Mafia #23 Revenge

[Madcrawdad]

His thoughts on clown do have merit. But I can't take Mads word for what it is. As grins pointed out how can someone not think LC looks scummy? Mad looks like he accepts the premise hook and sinker.

Here's the thing Ice, I didn't necessarily accepts LC's premise, just said that it was a possibility. I didn't see any urgency to lynching him...wasn't really positive if he was claiming to be the real detective or the previous one. He could have been lying altogether, but it didn't matter, though. If he was telling the truth, the mafia would have killed him overnight and we'd know anyway. If he was lying he would probably still be around come morning, and could have been lynched at nightfall.

Apparently you were buying into it some, it got you to rethink your stance on Judge. Since the beginning of the game you've been going at her hard without really pulling any case together...kind of like with Malbri.

Based on this earlier post below, I feel really good that you're scum...really trying to distance from trying to get Judge lynched.

You know I started quoting posts but omg there are way to many. You guys went overboard on the posting but I see why.

To begin I vote to lynch LC

At 1st I thought well maybe its possible. Many Det have stayed to the sideline trying to collect info. But then I thought but why come out? Him as Det is way more important then saving JMs life.

Then as I read more it became more apparent that this was just more of the mind bending BS you've been pulling. Its all about messing with peoples minds, the hell with the real game.

After I posted the clues and the 2 teams idea I started really thinking about it and thinking maybe I have JM wrong. Wouldn't be the 1st time won't be the last time.

But then you come out and claim DET when it helps no one at all. Then JM goes ballistic. Which moved JM back up but not as far as you.

While I was reading your posts and JMs posts it came to me that you might have be the Det but grabbed by the mafia team. This would be a great way to protect JM.

I think my best option is to lynch you and hope the mafia doesn't hit JM. If you show up as an innocent DET then I know JM is innocent. If you come up mafia Det then JM goes tomorrow.



I really don't know what to think of JM at this time. Maybe I jumped on her to hard but **** if all that going on didn't snowball in my mind. Then she was so defensive it was ridiculous.

 

[ZSandmann]

LChap you broke the game

 

[Grins]

HN, I'm not so sure LC broke the rules

 

[Lady G]

great job LG......are you number 4? lol this is hilarious

What???

Well, you guys as I said I understand the feeling, but maybe you should of found out from Bob what was going on exactly..instead of quiting like that. Yeah, if everyone is willing to keep playing I will too, but you guy's kinda made it hard.

 

[ZSandmann]

Mad, pay attention

 

[ZSandmann]

I'd like to play it out, my list just got a lot emptier but there are still good suspects.

 

[bkw1982]

HN, I'm not so sure LC broke the rules

5) You can say whatever you want in the game, but you can't 'prove it' with my PM to you.

It seems he broke rule #5

 

[Lady G]

it wasnt that big a deal IMO, ppl just need to learn to follow the rules and not use PMs as evidence.

RB you did the right thing to keep the game going, and no harm wouldve been done if ppl would just follow the rules.

I agree, they didn't all have to quite....I'm not sure what rule was broke, was it that whoever was going to quit, so Bob gave someone else the role???

LChap you broke the game

LOL!

 

[bkw1982]

What???

Well, you guys as I said I understand the feeling, but maybe you should of found out from Bob what was going on exactly..instead of quiting like that. Yeah, if everyone is willing to keep playing I will too, but you guy's kinda made it hard.

Well you were right on with your list lol

you pegged ice, grins, and clown......

 

[LesbianChap]

5) You can say whatever you want in the game, but you can't 'prove it' with my PM to you.

I said I was the detective...I mentioned getting the info via PMs (how else does one get it). I said I knew JM was innocent. I never quoted the PMs themselves. If you want to believe what I said, which was true, good for the town. If not, I didn't use the PMs themselves, just the knowledge of them and the role.

*shrugs* I only did it cause I saw similar...forget who it was but near the end of the game before I started playing, one player said: I'm a communicating innocent alone with X and Y, they'll back me up...there's at most 2 Mafia left, and three of you, so don't let the Mafia confuse you and let you kill us all." or something along those lines...I thought I was doing something very similar.