Mafia #23 Revenge

Well I'm taking my self to bed to try and get a good night's sleep. I might not get a chance to be on before noon but if there is a way I will. And I'll certainly be around after that. Hopefully there will be some input from those that others have already called out on fairly empty contributions. Especially as we have 6 mafia to figure out right now. See you guys tomorrow.
 
As for clarification...anything can be possible...unless there is a rule that says it can't happen....

Something has really been bugging me about this all night since BaBobLa posted this... And I would like further clarification..

So Bob, is what your saying with this line is that you could have brought in players as a mafia team or made them mafia members to meet your rule of 1/3 mafia before day 1 nightfall? I didn't see that semi-truck hole in your rules personally and you specifically state there are two teams so does this mean there are really three mafia teams? Or that you added to the two mafia teams?

So then the message of 50/50 would have more relevance as of this point because if you did do this then realistically we could have two teams of 3 mafia and one team of two or even three teams of 3 mafia or 2 teams of 4 mafia as of this point making it 50/50 already or darn close...

Bob if thats the case that would be really screwed up...:mad2:
 
i think i'll get my vote in now, just in case i sleep the day away tomorrow.

it's not set in stone

i vote to lynch grins
 
Well if I had disappointment it was initially in myself as I thought maybe I had possibly helped turn the town against a clear and valuable innocent because of something you said after nightfall:




If anyone left standing last night didn't want to be picked I think we all know who that would be and why I didn't want to point to this post before you answered if you had intentionally left a clue. Had you said yes I'd be trying my damndest to protect your crazy tush right now. But since you didn't...you're on your own.

i love you grins, ..however, ..seriously, i am just so dammed tired of being mafia, ..so its always a refreshing change of pace to be innocent, I really didn't want to be picked, ..i can't help it, ..but thanks, that would have been an awesome catch, ..and now, at least, for future reference, ..I know, i can be extremely subtle, ..and it will be noticed, by someone who cares !
 
Got up for cough drops and had a thought so wanted to share it and I will, but first a few comments:

Something has really been bugging me about this all night since BaBobLa posted this... And I would like further clarification..

So Bob, is what your saying with this line is that you could have brought in players as a mafia team or made them mafia members to meet your rule of 1/3 mafia before day 1 nightfall? I didn't see that semi-truck hole in your rules personally and you specifically state there are two teams so does this mean there are really three mafia teams? Or that you added to the two mafia teams?

So then the message of 50/50 would have more relevance as of this point because if you did do this then realistically we could have two teams of 3 mafia and one team of two or even three teams of 3 mafia or 2 teams of 4 mafia as of this point making it 50/50 already or darn close...

Bob if thats the case that would be really screwed up...:mad2:

Huh? Sorry Clown but I'm not following you.

bala bob seems to like to mes wih our heads


Yes he does, now would you like to contribute a bit to the game please? Frankly I keep forgetting you're even playing it. Emo has posted less than you and has been called out on it but you seem to float in and out with little to say.

No, the hidden message was a lot more obvious in that one.Bala's mean.
Kinda like the hidden message in this message.

Frankly LC, I've grown weary of the all the mind games. You changed your style so as not be a big target and as outrageous as your style is it has worked...and I'm wondering if that isn't what is causing the biggest laugh for you of all.

OK, now my thought I wanted to share. 2 people were chosen last night right? Which 2 people have started to shift their game play since after nightfall? It seems obvious yes but it is something I've neglected to look for and I'd like ideas on it. I'm tninking that the 2 new mafia members are either singing new tunes without reason...or they are sticking on obvious votes from yesterday to be safe. I'd think the obvious votes from yesterday are myself, JM, or even LC to a lesser degree. Obviously there are innocents that still find us suspect and I don't deny that. But some mafia have to be in there too and are probably going to stick to the 3 mentioned in order to blend in. The ones that give little to no reason I'm going to look harder at. But for now the people I most suspect as mafia so you have it :

Blue: The claim that she had never used her mod powers before, which 2 other people have also said they saw or heard about and she has yet to address. Yet she has had time to answer other things, and frankly even when she answered those things I thought she got very defensive. It is also interesting that she only started to post much at all once others were calling out people for not posting much.

LC: I think he is hoping that by acting outrageous we'll not suspect what he is up to. There are a few that have not called him to the carpet for his behavior as well which makes me question him all the more. I'd think if he had no teammates everyone would have blasted his admission that he was only here to screw with our minds. He made a post today that looked helpful yes, but then right back to the same outrageous new style. I think he is hoping we'll overlook him once again and let him slide. In fact, he has pretty much said this is his plan.

JM: I really thought for a bit that she sent us a message after nightfall and I've explained why now. I went back this morning with a clean slate like I said. I tried to look at her posts with the message I thought she was saying in mind, and while it could explain some of the defensiveness I still found it a stretch at times. Now that she has confirmed she didn't send the message I know why it was a stretch. Julz, I think you've been very defensive much like Blue has begun to be. I think that while you of course knew that Mal wasn't on your side you realized she was looking guilty and potentially on the other the mafia team and that is why you distanced yourself from her whenever she'd try to protect you. You had a win win situation. If she was mafia you could say you didn't go after her and if she was innocent you could use it to discredit any thoughts that you were. And I think you're going to probably try to ride her innocent coat tails to sneak by another nightfall.

Cory/Emo/Cool: I don't know if it is age or not but I don't like the sit back and let the others do all the work style that others have already mentioned. Yes this game is supposed to be fun but c'mon guys you're supposed to actually play it.

Emo your pitiful 2 posts after finding out you were obviously guilty to everyone in your first game makes it really appear as if you or your partner don't want you to do the same this game.

