Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

15 Minutes till nightfall
 
6 Minutes
 
A potential male captain?

jpappy789 said:
Well thanks for thinking about me a lot Rb...I have excuses as to where I've been all weekend but I dont think you guys really care...



Now I am. I have been going back and forth with hw.





Yes it is very interesting indeed. I vote mee-mee to walk the plank

I will not be her at all tomorrow
Click to expand...
Here's JPappy's 1st post of the game. Note he immediately votes mee-mee for no reason, following JL's vote. Also mentions that he will not be here tomorrow.


Hooked Newbie said:
If he were the Captain he'd discuss it in chat and or PM Clown.

If he were any other PR, I think he'd just PM Clown. I really don't think anyone that had one would discuss them openly. If anything, those discussing the rules are look more like townies trying to grasp the nuances. I've read and reread the rules 4 or 5 times and I still don't understand everything. Fortunately, I have no need to and just hope that those with the Town PRs are bugging Clown appropriately.
Click to expand...
In this post HN talks alot about power roles. could he be fishing for a power role? Not sure, but could be...sure looks like it, doesn't it?


jpappy789 said:
Some little things about DD that have, together, started me to question her innocence...



Starts off Day 1 questioning LC's ability to play this game, no doubt something to consider, him being a newb and playing well but I honestly do not see anything wrong with that as too many times newbs slide through or get lynched because of misunderstandings. IMO it is nice to have a new player adding to the game...ok now I have rambled on my own thoughts, my point is that already DD is throwing out a name, insinuating that they are being coached, and what really is odd is that last sentence..."Some of his posts that stick out..." and then none of his posts are quoted.



Names 3 people who joke about her missing the red M in MG right after it happened. No one, as far as I can tell, made a big deal about it so really this post is off to me.



First paragraph on her questioning grins "choice of words" vs. not mentioning hn at all (Ice was the one who asked DD). This answer seems unsatisfying. DD, I remember you not picking up on sarcasm in the past. You are used to hn's but when grins says 'arg maties' it deserves questioning?



DD brings Lup and Grins together. No commitment to the 'hunch'...just insinuating again.



Sentence in red makes absolutely no sense. How can anyone at this point in the game, Day 1, know who to switch to in order to help the town?




DD, why would people pm'ing each other point to mafia/pirate like tendencies? I think most have learned to stay away from that as a means of communication between team members. And why would your "primary" suspicion be that Lup was pm'ing? It is a feature of AC that is open for anyone to use, is it not???



Interesting, why would the players of this game allow clown to have a rule where you HAD to post every day or you UD'd in the first place. The UD rule has been about voting for a long time. Weird how you somehow misread the rules...seems to me like you were looking for another reason to suspect Lup because he "wasted" a vote on me night 1.



Another insinuation...(is that even a word?)



Quite a lot of accusing going on from DD all of a sudden. For someone who admits to not being perfect in past games you are going after LC pretty hard for making mistakes DD.



I read over LG"s posts and IMO I do not find her pushing for rb's lynch at all. She defends herself and questions him.

And then the whole captain thing...which has been pointed out already.


So these are my thoughts on DD atm. Basically threw a bunch of names out there at first and then starts attacking LC (after a few questioning posts) and LG (almost out of no where) today after two of her other suspects ended up innocent. I guess I could say DD is my top right now.
Click to expand...
Here's another of JPaps very interesting posts. Talks about DD, but remember he was still all over Mee-mee at this point. See the above part I've highlighted in green.
jpappy789 said:
I was going to bring this up in my post but forgot so thanks ICe for reminding me...what I didnt like was the way DD phrased her resposne to grins..."and just to note, Grins, you have the nerve to question whether I am skimming??"
Click to expand...
JPappy defending Grins... Okay, I do agree that Grins is an innocent.
Hooked Newbie said:
Rb- Jpap has definitely not added much up to this point, but his points this evening seem to be pretty valid. Why so defensive? Do you in fact have any thoughts or are you content to just post in defense? Why are you solely concerned about post count? (You may need to add some more smily only posts to bump up your count). You also seem to go back and forth whenever convenient on whether or not RL issues are valid reasons for not posting. I for one would like to see your thoughts on people.
Click to expand...
Here HN seems to go after JPap for not adding much to the game. Yet, he mentions that he has valid points. Is this defending?
IceH2O said:
Rb would it make you feel better if we switched to JM?

Did you guys luck out and get 7 pirates and with all the innocent UDs its made it so you guys could sacrifice a pirate thats to busy to play?

Guess she isn't a power role huh, just a normal run of the mill deck laborer?

Then when she shows pirate you can look good?
Click to expand...

IceH2O said:
I agree I hate the low posters. But its hard to vote to lynch someone based on that. Maybe if our numbers got to the point where we could chance it but we're down to many players for that right now.

We have no choice but to go with what has or hasn't been said when they do post.

As I said earlier I agree with JM as a vote. I just don't like the reason you are using.

Let me ask in a different way...

What are your thoughts on LC DD and Blue?
Click to expand...
Now some people are all over me for the JMax vote, but Ice here says he thinks that JM is scum...even kills her. Interesting that HN attacks me for my votes. Is he the captain?
rbishop said:
Blue, needs to post more..though I know she isn't one to post just to post...but inactivity means you you are presenting minimal chance of a slip up and really isn't helpful to the town in the long run. It is bad when they have posted so little, you can't even lean them one way or another.

Lchap....leaning pirate...he seems to be very good as a newbie...at least as a newbie here....

DD....don't trust...no way...no how...could go either way, but slightly leaning innocent...it almost bothers me that some of the low, infrequent posters only come out to attack her.....
Click to expand...
I just don't really trust JPap or HN enough not to think that they're the captain.

Also, I retract my vote on Blue and vote to have Grins walk the plank
 
I have waited to place this until the last possible second. Any moment before and I've have given the pirates too much info before nightfall.

By now you know I was telling the truth. The thief was a female and on my list of innocents I linked to earlier. She was paid well for her information and c'mon MeeMee is easy to figure out, we have ALL said that.

The captain was a female, the captain promoted a new captain..this time a male. Bala emailed the thief the new cap's name.

From what I've picked up on from other things known to me....the cap is either Mad or Jpap. I believe Jpap is innocent so went with Mad based on info I had to work with not from the thief.

So there, if mad is not the cap..Jpap is

/game off/ this game is going to give me a heartattack/game on
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom