Mafia #23 Revenge

[Grins]

Post 399

Cory Lover posted names and ideas on each player.

Fair enough, but the question remains to ILB with a different name.

ILB any reason why you chose to use Cory's list to base your thoughts off of?

 

[clown-lover]

Well it looks like its been a somewhat productive day even with some of the confusion in the game. At it stands right now I don't have a lot of suspects and much of what I am going to post has been hashed out today.. With the number of posts I like Hooked don't want to sit and quote them all.. But I will answer the questions that was asked of me..

Grins I am cutting out the parts that don't pertain to me so I can answer your question..

clown: Could you explain this post? It looks like you are saying that just because you didn't type it doesn't mean you didn't type it which of course makes me say huh? I'm still wondering why you have an avatar you have previously stated was used to let people know you're mafia. Oh and it appears we both kinda goofed yesterday early on in the midst of the silly flying posts. You did indeed respond to a post of Hook's that his last text was about me. So I was not incorrect about that, however I did miss that his first response was about JM which was the one you were referencing. Oh one last thing, I didn't watch the episode but my son tells me you're basically saying I never leave the computer in order to catch the mafia. Oh and you're calling me fat and icky. :silly:

And the post you are questioning...

Just because I didn't verbalize it doesn't mean it didn't happen ICE..

And the post of ICE that this referenced

That list. Jo also posted numerous times on the subject that random voting wasn't helping. But for some reason it didn't put him higher up as a suspect.

Which was after this posts

Off of what list ICE? I used last game as an example and JoAnder didn't play last game.

Which all started with this question

I expect all the vets to sit high on everyones list on Day 1 just for the fact we know how to play the game. To overlook any of them would be a mistake unless you already know their role.

If by pointing out that random voting doesn't help why did you leave Jo off that list?

I wasn't discouraging anything, I was pointing out that votes spread out among numerous players doesn't help us in the least, it gives mafia a place to hide.

Which ultimately boils down to that I have placed JoAnder higher on my list to a certain extent just like ICE and MAD for specific actions taken last night. Not really anything to worry about as of this point but as the game goes on like many players I have a ranking of who I feel is more mafia. Others have been placed higher on my suspect list as well. But just because I don't verbalize every change I make on my list doesn't mean it didn't happen.

This has been asked previously and answered previously here.

I didn't "goof" anywhere yesterday. While I might not have highlighted the exact part of the message I was answering, the person who the joke referenced knew that it was about her. You are the one who took it out of context.

Your son would be almost correct.. However please note you were the one who stated you would get a crane to pick you up so you could vote in this post I simply asked if you were the Eric Cartman of mafia in this post?

Hey, Clown...thought you were going to be quiet and lay low this game:lipssealedsmilie:

Actually LadyG what I said was that I was tired of letting the low posters slide by and letting them use my work to make themselves look innocent. I am trying a different approach as of last game and seeing if I can catch more crooks.

----------------------
Here is who I am looking at and why...

Beth - Nothing as of yet
BKW - Nothing as of yet
BlueIz - Nothing as of yet
Cool - Nothing as of yet, but would like to see more thoughts from him as he is a previous player from my understanding which means he knows how to play. Other insights are always welcome.
Cory - nothing as of yet
DD - nothing as of yet
Emo - am wondering where this player is as well.. Last game was posting and now you can't even get him to post in fun.
Grins - While others are stating they don't know why she is looking funny I do. She is taking things out of context and when a complete discussion was directed at her she had no input what so ever until the following day. Even though I viewed her online and in the thread late last evening and during the discussion.
Hooked - Nothing as of yet
ICE - leaning every so slightly mafia
ILB - Really am questioning some of the interactions here - leaning mafia
Joander - Wondering where his sense of humor has gone, and like ICE leaning every so slightly mafia
Judge - melodrama jr.. get a grip. leaning mafia.
KOTD - nothing really as of yet
LadyG - Is normally a higher poster and while I do understand that she had to go to work right before the game started am leaning her mafia as of this point because her play is not completely normal. While there has been some posting today am putting her on a to watch status.
LesbianChap - completely odd ball and honestly his strong play style agruement doesn't hold water. There are tons of strong play style people and while he might not understand why he looked mafia last game it was evident to those of us who have played for a while. As I stated with his first post voting for himself, let the melodrama being and it has. First we see martyr posts and then we almost see posts of I'm taking my marbles elsewhere to play. I agree with other posts that if he chooses to continue with this style of play he is going to look more guilty in my eyes.
Mad - slightly leaning mafia
Malbri - Ok so did you actually read the rules Mal? Did you see where the Don's get to pick there teams? As of this point according to the rules Mal there should be a total of 4 mafia, with 2 more being added after tonight. Did you also read in the sign up thread where RB stated he would take new players until 6pm tonight? Sheesh.. Leaning mafia.
Ogre - while others picked apart that post I simply have him as one to watch as I have a hard time reading him.

