Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game

[Rbishop]

Well, since you are in that frame of mind....I am * * * * * * * that completely unidentified things are out into play and we don't know the rules.

'Nuff said.

 

[IceH2O]

So the communicating innocents would not have to reveal themselves in any, way, shape or form. If someone questioned me on how I knew LG is a stalker or assumed I'd gotten the investigation because of being on the team, I did not want to have the team having to defend me or take the chance they would not believe me. Basically I felt honesty is the best policy. Perhaps it was too much info, but I tend to get a bit excited when I get to have an investigation and it ends up a good one and even thought I try to be very careful and plan out all the potential scenarios, I am human and do not manage to think of all the angles.

I wanted to figure out what LG was because I figured it would help figure out you and Jensons (and it looked like Jensons was getting lynched anyhow)...I still believe that my theory was right, LG was trying to latch onto Ice because he's such a high profile player. I seriously doubt she'd follow his votes if both are stalkers.

I'm going out on a limb here but the more I think about my scenario about Sway and what LG said it makes more sense.

Sway here you say that you chose to investigate LG because Jensons looked like she was about to be lynched. When did you send in your investigation?

Jenson only had 6 votes on her out of a possible 16 when you came out against LG, only 12 of the 16 had been cast. The other votes were on Ice(1) Beth(2) LG(1) Bkw(1) Enya(1) JM(1).

I'd like to ask the players. IF Sway hadn't come out against LG who would your votes actually have fell on?


I'm starting to think the 3 remaining are Sway Bkw and Plantling. Bkw did have a post where he pushed the point that Sway and Plantling are pretty much known innocents to him.

 

[IceH2O]

This is very good.

How would my vote on Jmax influence this?

If everyone had jumped to LG and your vote had stayed on JM since you weren't around then the 2nd highest vote getter would have been JM with 1 vote.Not implicating you at all.

It doesn't add up Ice..too many coincidences...I think juggling was involved due to the UD of two stalkers...

Possible

Rb...are you really that upset? Are you admitting to being a stalker???!!!:lipssealedsmilie:

I also find it strange that you'd be upset that the Stalkers hit was wasted. I hate that Jensons was taken out but by the same token instead of losing 2 possible innocents we only lost 1.

Now you make me have to reshuffle my list. I guess you could take Plantlings place. I wasn't real sure about her being a stalker anyway.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I am looking into HN's posts, basicly after Lady G's list. Found this quote. Look at the second and third lines of his list. It is either Rb OR Judgemax or it is either Judgemax OR Rb. That does not make any sense at all.

I also see that HN has been on judgemax, so I do not think they could both be stalkers.

Maybe for his third line he meant "Judgemax OR Hn and it was just a typo.

No, I didn't. Thanks for trying to speak for me though. At that time (and now) I'm pretty sure that JM AND Rb are stalkers. I keep waffling between Rb, Bk, and Ice (to a lesser extent) though. I think ONE of that group is a stalker.

This post bothered me when I first saw it, but I let it slide. I thought you were implying you were the doctor.

I seem to be the one that forces the issue at times and did not think it would be good for the town to bring out the doctor at that time. Now I know that you are not the doctor. I also know that others could have thought of your post the same way. This is almost asking to get hit, but the stalkers hit Jensons, who was the doctor. Odd that you were not investigated or hit.

So why did you hope they don't investigate you? We only have one doctor. I think now is a good time to explain.

I have explained, but I will again... as I responded to you (the first time you asked) in morse code. I yield nothing. Yes, I invited an investigation from the Stalkers. Why wouldn't anyone that wasn't a power role?

You seem to be suddenly trying to get something rolling on JM's behalf. Is that just me? I think I need to add you to the above group and may have been mixing you up with bkw.

 

[Rbishop]

I retract my vote on Lady G and vote to toss Ice into the zone..

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm going out on a limb here but the more I think about my scenario about Sway and what LG said it makes more sense.

Sway here you say that you chose to investigate LG because Jensons looked like she was about to be lynched. When did you send in your investigation?

Jenson only had 6 votes on her out of a possible 16 when you came out against LG, only 12 of the 16 had been cast. The other votes were on Ice(1) Beth(2) LG(1) Bkw(1) Enya(1) JM(1).

I'd like to ask the players. IF Sway hadn't come out against LG who would your votes actually have fell on?


I'm starting to think the 3 remaining are Sway Bkw and Plantling. Bkw did have a post where he pushed the point that Sway and Plantling are pretty much known innocents to him.

I felt good about my vote on JM, but honestly no one seemed interested and I may have moved to Jensons. I saw the case being made, but didn't really get an evil feel from her myself and I don't like the one off safe votes.

 

[IceH2O]

No, I didn't. Thanks for trying to speak for me though. At that time (and now) I'm pretty sure that JM AND Rb are stalkers. I keep waffling between Rb, Bk, and Ice (to a lesser extent) though. I think ONE of that group is a stalker.



I have explained, but I will again... as I responded to you (the first time you asked) in morse code. I yield nothing. Yes, I invited an investigation from the Stalkers. Why wouldn't anyone that wasn't a power role?

You seem to be suddenly trying to get something rolling on JM's behalf. Is that just me? I think I need to add you to the above group and may have been mixing you up with bkw.

Actually you said you hope you WEREN"T investigated.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Actually you said you hope you WEREN"T investigated.

And that wouldn't invite you to investigate me if you were scum?

 

[IceH2O]

I guess thinking about it 1st thought was then and probably holds true tonight was that by asking to not be investigated then someone would investigate you.

 

[bkw1982]

i vote to toss LG into the zone

im off to class and will post after i get back