Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game
- Thread starter ZSandmann
- Start date
Sounds good Z...
Regarding Ice's comments on Beth/Lg:
Beth did vote Lg early and after swayde came out with the investigation result it would have been very scummy for her to switch.But at the same time Jensons had a nice train going as well, yet Beth put out the Lady G vote. When Beth came back asking if she was still alive, Lg put some heavy pressure on her. Lady G is an aggressive player but not so much when scum as you can see with this game. I don't think they would have risked that much distancing when Beth was already looking pretty suspicious to quite a few people at the time because of her lack of imput. I would be very suprised if Beth turned out stalker as well.
Regarding Ice's comments on Beth/Lg:
Beth did vote Lg early and after swayde came out with the investigation result it would have been very scummy for her to switch.But at the same time Jensons had a nice train going as well, yet Beth put out the Lady G vote. When Beth came back asking if she was still alive, Lg put some heavy pressure on her. Lady G is an aggressive player but not so much when scum as you can see with this game. I don't think they would have risked that much distancing when Beth was already looking pretty suspicious to quite a few people at the time because of her lack of imput. I would be very suprised if Beth turned out stalker as well.
So is this how its going to be for the next 24 hours? At least start working on your suspects case for when I'm found innocent. Don't waste the next 24 hours.
I've been spending some time reading the 1st days events. Especially the role play. With knowing LG Grace and Coler were mafia and actually have posts to read you can see Ogres name thrown around a lot.
Coler was pretty protective of Ogre while bashing Cory.
LG flipped back and forth on him. She said something about me and RB should work together and we might figure something out.
Ogre says he thinks me and RB are innocents.I believe twice in fact.I vote Ogre on a slip and he OMGUS votes me.
So I'm figuring Ogre is a stalker and RB and Cory are for sure clear.
At this point I think Ogre and JM are both stalkers.
I've been spending some time reading the 1st days events. Especially the role play. With knowing LG Grace and Coler were mafia and actually have posts to read you can see Ogres name thrown around a lot.
Coler was pretty protective of Ogre while bashing Cory.
LG flipped back and forth on him. She said something about me and RB should work together and we might figure something out.
Ogre says he thinks me and RB are innocents.I believe twice in fact.I vote Ogre on a slip and he OMGUS votes me.
So I'm figuring Ogre is a stalker and RB and Cory are for sure clear.
At this point I think Ogre and JM are both stalkers.
Yeah re reading the 1st days events I came to a different conclusion also. I'm just trying to put out as many scenarios as possible. The more put out and squashed the easier it will be to narrow the field. Might even force a stalker into slipping.
You guys being quiet isn't helping the town.You're all giving the Stalkers time to get a plan together. You need to keep the pressure on them.
Still sticking with this "list"...so in summary:
Jmax- already made a case, nothing has changed because nothing has really come from her lately
Rb- outburst still bothers me. I know others think he is innocent but my gut says stalker
Bkw- as stated above. I think that most likely either Ice or Bkw is a stalker. Its not like the feuds that get heated and then simmer down between two innocents. Its been almost constant nit-picking at some times.
Then I would go...
Ogre- not in the clear and hasnt helped at all since the decoded messages...again, hes sliding through
Hn- playing similarily to Ogre, not a lot of useful stuff coming from him. RL gets in the way but some of his posts are just odd...for someone so good and experienced at this game how likely is it for him to make those little "mistakes" as an innocent? Maybe just an off game or a stalker who hasnt been paying much attention and is just sliding through under the radar...
One thing about Jmax that I just noticed.
She boldly states early on that Ogre is innocent in her opinion because of his tone.
Then going back through the posts I see that she hints at her suspicion, well mostly confusion, about why Ogre was saved.
Now I understand the caution but it seems odd that she turned it around so much.
After not having any suspects for a while she lists Lady G (obvious), Ice (after "pointing out" Jensons as Doc), and Ogre is the "iffy" third suspect and hasn't changed since then if I read every thing correctly.
Right now I am having some second thoughts on Ice and feel I may have rushed into the vote. After Jmax showed Ice "figuring out" Jensons I found it odd that Ice of all people would point it out, I think Jmax even said something to that effect herself. I mean, why would he risk putting himself in the spotlight if someone did realize what he was doing rather than keep quiet about it and let someone else catch on and speak up or just place the hit and cause mass confusion and finger-pointing? I am less sure about the vote, but at this point it wouldnt do any good to move.
She boldly states early on that Ogre is innocent in her opinion because of his tone.
Then going back through the posts I see that she hints at her suspicion, well mostly confusion, about why Ogre was saved.
Now I understand the caution but it seems odd that she turned it around so much.
After not having any suspects for a while she lists Lady G (obvious), Ice (after "pointing out" Jensons as Doc), and Ogre is the "iffy" third suspect and hasn't changed since then if I read every thing correctly.
Right now I am having some second thoughts on Ice and feel I may have rushed into the vote. After Jmax showed Ice "figuring out" Jensons I found it odd that Ice of all people would point it out, I think Jmax even said something to that effect herself. I mean, why would he risk putting himself in the spotlight if someone did realize what he was doing rather than keep quiet about it and let someone else catch on and speak up or just place the hit and cause mass confusion and finger-pointing? I am less sure about the vote, but at this point it wouldnt do any good to move.
At this point, the only one other than Ice that I'd be ok voting for is Judgemax. If we can get a consensus, I'll move my vote. I'm having some second thoughts about Ice as well, but it's a coin flip between the 2 right now for me. Our suspects seem very similar and we have the numbers right now to leverage by working together.
Jpap- thanks for the compliments (I think) and yes, I have had an "off ganme". I've been admitting it for several days now. Look back on my posts in comparison to your's. I was actually a bit worried about you because you were posting very similar thoughts and I was worried about you being evil and trying to attach yourself (like I did with Ice last game). If you aren't, we're of like mind. To say that I'm playing like Ogre is wrong though. Look at the post counts, the suspect lists, etc. Where's he been? Who are is suspects? And the key question to me... Why did Z save him? I actually thought he might be the Doc until Jensons posted the heal post. When will the docs learn to not hint huh? lol
Jpap- thanks for the compliments (I think) and yes, I have had an "off ganme". I've been admitting it for several days now. Look back on my posts in comparison to your's. I was actually a bit worried about you because you were posting very similar thoughts and I was worried about you being evil and trying to attach yourself (like I did with Ice last game). If you aren't, we're of like mind. To say that I'm playing like Ogre is wrong though. Look at the post counts, the suspect lists, etc. Where's he been? Who are is suspects? And the key question to me... Why did Z save him? I actually thought he might be the Doc until Jensons posted the heal post. When will the docs learn to not hint huh? lol
OK reading further into the day as it ends and the start of Day 2 I'm thinking Ogre might not be a stalker. Him and LG go after one another pretty hard and Ogre even puts her on his list.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I am amazed at the lack of posting.
I really wish Ogre and Beth would at least vote. It would be great if at least one was a stalker.
Part of me wants to switch my vote to judgemax. She will be my vote for the next day.
I really wish Ogre and Beth would at least vote. It would be great if at least one was a stalker.
Part of me wants to switch my vote to judgemax. She will be my vote for the next day.
Reading further into Day 2 I'm starting to feel that the stalker team is JM and Bkw. Tough to tell though as neither has posted much. I'm basically having to go by the thoughts of the people I think are innocent.