Cory, you don't seem to give much in the way of reasonings when you do participate and frankly when you do give reasons I'm not following them. Your gut feelings do nothing for us and if your gut sincerely thinks that posters like Emo that have said barely one word are leaning innocent...well then sorry but I dont' trust that gut very much.

Cool you're the less bothersome of the 3 to me, but like I said before you're seeming like you're intentionally trying to not be the lowest poster but not stick your neck too far out there either. A little more help would be nice.

Beth: She hasn't posted in the thread since Tuesday at 5:35 PM. I have to question that but I also have to point out that she doesn't appear to have posted anywhere on the site since then. I don't feel as suspect about Beth as the ones I've listed before her though.

Maybe I have the 6 mafia members listed in those 7. Maybe not. But chances are I got a few of them correct.
 
i love you grins, ..however, ..seriously, i am just so dammed tired of being mafia, ..so its always a refreshing change of pace to be innocent, I really didn't want to be picked, ..i can't help it, ..but thanks, that would have been an awesome catch, ..and now, at least, for future reference, ..I know, i can be extremely subtle, ..and it will be noticed, by someone who cares !


Hey I'm glad it isn't you. Makes my thoughts on who is mafia much clearer. :silly:
 
Wow, just WOW...what posts!! I have so much to comment on I don't even really know where to start! Like always I start out reading and think oh...I need to quote this, then that, then this...by the time I get through it all I have what would end up being a 2 page post...So, I am going to try and go through this again and quote and post as I go, yes...there are some MAJOR lights flashing in my head right now I could just post about and say....but I really want the posts to go along with it...just know after all this I think my suspect list has changed a bit!!!
 
OK, I am starting w/ Blue

Yes Blue has used Mod powers during the game, she tried when a team mate of mine and I told her it was cheating. She didn't care but I wasn't going to turn in a player on my team lol.
Understandable...I wouldn't "turn in" a team mate either....may keep it in my mind for further reference but not turn on them. Really I do not remember for sure which person said that to me as a team mate....but she sure hasn't commented on your or my statement. This helps seal that post from her though as total BS.
Hmmm...no tunnel vision here clown. If that was the case, why would I bother reading the posts after I cast my vote? Feel free to look at me all you want to, I do expect that.

And yes, you have tickled my brain..;).
How is sitting on one person for one thing not tunnel vision?? Oh, wait he is now suspicious to you...well DUH he posted against you, how could he not be? :headshake2:
ok fist off i was ganna say...Wasn't there a game where some one had left a major hint in an ad post? and weren't pple mad about that? i would think bob would think it would be unfair to do this again...


but then this post came up again so now i don't kno, he did use blue, and orange...
Now, I included this post for a reason....notice he and Blue are posting about the same time....obviously it is referencing me. Now if he had ever played w/ me before, or was playing anytime around that game...I may of thought not so much of it...but am I really to believe someone who hasn't been in the game is going to think of a game from like 2 months ago??? No, I just don't buy it, someone has told him this, was it Blue..not sure, but he is "recalling" a game that was about 2 months ago...my first innocent PR as the DR. Pap and I fooled everyone making them think I was the detective and protected by the DR. we were getting Mafia lynched well with this method, then I did get hit, with my AD post I wrote it in Blue an said how I looked up to the "blue" sky before closing me eyes forever, or something on those lines...well it was obvious Blue was our last investigation together. And she did end up lynched...believe me I felt the wrath from every player for that. Anyway, I just find it very hard to believe he just "knew" this. Now IMO, Blue may not be the one who said this the only other one I could see it coming from would be Clown...he was amazed apparently that I had pegged him as mafia that game, and the next game I played with him he really tried head games with me...this is where our "non trust" issues of each other in these games came from. I have no idea at this point which I think said this to Cool dude...but I am almost positive it was either Blue or Clown.
If I am voted to be lynched, please let it be for somethng that is more sunstantial than color codings.

Anyone following this train of thought is suspcious to me.
Actually Blue you should say anyone looking at you is suspicious...at least that seems to be your trend, this game and most other games.

My play style is no secret clown, how about finding something substantial regarding me and posting it.

Oh....wait a minute, Im sure you would love to lynch another innocent. :lipssealedsmilie:

This is what, the fourth time you have mentioned my posting? Trying to get a train started and no one is jumping on?
Oh, I think you yourself are the conductor of your "train" Blue...isn't a persons posting the reason they get looked at in the first place...also I can recall several times you saying these same things (almost to the word I bet) when you have been evil. No, your "style" is no secret...it seems you lay low, until called out, then say anyone looking your way is of interest to you.
You are saying you already know what I am?? Then why isnt your vote on me? Seeing how its not, I guess you really arent as sure of yourself as you are trying to sound.

I say this every game, I ost my thoughts as I have them. Sorry if that isnt good enough. Rest assured you wont have to worry about it after this game.
So, besides calling ppl out that have mentioned you..where are your thoughts Blue?? I too am going to ask, what is that suppose to mean, I see no answer from you...OH would that require a actual thought???
So, tell me. If i post trying to help the town, it looks scummy, if i post defending myself, it looks scummy, if i dont post at all, it looks scummy. So, either way I look scummy. It depends on who you are as to what you can post.
The thing is you haven't posted to help the town...well except to say Grins edited a post...to which when questioned about by Grins you said would require "mod powers" and you don't do that in these games right.
To add to my above post. Im not changing my play style, its how I play. At least I am posting, unlike some others on the list, and actually paying attention to the game.
Yep, you are posting, mainly to "defend" yourself...still waiting on some real thoughts though...I think the only thing you pay attention to is if someone has said you look suspicious..
Put your vote where your words are..;)
OUCH...touchy are we???
Dead weight townie CL.
So you admit you do nothing to help the town..right?
 
AquariaCentral.com