I am defending no one HN, I'm not really flustered so much as not sure what I think at the moment really. The pirates very well may shut me up, next nightfall if I am not planked, then you will be saying the same thing you said about Beth...I went hard on her, and was WRONG
Oh c'mon...you really think they'd go after you? For what? Who are they going strong after now? Who do we know the pirates wanted/want to kill?
too many variables for that...jm never took the lead in votes so would the pirates waste a proctection on jm, or would they play conservative just in case some swithced?
Wouldn't have been a waste, Cooke can protect someone each night
Cooke – you are the ships cook and doctor. Not only do you feed the men their daily rations but you bind their wounds and are able to protect one of your mates during the nightly excursions. You may protect someone twice. You may not protect the Captain at any time. You may communicate with the Captain, 1st Mate and other pirates outside of the thread.
They didn't know, JL was going to get killed though Beth...from their point, ONE pirate was about to maybe be hit by the guard, or planked...they hadn't lost any other pirates at the time.
I'm not following you. How was JL going to get killed through Beth?
If you say so. Why should I worry about you at this point? You don't know who you're posting to sometimes and are blindly defending the person I think is the Captain. He can't even make an appearance? C'mon, Mad... you sent the wrong lackeys. You won't be planked, you're a pirate, but we need to get the Captain.
You don't think he is the captain? I do.
Grins, as a townie you should get your facts straight. 1) would mad, as the hypothetical capt. would rather place a vote on an innocent or risk one of his own? 2) three people (blue, myself, and meemee) had not voted when mad placed his, which is why I am struggling with the idea of him voting off his own when rb was a clear target for the town 3) mad never aligned himself with rb in fact he openly questioned his vote on jm while mainly going after Lg
If you werent the attempted hit last night I would seriously consider you as captain :grinyes:
1) he was not risking JM. He knew that Rb was the likely lynch and that they could protect her for a lynch via Cooke.
2) Again, he had aligned himself with the known innocent that they were about to off via the town (Rb) and JM was probably protected via Cooke.
3) He did align himself with RB...he didn't do it for day 2, but rather day 3. By voting the same as Rb, and few other known innocents (to the pirates) he was setting himself to be golden in day 3 questioning.
And eh, they aren't going to give me the fun roles so soon after being the Grinch. They're going to give me these innocent townies roles where I have to twist in the wind by myself.
I'm sorry..I just find it hard to believe a pirate would pile that late on such a close call of another pirate. Maybe be one of the first on, when there were only a couple votes, but not to make it really that much closer. IMO
Are you even stopping to consider Cooke's protection?
She is cute when she is flustered isn't she?
Waste a protection? They get one each night and there were two leading vote getters... one was their's, the other they knew to be innocent. It was an easy call for them to try to protect JM. Ice saved us there.
Thank you! At last another townie that is thinking like I am!! And I agree, Ice if you're reading this and the townies win this game you deserve a huge thank you. Shoot, either way you rule!
Mad very well may be pirate, but I think you are blindly following HN, not sure why...but careful who you follow GRINS.
I'm blindly following no one LG. The only person that I have followed in this game I admitted to...Ice. I did that when I was not an obvious innocent.
With as vocal as I've been in this game so far (you pirates want to gag me don't you?) there is no reason for me to be less vocal now. This is when I'm getting
more vocal. Obnoxious, granted...but you have to agree with me that I'm not hiding what I think at this point. And to be perfectly clear and for reasons I've stated of my own volition...I think Mad is blackbeard.
oh, I see where I made the mistake...you said you were deciding between me and mad for pirates. I misinterpreted that as who was bb but it makes sense seeing as you have been on him for a while...I was wondering why you suddenly thought I was...:grinyes:
Anyways, any thought about the post I had about one of yours...sorry no post # atm
Well understand, I'm not sure about you. I'm just more sure about him. Lots more.
Whatwould you like me to say? That I missed it? That I wanted you to repeat yourself and you chose not to? Take your pick, either way, obviously if Im asking it means that I didnt know.
How about you confirm who the new captain is PirateBlue? I'd
really like that. :lol2:
