MAFIA 22: Who is who?

[Lady G]

hmmm... where's MG in all this. He was watching before the vote... I guess he had to go beat someone up to make up for killing his own hitman.

:lipssealedsmilie:

I'm not stuttering anywhere, if you LOOK I was posting in the salty threads... Helping newbies or others in areas where I have experience. You know the true purpose of this Bulletin Board... (Contrary to popular belief it is not to support the mafia game )

Honestly I got home from work at 6:30 read through the threads before night fell and you are right my spreadsheet was off by one vote on you.. I stand corrected.. For now I'm going to remove my vote from you but you do have other points of interest that have popped up since nightfall..

I retract my vote from LesbianChap

OH, my Clown....I thought this board was to keep mafia going too

 

[clown-lover]

Yes, when they all know one another this is true, but as tonight proved they do not know their own, how can they know who they want eliminated at this point??

LOL, sorry have to laugh...it's just so funny that s/he took out her/his own hitman!!!

Yes, I do agree and have started looking through his posts already.

Clown, you know this post is so "scatter brained" you start out with how they can make us eliminate our own and vote our own in what ever order they fancy...but HN was their hitman and their HIT, so are you sure your not speaking FOR the mafia, saying how the innocents are turning the game around??

I don't think you are understanding what I'm trying to say G.. What I'm saying is if HN looked innocent (and to me he did as I had him at a neutral really as nothing to me stood out) then I'm assuming that he probably looked that way to the mafia boss as well.. In any game whether the mafia are communicating or even this one where they aren't, their goal is to make us innocents look like mafia or to pick at us and make us vote our own out.. Correct me if I am wrong here.. Then they also can hit us and eliminate two of us in one night to get our own numbers down so they can win. (tonight we were lucky and they hit one of their own)... But when I have been mafia the team comes up with a list of people that they think the mod may have put into whatever roles and adjust as the game goes on, but it ends up being their primary objective hit list.. Those that they wish to see go because they are either good at rooting out mafia (such as HN is when he is an innocent), or are on their scent or might be the innocent power roles..

So what made HN look like an innocent to the Mafia boss? Why did he say something that might have made him look like an innocent in their eyes or was it just a random hit.. Thats what I'm looking at now. Just to see if there is anything in his posts that might point us in the mafia boss direction..

 

[clown-lover]

HOW COULD THEY KNOW TO COMMUNICATE?!?!?!?!?!??!

Half the hypothesises posted so far all involve people communicating before anyone could know anything about anyone else.

Here's the scenarios right now:
Mayor finds innocent : begins communication
Mayor finds mafia : begins pushing for a lynch on that player
Boss finds innocent : innocent dies tonight
Boss finds mafia : they begin communication

Whenever the two leaders find one of their own, we probably will not see much happen at all. They'll need to protect that relationship as much as possible... crap, I'm giving away secrets again, but...

At this point, anyone pushing a 'they knew to communicate last night' theory is mafia to me.

The big deal that we won't learn very much at all for a few days... until a) the mayor finds the police and a few targets or b) one of the bosses finds enough of his/her team to start really manipulating the votes.

What secrets Ogre.. This is basic mafia.. If most of the players haven't figured this stuff out by now they shouldn't be playing.. But I do agree with the above..

 

[Mgamer20o0]

hmmm... where's MG in all this. He was watching before the vote... I guess he had to go beat someone up to make up for killing his own hitman.

blockbuster.......

i havent stopped laughing from the boss taking out his own hit man..... i mean..... what a blow lol...... some people are looking guilty.... others i not sure.....

 

[clown-lover]

:lipssealedsmilie:



OH, my Clown....I thought this board was to keep mafia going too

:grinyes:

 

[Lady G]

I don't think you are understanding what I'm trying to say G.. What I'm saying is if HN looked innocent (and to me he did as I had him at a neutral really as nothing to me stood out) then I'm assuming that he probably looked that way to the mafia boss as well.. In any game whether the mafia are communicating or even this one where they aren't, their goal is to make us innocents look like mafia or to pick at us and make us vote our own out.. Correct me if I am wrong here.. Then they also can hit us and eliminate two of us in one night to get our own numbers down so they can win. (tonight we were lucky and they hit one of their own)... But when I have been mafia the team comes up with a list of people that they think the mod may have put into whatever roles and adjust as the game goes on, but it ends up being their primary objective hit list.. Those that they wish to see go because they are either good at rooting out mafia (such as HN is when he is an innocent), or are on their scent or might be the innocent power roles..

So what made HN look like an innocent to the Mafia boss? Why did he say something that might have made him look like an innocent in their eyes or was it just a random hit.. Thats what I'm looking at now. Just to see if there is anything in his posts that might point us in the mafia boss direction..

Clown, I do get what you are saying...but you have me a little worried about you at this point.
IMO, HN was a bad call for either teams "boss" on day one, he would be one to keep around at least a little while until you got more of a feel as to what he was, good or evil he is a good one to have on our team personally I wouldn't want to hit him until I thought for sure he was opposite of me. This point has me leaning to a newer player as the mafia boss.

 

[Lady G]

All those posts and not much substance. The Emo thing is interesting, but since no one knows who is who, I doubt it's staged in the least. Also, DD & Rb- isn't deleting posts basically editting AND using Mod powers? I believe Ice probably tweaked the roles too. LChap- good post but then again I remember how much you've been working for "future games" in the 2 you've played so anything I see from you wil be with a grain of salt.



Comments in blue.

Ok my list... Emo, Jpappy, and CT (Welcome to the game). :grinyes:

Little mixed up LC... or did you skim?

Curious... you said you got good grades and all, but is English your first langauge?

Ok, just thought I'd ask.

*ding ding* Resume newb war.

Is that the one that you were using to track votes with? :lipssealedsmilie:

CT... I really am not sure what to think about you. Did you get some tips from Lchap on how to appear as evil as possible? My vote isn't on you, but only because in this format I'm not comfortable voting off a newb. It is easy to see why you have the votes though. The ones that concern me the most right now are CL, Bkw, Ogre (they disappear off the radar too easily) and JM & Clown (for their out of norm play). Go ahead Julz.... tell me again how busy you've been.

I retract my vote from Lchap and vote to lynch Ogre.

Hopefully this makes it even. I'll be back in a few... I need to use the restroom to take a big bala...

Ok, going through HNs post, yes most were joke sounding type posts...but he took stabs at Lchap and Emo alot. Now, honestly I do not see Ice giving the "boss" position to a complete newb...but Lchap, yep I could see this.
HN started the game out switching votes, I took it as "poking fun" at Lchap, could he (Lchap) of taken (or tooken for Grins) it personal?

I'm not really sure on this obviously, but I really could see Lchap taking out HN in retaliation to him picking on Lchap so much. IF we were to take the boss is a newer player in consideration.

 

[clown-lover]

Clown, I do get what you are saying...but you have me a little worried about you at this point.
IMO, HN was a bad call for either teams "boss" on day one, he would be one to keep around at least a little while until you got more of a feel as to what he was, good or evil he is a good one to have on our team personally I wouldn't want to hit him until I thought for sure he was opposite of me. This point has me leaning to a newer player as the mafia boss.

I don't know what I can do to "quell" your issues LadyG.. All I can do is keep playing and hopefully help the town get rid of mafia. But then I think I make you nervous every game anymore.

This format does make it more difficult for the mafia because they are on the same playing field as us as they have to find their players first. If you remember back to the vamp game I turned HN because I felt he would be a valued asset to the team..

In this format if I was Mafia (I agree with you) I wouldn't have hit him right away either until I found out what side he was really on.. With that being said though, that doesn't mean that another mafia boss, whether a newbie or vet player wouldn't just view him as a threat and made an incorrect assumption that he was an innocent and decided to remove him from the game.. I mean when HN is an innocent he is good at rooting out the mafia..

 

[Lady G]

I don't know what I can do to "quell" your issues LadyG.. All I can do is keep playing and hopefully help the town get rid of mafia. But then I think I make you nervous every game anymore.

This format does make it more difficult for the mafia because they are on the same playing field as us as they have to find their players first. If you remember back to the vamp game I turned HN because I felt he would be a valued asset to the team..

In this format if I was Mafia (I agree with you) I wouldn't have hit him right away either until I found out what side he was really on.. With that being said though, that doesn't mean that another mafia boss, whether a newbie or vet player wouldn't just view him as a threat and made an incorrect assumption that he was an innocent and decided to remove him from the game.. I mean when HN is an innocent he is good at rooting out the mafia..

"quell" my issues...LOL! You are silly if nothing else, and yes you do make me nervous.

At this point I have to say, DD...Lchap...and Emo are my highest suspects.

 

[Lady G]

Mg
Beth
Jpap
- known mafia
LC
LG
Clown
CT-known mafia
JM
RB
Grins
Ogre
Bkw
DD
Cory
Emo

Just bringing up the list of players, for easy reference.