Mafia #21 Cabin Fever- The Play

[jpappy789]

Night 1: Nightfall Friday 12/28 @ 5:00 PM CST

Votes:

Beth (0)- LChap 6
Ogre (0)- LChap 11
Lady G (0)- LChap 31
Cory Lover (1)- Mg 103 Lchap 155
Lchap (4) Hn 119 Lady G 164 Mal 183 Jmax 184
Clown (0)- LChap 145
Hn (1)- JL 181
Mal (2)- Rb 186 Beth 210
Mg (3)- Lchap 160 Ogre 192 CL 195


No votes from: Ice, Jensons, DD, Clown, bkw, JJ

 

[OgreMkV]

If it weren't for the fact that there are no teams, I'd say there are two pretty obvious teams so far.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Or just posting like a Madman!

I have vote jumped on Day 1, but that was when other people were voting also. LC seems to be just random vote jumping. I think he is just into it. He might get himself killed, but I would expect the madman to be trying to blend in.

My number one canidate is HN. Mostly for comments made on the mafia anonymous thread and that he has "blended in" so far.

I vote to banish Hooked Newbie

LOL. I actually said that I would be a low poster / observer this game. At least get the wording right. I said that and will go by it because (and zero offense intended to Jpappy here) the more I've thought about it, the less I like this format. There's little to no strategy other than for 3 (MM, Ac, & Det) people (the Doc MAY come into play later, but even that is doubtful) and the vast majority are in the dark so like someone said before, it's basically a crapshoot. We'd be just as (maybe more) likely to win the game if we all just agreed to the list of people to banish each night right now (I'll even volunteer to be first). So, given that I don't believe my posting and questioning people will yield anything because there are only 2 people to hope for a slip from and the chances of identifying any real connection is basically nil.

I do find it terribly amusing that YOU are the one to call posting style into question.

 

[jpappy789]

LOL. I actually said that I would be a low poster / observer this game. At least get the wording right. I said that and will go by it because (and zero offense intended to Jpappy here) the more I've thought about it, the less I like this format. There's little to no strategy other than for 3 (MM, Ac, & Det) people (the Doc MAY come into play later, but even that is doubtful) and the vast majority are in the dark so like someone said before, it's basically a crapshoot. We'd be just as (maybe more) likely to win the game if we all just agreed to the list of people to banish each night right now (I'll even volunteer to be first). So, given that I don't believe my posting and questioning people will yield anything because there are only 2 people to hope for a slip from and the chances of identifying any real connection is basically nil.

I do find it terribly amusing that YOU are the one to call posting style into question.

no offense taken at all...I am beginning to not like the format but I wanted to see how this would work out. Its alway been a group of innocents against a group of mafia or whatever.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

no offense taken at all...I am beginning to not like the format but I wanted to see how this would work out. Its alway been a group of innocents against a group of mafia or whatever.

I was thinking about it yesterday and maybe next time, make like 2 or 3 small groups of innocents that can communicate, but only amongst themselves. Still against the MM and acc. Just a thought.

 

[jpappy789]

I was thiking about adding a group of communicating innocents before starting the game but completely forgot...

 

[Dangerdoll]

Or I'm intentionally playing differently, as there is no communicating innocents this round like there were last...

Ok, first chance here today and reading through, I found this to be quite peculiar. To come out and admit to playing differently to me, is huge. Who cares if you were on a communicating team last game or not. The facts are, this game, one of your earliest post, you came out with what you would like to appear as a helpful post... which struck me as you trying desperately to seem as you did last game anyway but to do all that and then put it out like this in a post, I don't know..... odd, but cant say you aren't the most normal card on the stack.

Or just posting like a Madman!

I have vote jumped on Day 1, but that was when other people were voting also. LC seems to be just random vote jumping. I think he is just into it. He might get himself killed, but I would expect the madman to be trying to blend in.

My number one canidate is HN. Mostly for comments made on the mafia anonymous thread and that he has "blended in" so far.

I vote to banish Hooked Newbie

I dont think this is allowed, John.... or if Hooked, you are duvulging int hi gs about this game in another thread, I don't think that is allowed either. Thinking more though, this could be part of Hooked's plan, put posts out there all over. Seems to me, Hooked is trying too hard if that is the case. That said, I don't know if Hooked is the only one to talk Mafia in other threads either.... nice tactic, either way, puts John and Hooked in my suspicions because of the whole questioning thoughts about it.

Oh boy, I really did it in for myself this game. Oh well, Someone's gotta go in the first night, pity it has to be me.

Wow, not used to just a give up like this from LC.... when he says he's playing differently, he certainly is or is it that he needs to play differently and is looking to fan out any flames that may pick up on it early... I dunno...

Well, we can't let that happen, Lchap.....let me be accused of train starting and defending you.


Lchap is Innocent!!!!!!


I vote to banish Malbri....

(teenagers bug me...)

Not sure about this outburst, rb.... seems early in the game to make such definite post.

In person, I'm not innocent by any standard (save that of a serial killer, thus far)...but this game I have been given that role.

Anywho, if I go, it won't help the town...but at this point, it's not really going to hurt the town either...odds are we're banishing an innocent one way or another. If I'm to be the innocent sacrifice, so be it.

as you wish...

I vote to banish LC (I am thinking this will change though)

 

[Dangerdoll]

RB, the more I think about it, the more I am interested in hearing why Mal should be voted as opposed to LC. You're too smart to make such an early designation, prove to me that I am wrong in my vote.

 

[Mgamer20o0]

cant even sleep now...... someone in the game is trying to kill everyone...... they come after me i only have to point it out......

 

[johnlarson66]

Or just posting like a Madman!

I have vote jumped on Day 1, but that was when other people were voting also. LC seems to be just random vote jumping. I think he is just into it. He might get himself killed, but I would expect the madman to be trying to blend in.

My number one canidate is HN. Mostly for comments made on the mafia anonymous thread and that he has "blended in" so far.

I vote to banish Hooked Newbie

LOL. I actually said that I would be a low poster / observer this game. At least get the wording right. I said that and will go by it because (and zero offense intended to Jpappy here) the more I've thought about it, the less I like this format. There's little to no strategy other than for 3 (MM, Ac, & Det) people (the Doc MAY come into play later, but even that is doubtful) and the vast majority are in the dark so like someone said before, it's basically a crapshoot. We'd be just as (maybe more) likely to win the game if we all just agreed to the list of people to banish each night right now (I'll even volunteer to be first). So, given that I don't believe my posting and questioning people will yield anything because there are only 2 people to hope for a slip from and the chances of identifying any real connection is basically nil.

I do find it terribly amusing that YOU are the one to call posting style into question.

Get what wording right? I didn't quote you or even attempt to say what you said. I said "for comments made on the mafia anonymous thread ". I did not say what the comments were. How can you quote a post that you skim?

Sounds to me that you want to quit, before even giving this format a chance.

I am glad I have amused you, but I would think that you would atleast have one suspect at this point. A guess is better than just quitting.

So far, I like this format better than the 50/50 with some mafia not being able to talk. I think this would be better with a small group of mafia AND a lone madman. I think after a few nights and a few suitcases it will get interesting.