 

[Grins]

Nice theory, BUT right now I believe LC is probably innocent (at least more so than you) which is why I haven't gone after him. Any revenge I do get (and I will eventually :grinyes will be when I believe he is evil or if he's innocent and I'm not. This new style of his does bug the heck out of me though. Keep your vote where it is. I know it AND this post for what they are.

Why is it that you think he is innocent thus far? He sure isn't acting like he is even if he had never played before for me to compare his play to.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

The quotes imply that your vote wasn't random to begin with but going back and seeing your reasoning was the joke about the toothbrush I'm not sure how it couldn't be? Not that I'm disagreeing Julz looks a bit suspicious the past few hours.

The original vote was pretty much in jest and to see if I got a reaction. The quotes may give the wrong impression, it wasn't necessarily random. Judge and I always go at eachother so I thought I'd put it out there early. After 24 + hours of day 1, it now appears to be my best choice so far. Gotta remember to but some lotto tickets tomorrow...

ACK I hate that word! If I am ever the mod I will automatically UD anyone that uses that word. And CL can be Clown Lover.

LMAO. How do you really feel?

 

[clown-lover]

Um, that is an unusual thing to do. Any particular reason why you chose Clown's post?

She didn't she picked Cory Lovers

 

[judgemax]

Clown?..did you just call me melodrama jr.?..lmao!

 

[clown-lover]

Clown?..did you just call me melodrama jr.?..lmao!

Well when you did the "I'm taking my marbles and leaving post" what do you expect me to call you.. LC is not the person to be taking lessons from this game.

 

[Grins]

This has been asked previously and answered previously here.

True, and I had almost forgotten about it until you now reminded me.

I didn't "goof" anywhere yesterday. While I might not have highlighted the exact part of the message I was answering, the person who the joke referenced knew that it was about her. You are the one who took it out of context.

And I still think you made it appear as if I had been talking out the side of my mouth by inferring that nothing you had responded to had anything to do with me. Because part of what you quoted was indeed directed towards me by the orignal poster that is where I think you also had a part in the misunderstanding. I had frankly gotten past this but um once again I'm having to wonder if this is just you catching up on an admittingly large amount of posts or you are trying to discredit people on anything possible. I won't make my mind on that now, see no reason to.

Your son would be almost correct.. However please note you were the one who stated you would get a crane to pick you up so you could vote in this post I simply asked if you were the Eric Cartman of mafia in this post?

And again I will ask, was my son correct in saying that Cartman was not part of the mafia in that game but rather going after the mafia? On the fat reference, lol...yeah I know I said it myself with the crane and bonbon remarks. If ate as many bonbons in a lifetime as I have typed about the past few months I'd be bigger than a house.

Grins - While others are stating they don't know why she is looking funny I do. She is taking things out of context and when a complete discussion was directed at her she had no input what so ever until the following day. Even though I viewed her online and in the thread late last evening and during the discussion.

I was online in other posts yes and checked in this thread from time to time but what did I miss? I'll be glad to post more :silly: ...just show me what I missed.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Why is it that you think he is innocent thus far? He sure isn't acting like he is even if he had never played before for me to compare his play to.

Mostly a feel. He'd be stupid to change so drastically with an evil role. Remember, the difference between this game and the last is that he'd have somebody to communicate with now that he didn't have last game. I don't believe he's stupid, I do believe his play is this game however. IMO- He's trying to play a game within a game and looking out for himself and his reputation in these games versus playing honest in whatever role he has. He was boisterous (almost to our detriment) in his first game as an innocent PR. He attempted to match that style with an evil PR last game and had no one on his side. This game, I think he's gotten a role he hasn't had before... normal townie and is trying too hard to play differently. I'd rather focus on those that appear evil right now vs. those that might be irking me me.

 

[clown-lover]

As of right now I do think I have a person who deserves a vote.. I vote to lynch Grins