Mafia #28: The Play

judgemax said:
seriously, i am voting ICE, i think he is scum. I voted by mistake on DD. i am not doing it again.
Click to expand...

JM okay we know I am your top suspect.

Who are your other suspects?

Again I ask to show the town in detail how I am hosing them?
 
Swayde said:
It's possible to save your own neck. I really don't trust you at this point. I am not as sure of you as I am of RB, which is why my vote is on RB and not you. Unfortunately you haven't been very helpful and I am not sure what to make of the sudden change of heart. Your list is completely different today from what it was yesterday, which I can understand with the hectic nightfall we had last night, but I am just not ready to trust you. You are last on my list, so you have some time to prove yourself. But if I had to vote for 4 mafia right now at this time I'd choose RB, JM, ZS and CS. I hope that if you are a good guy you can show it and understand my hesitancy to believe you.
Click to expand...


I agree with this entire post. As I mentioned earlier Charlie you've dug yourself a deep hole and its going to take more then a list matching mine to sell me.


ZSandmann said:
Yes I had a bad list. But we haven't lynched any Mafia yet as a town. You went after HN on Day 1 and he was Innocent and I didn't rub it in your face as I believed you were Innocent, and I did all the way through last Night. Now with the sudden crowd of people yelling for my head I have to drasticly rethink my entire list. Last Night was telling, but what did it tell us? I see you as the puppet master now Ice. I'm not voting Rb again because you want him lynched so badly. I also do not think JM is showing any signs of Mafiosity.



This is like the third time you've mentioned the Vig. I'm hoping that they have a cooler head and have a better list of suspects than yourself.

I vote to lynch Ice.
Click to expand...


Of course I want the Vig to take the hit. The innocent numbers are falling fast and you have a better chance of hitting them before they get their shot off. If we can nail 2 of you before you get the Vig we'll be a much better position.

OMG on Day 1 I suspected LOL of being mafia,I suspected everyone of being mafia. Who didn't? I suspected but it wasn't a strong enough feeling to lay a vote on her,like you did. She defenitley wasn't a strong enough candidate to vote last night with RB and JM the leading vote getters.

I'm fine with it being between me and RB, either way the innocents will see the truth. Only downside is if the Vig,yep said it again, doesn't take their shot and I'm lynched the mafia will win 3-4.If the Vig successfully hits a Mafia then we still have a 3-3 tie if I'm lynched. If the innocents see the truth already and the Vig hits mafia we are in control 4-2.
 
Your logic relies on too many what ifs Ice. Of all the people that are now dead and shown Innocent you only addressed LOL, the easiest one to explain away. No mention of DD or HN or even MM. The Vig may very well need to take a shot for us to stand a chance at turning this around, but I leave it to them to pick their target. The Innocents that remain need to stay together, we have had far too many candidates in the running the past Nights.
 
Ok, Ice I am going to vote RB I do believe we should of went after Jmax but I wont be here tonight so I don't want to waist a vote.....if he DOES come back Innocent, please realize you will shift to my top suspect....I know you don't control who votes what but you are pushing very hard to his lynching, although with the way votes shifted last night if does make it look as though you are correct.

I vote to lynch RB

Vig...I have to agree with Ice, THIS is the night you need to take your shot...we NEED to get the mafia NOW!!! Please chose wisely.
 
Well, guys was hoping there would be more before I had to go to work...but it looks like I will have to go without any more discussion. I will be back on after work......
 
ZSandmann said:
Your logic relies on too many what ifs Ice. Of all the people that are now dead and shown Innocent you only addressed LOL, the easiest one to explain away. No mention of DD or HN or even MM. The Vig may very well need to take a shot for us to stand a chance at turning this around, but I leave it to them to pick their target. The Innocents that remain need to stay together, we have had far too many candidates in the running the past Nights.
Click to expand...

What can I say about MM? I'll have to go back but I don't think I pushed her at all. I actually think all I really did was ask for answers to my questions.

HN, yeah we went back and forth on Day 1, we always do. I never put a vote on him either though he did me. I felt that he was innocent though because I can't see a vet chasing me down that early if they were mafia.

DD, what do you want me to say that I haven't already addressed? I think my case against her is pretty evident in the thread. Miscommunication led to her being lynched.

Keep trying Z. I know I paint a target on myself every game because I DO go after people. I just can't sit back and reap the benefits of others work or hide in the background so if I'm wrong I don't get looked at.

I play out in the open, if I think I have something I go balls to the wall to get it. Sometimes I'm way off base,especially on Day 1s.Eventually though if I'm around long enough I can usually put all the pieces together.

You're just upset that you telegraphed yourself. You tried to get to cute with your vote.Whats funny is that if you had waited just a couple of more minutes you wouldn't even be in the situation you are. You'd be looked at but that swapping around sealed the deal for sure.
 
Charlie, question about post 493. Its hard to see because the colors are so similar but are you saying you guys are going to hit me tonight?

Or are you implying that if I'm not hit I'm not innocent?

I can tell you I'm most likely not going to be hit, the one problem with talking about the Vig is that they can assume I'm not him and try to take out the others hoping to hit them. I believe thats why JL was hit last night.

But you know how I think sometimes. I actually could be the Vig and using that thought process to help buy time to be more sure of my shot. Guess we'll find out at games end.

I can see the mafia huddling up now, wtf is he the vig or not, do we hit him or not.What should we do huh huh huh.....
 
Ice the whole reason you pulled that was just to try and save your butt by claiming you are the vigilante...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom