Mafia #23 Revenge

LesbianChap said:
eh, why not tie it up in case the internet goes out tomorrow.
I vote to lynch the elmo punk
Click to expand...

Oh, and voting cause he's the least interesting mafia-suspect out there. At least the others are posting and amusing me...even Blue'z made me smirk. Oh, and to tie it up. Happy?
 
Madcrawdad said:
Ice, a couple of things about your list... now you're saying that I haven't latched onto anyone. Yesterday you accused me of helping railroad Grins, and tying you to her. So which is it? If anyone is riding the wind, it's you, old boy with your major vote hopping yesterday. Your relationship with Grins is really bizarre for Day 1, and regardless of Grins' status, your actions look really scummy.

Also, I noticed that you've got Clown at a 4 now. Fine. Yesterday you had him as my partner in crime helping deflect attention from your Mal/Judge dynamic duo. Apparently he's changed your mind, but going from a 7-7.5 on him to a 4 is quite a quick turnaround, don't you think? Especially with his late pull of of Grins.
Click to expand...

My vote hopping was between 2 players I thought mafia, why sit on the one not going to be lynched when my vote could be the difference maker?

As for your description yeah I messed up on it. There was so much reading and interruptions from my son I lost my train of thought. What I meant was that you usually cast a wider net then just 2 players. That you usually latch into more players.

Clown dropped when I saw that Mal was in fact innocent. So that blew the sister team idea out of the water. His posts have been more helpful and he has looked into many other players where you haven't been.

I probably should have dropped you down to a 6 or 7 but I have a gut feeling,which could be clouding my judgment of you, but with you my gut is usually right. In the pirates game my gut said to hit you that if you were pirate you'd be the one switched to Capt. I didn't because I didn't want to lose a good townie. From then on I decided to follow my gut with you.

Madcrawdad said:
Ice you said you thought Mal was the Don, as you figure she would have chosen Judge and not the other way around. If my memory serves me correctly, it was Mal's seeming protection of Judge that got her lynched. Now if Mal were the Don, wouldn't you have expected Judge to protect Mal, and not the other way around?
Click to expand...

If Mal was experienced yeah I'd think that. But with her being a newer player and not that good yet I think she didn't want to lose a team mate. The more she tried to protect the more JM tried to push away, well that was the thought last night. I think JM also thought Mal might be mafia and if she was going down didn't want to be attached to her.


ILOVEBETTAS said:
I unvote JM and I am voting for no one now.

Modify: Now CL's telling me I'm dead, so whatever...
Click to expand...

Best AD post to date.

Grins said:
Again, since I haven't seen Bob give this kinds of clue about color before it isn't something I'm quite ready to buy yet. Maybe if more people confirm they've seen this sort of clue before I would but for now I'm not wanting to put too much stock in it.




Why not your own name I wonder. :lipssealedsmilie: Sincerely if the majority of the town wants to break it down to 3 and tying it I'm not completely against that provided no one feels bullied. My own typos and silliness from feeling crappy or not put me and the town in the spot we're in and I'm willing to take any heat on me. However, I don't like you picking the 3 people and think the town should. Seems the fair thing would be to take an informal poll and have everyone submit their top 3 suspects, and the 3 names that get picked the most should be the 3 that a tie is tried to be made on. And yes I fully realize that if the poll were to be made at this second I may well end up on it.
Click to expand...

The color thing was just something to watch. I actually have LG as one of the most innocent of the bunch.

As for why I put your name out there its because most everyone has you on their list anyway. I was suggesting I wasn't telling anyone who should vote where. Any other 3 suspects work also. Blue isn't in my top 3 suspects but I threw her name out there just to see what others thought. I'd be happy with emo or lc as long as they are players that others think mafia.
 
clown-lover said:
Blue I'm not trying to start anything on you other than doing my job as a player in this game and pointing out that you really haven't done anything productive in this game. In my daily post of all players all I asked was to see more help out of you. Thats all I asked. To me if you aren't helping the town then I'm sorry you seem mafia and most of the rest of the players. And you know what its not the quantity of the posts that is a tell on whether you look scummy or not its the quality and right now you have neither in my book.

If you hang yourself its going to be by your own accord with the rope in your own hand. Quit trying your lack of game play or how you are viewed on everyone else. It is our job as townies to rid the town of mafia. That is the purpose of the game. To do that players need to be engaged and posting. If your not posting in my eyes your either mafia or a dead weight townie. Which is it blue? Why even join the game if your not going to play? You and the rest of the low posters.. Yes I have made some posts in speculation about what Bob ment.. His "I'm gonna screw with the player" posts can mean many things. That was one I thought of, I never said it was 100% sure, it was a "thought" that I posted. You are the one who came back and basically accussed me of starting a train on you and getting all defensive because I'm doing my job and pointing out things to the rest of the town. Your defensiveness over a couple of posts with no votes is more telling of you and your role in this game than anything else.
Click to expand...


Dead weight townie CL.
 
Grins said:
Fair enough, it was not meant as a slam on your ethics or morals outside of the game. I even have good reason to believe that many don't out and out lie in the game itself. But please do me the favor of answering the original question and telling me why you would not hit her. Why not if she was the best person to hit for your team?

Emo was also told he gave obvious tells that he was mafia last time. Which would explain his decision to hardly say anything at all this time. It doesn't mean that he is mafia, but it sure doesn't mean he isn't. How can you not suspect LC after his own admission that his intention was to screw with our minds? And to not consider Beth or Cool? They have hardly said anything since last night. Again it doesn't mean they are guilty but why does that throw them to innocent?
Click to expand...

Because she is my internet friend, I don't put a game ahead of a friend.

Grins, like I said, I don't always go on what people post, I go on my gut partly. Thats my playing style...ask other people if you feel you have to verify that.

Who said I'm not considering them? If I wasn't considering them they would be a 1. A 4 means I'm thinking they are innocent, but am not sure.

Matt
 
My thoughts on Emo

I think that most people have come to the conclusion that emo will not be joining us much this game. This presents kind of a problem, as if the guy doesn't post, his status can only be guessed at.

I think that at some point, the town will need to address the issue, as based upon his single last-minute vote yesterday he doesn't plan on UDing.

Everyone keep in mind that lynching non-producing newbies has typically not gone in the town's favor, so lynching Emo is risky. But if it's going to be done, earlier is probably the better time to do it just to put an end to the distraction.

I myself would prefer to give him another chance to UD, and if that doesn't work, then deal with him. Thoughts?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom