Mafia #23 Revenge
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Ok so riddle me this Grins.. Since you and ICE seem to be the forefront press people on this issue. Why would an experienced player like Judge perform in such a way that she knows is going to get her lynched while acting like a newbie? To me that would be the same as ICE acting like a newbie or ICE RPing when he normally doesn't don't you think? With Mal who knows she is a novice at this game and young and very well its probable for her to make these kinds of errors. But with JM having as many games under her belt if not more than people I consider vets I'm just having a hard time with the reasoning.
Day 1 votes of hitting an innocent far outweigh those of day 1 votes of us hitting a mafia. And with this game and currently only having 4 mafia they very well could be all of the people being quiet while us townies rip ourselves apart looking for mafia. I have no doubt that BaBobLa is laughing his arse off right now. I might be changing my vote to Mal as of this point, but as I have always stated I don't go looking for the easy picks. I never have..
OMG the dead does walk... Welcome back Zman! Love the last line of the post.. LMAO
Firstly, my vote. I would hate to UD after spending about 6 hours reading this thread.
1-LesChap: LesChap(4) LadyG (205)Grins(309)
1-HN: judge(7) Grins(30) ILB(52/123)
4-JM: ILB(14) HN(27) Cory(486) ILB (560) Ice(582) Grins(718)
1-ILB: Malbri(23) bkw(433) King(475)
4-Grins: bkw(69) Ogre(107) clown(450) Mad(682) Blue(693)
1-Clown lover: cooldude(114)
2-Malbri: Ice(242) Ice(632) King(638) Beth(725)
1-King: Malbri(498)
It looks as if tonight will be a vote of either JM or Grins. But I think there are many good suspects, probably many more than actual Mafia positions as several players are undoubtedly acting screwy for attention, drama, or what ever strange motivation they have to make things more complicated. No list today as I don't feel it will achieve anything, but I will put King at the highest spot on Innocence as I will assume that for now at least he entered under the same rules as myself. I can't prove that of course, I can't even prove it for myself, but I think he is clear. After Nightfall that ranking becomes invalid though.
People I have had strong feeling of doubt about are a short list but worth mentioning.
LChap is first and foremost. I don't like your play style. Try and give it credability however you like but it is pointless and personally I found it minorly rude and unneedingly convoluted.
Malbri the last 200 or so posts have been an epic battle between my sanity and pity of your situation. I'm not sure why you thought using any correspondence with a game mod would be useful to your quest, but it blew up in your face in a quite hilarious fashion. However, I am glad to see King has a new friend he can debate with
Brings me to the two "contenders". Grins and JM. Judge is an enigma to me, I used to think I could read her after the "List"-that-shall-not-be-named. But I found quickly that it is an impossible task. As others have said, she is guilty even when she is innocent.
Grins, you win for the longest posts in this thread so far. Although most were amalgamations of quotes. However, I've seen little of actual substance. I see you defended yourself a lot (not saying you shouldn't - just observing). I also see a lot of fluff, and a failure to take Day 1 seriously. Sure have fun, it is a game, but the point of a game is to win. I would like to see the town win.
So, I don't know if we can find a mafia today, the odds are against us, but I want to at least put out the effort. If we don't hit mafia, maybe we at least focus the game a bit by taking out someone that is creating noise in our data collection. (sorry that was the scientist coming out).
I vote to lynch Grins.
Sorry for the long post, but I'm making up for three days of not posting here.
1-LesChap: LesChap(4) LadyG (205)Grins(309)
1-HN: judge(7) Grins(30) ILB(52/123)
4-JM: ILB(14) HN(27) Cory(486) ILB (560) Ice(582) Grins(718)
1-ILB: Malbri(23) bkw(433) King(475)
4-Grins: bkw(69) Ogre(107) clown(450) Mad(682) Blue(693)
1-Clown lover: cooldude(114)
2-Malbri: Ice(242) Ice(632) King(638) Beth(725)
1-King: Malbri(498)
It looks as if tonight will be a vote of either JM or Grins. But I think there are many good suspects, probably many more than actual Mafia positions as several players are undoubtedly acting screwy for attention, drama, or what ever strange motivation they have to make things more complicated. No list today as I don't feel it will achieve anything, but I will put King at the highest spot on Innocence as I will assume that for now at least he entered under the same rules as myself. I can't prove that of course, I can't even prove it for myself, but I think he is clear. After Nightfall that ranking becomes invalid though.
People I have had strong feeling of doubt about are a short list but worth mentioning.
LChap is first and foremost. I don't like your play style. Try and give it credability however you like but it is pointless and personally I found it minorly rude and unneedingly convoluted.
Malbri the last 200 or so posts have been an epic battle between my sanity and pity of your situation. I'm not sure why you thought using any correspondence with a game mod would be useful to your quest, but it blew up in your face in a quite hilarious fashion. However, I am glad to see King has a new friend he can debate with
Brings me to the two "contenders". Grins and JM. Judge is an enigma to me, I used to think I could read her after the "List"-that-shall-not-be-named. But I found quickly that it is an impossible task. As others have said, she is guilty even when she is innocent.
Grins, you win for the longest posts in this thread so far. Although most were amalgamations of quotes. However, I've seen little of actual substance. I see you defended yourself a lot (not saying you shouldn't - just observing). I also see a lot of fluff, and a failure to take Day 1 seriously. Sure have fun, it is a game, but the point of a game is to win. I would like to see the town win.
So, I don't know if we can find a mafia today, the odds are against us, but I want to at least put out the effort. If we don't hit mafia, maybe we at least focus the game a bit by taking out someone that is creating noise in our data collection. (sorry that was the scientist coming out).
I vote to lynch Grins.
Sorry for the long post, but I'm making up for three days of not posting here.
On Day 1 of Day 1 you asked when the game started... after it had. Now you think Day 2 has started? Are you playing the same game as the rest of us? I would accuse you of skimming but that would require that you at least read 1 post. Maybe you could go watch My Little Pony now...
I have sat here for ten minutes trying to decide who should get my vote. Should I make it a tie since Z voted for Grins? Should I put my vote back on Mal since I hae felt very uncomfortable taking it off? so Many possibilities yet the actual chance of getting a Mafia slim.
