Mafia #23 Revenge

Cory Lover said:
Because she is my internet friend, I don't put a game ahead of a friend.

Grins, like I said, I don't always go on what people post, I go on my gut partly. Thats my playing style...ask other people if you feel you have to verify that.

Who said I'm not considering them? If I wasn't considering them they would be a 1. A 4 means I'm thinking they are innocent, but am not sure.

Matt
Click to expand...

i have internet friends to, but, alls fair in love and war! :lipssealedsmilie:

and grins, no no hints, sorry to disappoint you!
 
Hooked Newbie said:
I love ya and clown to death, but I don't trust either one of you. Sorry, I'm a bit paranoid in the game. And, I did catch the hint. Doesn't mean that I don't want to see you acknowledge it after CL put it out there. No reason it couldn't be used for evil though is there? I am still getting a different feel from your posts this game. I've said it before and I'll take the heat saying it again, the top players can play without making any glaring "mistakes". Ice and Mad have both berated me for saying that in the past, but it's true and sometimes it does have to come down to a feel.
Click to expand...

Well I'm glad that someone else saw the **** hint and actually it.

But Hooked riddle me this... if I was in a game where I could pick my team mates where would that put you after our success in the vamp game? Just like if I believe Grins is evil then where does that put you after your success in the pirate game? While I won't go as far to say your the best player here as I don't think your ego could stand that kind of inflation, I would go so far to say you'd be one of the top picked players under these circumstances.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Originally Posted by Grins
Hooked, I realize that my first post today was indeed addressing some of what was said in the first game day, but perhaps you missed that I said at the end of it that I would address new thoughts in a separate post. Which I did..about 13 minutes before you posted this.

Actually, your first post was to say that you'd be posting after a review. It took me far more than 13 minutes to type mine, you did post during that time.

It didn't make sense to address it in day one as one of the intended recipents understood it. You were the other one by the way. I thought you'd have remembered when we were considering what roles others might have had when we were a team. I have answered it today however.

I love ya and clown to death, but I don't trust either one of you. Sorry, I'm a bit paranoid in the game. And, I did catch the hint. Doesn't mean that I don't want to see you acknowledge it after CL put it out there. No reason it couldn't be used for evil though is there? I am still getting a different feel from your posts this game. I've said it before and I'll take the heat saying it again, the top players can play without making any glaring "mistakes". Ice and Mad have both berated me for saying that in the past, but it's true and sometimes it does have to come down to a feel.

I agree with your thoughts on Ogre, Bkw, Emo, DD, King and Z.
I cut out the parts not addressed to me.
Click to expand...

You are correct, I forgot I made that post so people wouldn't think I was up to evil things for being here when I was making the 2nd post. However, the post I made 3rd, and included the detailed thoughts...did indeed happen 13 minutes before you called me out on not posting any. I made the detailed post at 5:39 my time, and your post saying I hadn't done so was at 5:52. I might have gotten the post number wrong but not the meaning of what I was saying.

On your second comment, I respect that. But do this for me, don't burn me at the stake for something I could do versus something I've done.

IceH2O said:
As for why I put your name out there its because most everyone has you on their list anyway. I was suggesting I wasn't telling anyone who should vote where. Any other 3 suspects work also. Blue isn't in my top 3 suspects but I threw her name out there just to see what others thought. I'd be happy with emo or lc as long as they are players that others think mafia.
Click to expand...

My problem isn't that you named me, my problem was that you seemed to want to pick the top 3. I'd rather see everyone's top 3 and pick from those.

Cory Lover said:
Because she is my internet friend, I don't put a game ahead of a friend.

Grins, like I said, I don't always go on what people post, I go on my gut partly. Thats my playing style...ask other people if you feel you have to verify that.

Who said I'm not considering them? If I wasn't considering them they would be a 1. A 4 means I'm thinking they are innocent, but am not sure.

Matt
Click to expand...

Matt, you seem like a nice guy so please don't take this as me saying you aren't. But this is a game that we all sign up for and play with friends. I was friends with Clown before playing this game but I'd sure in heck put him up if it was for the better of the town and I'm willing to bet he would do the same. Same goes for Beth. I've become friends with others here as well Hooked over there sure isn't going easy on me and neither is Julz (she is crazy by the way :lipssealedsmilie:). It is a game, putting a hit on someone in the game doens't mean that you aren't their friend outside the game. Why come into it with the pre-concieved notion that you won't play for the good of your team?

You can go on your gut all you want by the way, but how are we supposed to use you as a team member when it is your gut? Sorry but that looks guilty to me as no one can be called out for what they feel in their gut. And I said you're not considering them, at least not fully if you are saying they don't seem mafia to you. How can you say they don't seem mafia after either not posting or doing some of the strange things LC did?

Sorry Cory, I wasn't paying that much attention to you yesterday but with a fresh look on things today you are not looking so innocent to me.
 
IceH2O said:
I probably should have dropped you down to a 6 or 7 but I have a gut feeling,which could be clouding my judgment of you, but with you my gut is usually right. In the pirates game my gut said to hit you that if you were pirate you'd be the one switched to Capt. I didn't because I didn't want to lose a good townie. From then on I decided to follow my gut with you.
Click to expand...

I can understand the gut thing (to an extent)...during the Santa game I had a gut feeling about you that I didn't act on, and I made the same decision regarding you.
 
Madcrawdad said:
I think that most people have come to the conclusion that emo will not be joining us much this game. This presents kind of a problem, as if the guy doesn't post, his status can only be guessed at.

I think that at some point, the town will need to address the issue, as based upon his single last-minute vote yesterday he doesn't plan on UDing.

Everyone keep in mind that lynching non-producing newbies has typically not gone in the town's favor, so lynching Emo is risky. But if it's going to be done, earlier is probably the better time to do it just to put an end to the distraction.

I myself would prefer to give him another chance to UD, and if that doesn't work, then deal with him. Thoughts?
Click to expand...

I almost didn't answer this because I'm thinking your trying to lay a trap and turn this and say why won't you vote someone you think is mafia.. But I did decide to answer for the following reasons.

Honestly Mad I don't have a problem switching my vote to any of my top candidates. But right now I'm just trying to get him to be a contributing member of the town or label him mafia.. As I'm trying to pull out as many of the low posters as I can.

I'll probably not ultimately vote for any of them I think its important to try and seperate the wheat from the chaff. I'll probably put my real vote sometime tomorrow until then I'm going to try my hardest to find out who the mafia are..
 
clown-lover said:
I almost didn't answer this because I'm thinking your trying to lay a trap and turn this and say why won't you vote someone you think is mafia.. But I did decide to answer for the following reasons.

Honestly Mad I don't have a problem switching my vote to any of my top candidates. But right now I'm just trying to get him to be a contributing member of the town or label him mafia.. As I'm trying to pull out as many of the low posters as I can.

I'll probably not ultimately vote for any of them I think its important to try and seperate the wheat from the chaff. I'll probably put my real vote sometime tomorrow until then I'm going to try my hardest to find out who the mafia are..
Click to expand...

Nope...no trap. I don't know what we can do about the guy. If he's innocent and he's not lynched early (while the town still has some numbers), I'm afraid that scum will toss him onto the table late in the game, at a potentially inopportune time for the town, which could really muddy the waters. This guy is the worst lurker ever (with the exception of those who don't post, but end up UDing).

Before I'd vote for him solely based on lurking, though, I'd probably want to see a huge majority of the town in agreement (ie, not just me and 6 mafia members voting off a potential innocent).
 
clown-lover said:
Well I'm glad that someone else saw the **** hint and actually it.

But Hooked riddle me this... if I was in a game where I could pick my team mates where would that put you after our success in the vamp game? Just like if I believe Grins is evil then where does that put you after your success in the pirate game? While I won't go as far to say your the best player here as I don't think your ego could stand that kind of inflation, I would go so far to say you'd be one of the top picked players under these circumstances.
Click to expand...

Well, the vamp game was already sewn up by the time I was turned so thanks I guess. When I signed up, I thought I'd be a good choice too. Should my feelings be hurt that I wasn't? Maybe me not being as active affected choices? Does it matter what I say? Nope. Gonna play what I've been dealt. I have no problem with this. Less stress and I can feel righteous at the same time.

The other common thread in those games is you though. So, riddle me that. Also Grins was equally as successful in the Santa game with Ice correct and weren't you the Lead Vamp?

And there are at least 5 players that are better than me at this game than I am counting you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom