great role player and often her Pastry shop was a central point in many peoples role playing.

I also disliked the role playing and always voted for the first role player. I am not sure if I really disliked it, but it was fun not liking it.

Now, after a few games, I have lightened up about the role playing. I even took over mee-mee's place.

Besides implying that mee-mee's place was a place of ill repute and calling mee-mee a lush, I really do not see us buddy buddy. If anything, I have tricked her in the past and she most likely does not trust me very much.

To the best of my knowledge (see my lawyer), I have not been on a communitcating team with mee-mee in the 18 games I have played. I do not remember ever talking to mee-mee outside of these games.

Maybe you are playing different because maybe you are a pirate...

Today is a day when I have time to post.

I agree I am playing real different on day one. Just one of those days.

And why the interest in what I am doing outside the game....Others give reasons on why they don't post much, so why not bother with them...

I was just wondering, where is mee-mee? Surely she has more to post. Then we get this.

I am glad she chose to defend jpap.

I retract my vote on rbishop and vote to have mee-mee walk the plank.

And who am I in a close race with someone. Only you and JP voted for me. Nice one. Did you tell him to follow your vote and how would you know if JP pulls his vote off of me or not....but he won't be here for you to tell him to change his vote at the last minute.

At this point in the game, I would expect more from mee-mee and jpap (even thought mee-mee defended jpap and then jpap voted for mee-mee.

I am fairly sure if mee-mee was in a close race with someone that jpap with change his vote. Just a hunch.

Also, I know Lupin is a newb, but we need a little more activity. Any thoughts on the game? Anyone look like a pirate? Why haven't you voted?

Really that goes for everyone that has not voted yet, why not?

JL, you are looking more and more suspect to me.

I vote for JL to walk the plank...

 

[bethkira2000]

Mad I have explained everything in great detail,I can't do anything else to convince you, however besides me who else are your top suspects?

 

[Grins]

As of post #564

Beth (6) by HN(87), HN(392), DD(414), Mal(416), Mad(477), Grins(490), LC(497)
LC (3) by Beth(524), JM(530), Blue(538)
mee-mee (2) by JL(457), Jp(481)
Judge(1) by RB(508)
Lupin (1) by ICE(399)
RB (1) by JL(80). LG(503)
JL (1) MeeMee (563)
HN (0) by Beth(90)
Mad (0) by LC(251)
MG - RIP (0) by ICE (305), HN (387)

We have 15 of the 16 voting. No vote yet from Lupin.

Lupin , I know you're new but if you don't vote before nightfall you UD. I'm fine with that if you're a pirate.

To everyone else, I re-ordered the list a little to show those with the most votes at the top. Although my vote is currently on Beth, this game has more than one pirate and even if she is one there are still several hours to find someone that looks more guilty.

 

[Grins]

I didn't have so many going after me at once. And to be honest Grins, I was having a rough day it was an emmotional day, in RL so I took it harder than normal. I really wish you would believe me normally I wouldn't have gotten so upset, but it was just the heat of the moment, and a bad day combo.

Okay, let's try this instead. If you're innocent let your reasons for previous actions stand and the actions over the next few hours speak volumes. We have to find:

Captain
First Mate
Cooke
Pirates
Thief (I don't trust anyone that is only in it for money)

8) The Innocents win if they lynch more than 50% of the total pirate population or you kill Black Beard.

9) The number of Pirates within this game will be up to the random number generator. It will be less than or equal to 40% of the total game population but not less than 25% of the game population.

So according to Clown we have 17 people playing and the PirateMafia accounts for 25-40% of that total number. 4.25(5) to 6.8 (6/7) = 5-7 mafia. If my math is right that means we have 5-7 PirateMafia and 1 Thief.

Beth, that means that there are cases there for several people. If you're innocent help us find one that is more compelling than what has been presented against you.

 

[bethkira2000]

okay Grins fair enough, lets do this perhaps what about Rbs reaction to what happened with Mg?
some of us were very upset about that, but seemed more upset then the rest of us.
ans then what about Jpap, he has hardly posted, but then voted for Mee-Mee with no explanation.

 

[bethkira2000]

Okay not only did Jpap vote with no explanation, but also said he will not be here tomorrow at all, not that its a reason to think he's a pirate, but why did he vote for Mee-Mee.

 

[bethkira2000]

Okay and LC, at first I had LC-pegged as innocent,but the posts just don't add up, I am going to find the quote that has me scratching my head.

 

[Grins]

okay Grins fair enough, lets do this perhaps what about Rbs reaction to what happened with Mg?
some of us were very upset about that, but seemed more upset then the rest of us.
ans then what about Jpap, he has hardly posted, but then voted for Mee-Mee with no explanation.

Yep, as I said in 544 Bob is looking like a pirate to me at this point and I'm wanting to see something from him before nightfall.

In the same post I mentioned that I forget Jpap is even in the game. But his quickie vote that matches JL has me wondering about him since I had already started to feel a wee bit uneasy about JL, which was also posted in 544. I'd like to hear more from Jpap, but as you pointed out he won't be around before nightfall. Could he be a pirate? Maybe, but with so many pirates out there I'd prefer to vote for someone I have a better sense for.

I'm open to any other theories. As they say "it isn't over until the fat lady sings". Whoops, I think I just called Clown a fat lady. :lipssealedsmilie: