I think I am caught up. These are my thoughts and questions mixed together
Knowns
Plant: Bio Engineer
Grins: Bio Engineer
Ogre: Innocent, you aren't Harpo are you? I think an investigation on Harpo would show him innocent but give the role.
-----------------------
Unknowns
Hook: Are you willing to vote Ice? Are you Harpo? And psst if you are using a clue hoping I'll take it..and I do and you're using it against me, I'll not believe another clue again.
Ice: Are you willing to vote Hook? Are you Harpo?
CL: Are you Harpo? Why did you have a feeling Plant and I were the BEs?
Cat: Does the crow blacktop howl moon midnight peterpan? Oh yeah, meant to also ask...why have you been so willing to dismiss that Ice and Hook are mafia all along and also quick to follow Ice's thought of me not being mafia in the thread when at the time you were positive I was Dr. Gene?
Zig: So you're not Harpo correct?
All Unkowns: Do you think the game started with 3, 4, or __ evils? Who do you think they were? Who do you think a serum switched and why? Why do you think Cat has changed posting styles and begun to name people he previously showed trust in? What is the probability of a mist occuring during nightfall on night3 and causing the revived player to be mafia before they've even contributed in the thread?
------------------------
Night 3 Vote
JM, JPap, John, ZSand: Whichever of you has the vote night 3, I think Plant is right and 2 innocents were probably up for the vote both nights. Help us get revenge on the guys that must have been having laughing up a storm at our early bumbling.
I am not ready to vote right now. There is no reason to rush a vote. Part of the decision in coming out when we did was in that it would allow more open discussion in the thread by some. We need to hear from our unknowns. The innocents in the unknown will have all the reason in the world to share thoughts of substance, Harpo can announce themself (although not give details of deeds). The mafia on the other hand may choose to be wishy washy about thoughts on the unknowns because they'll be trying to protect their team as well.
So in my opinion the best thing for the town right now is for the unknowns to give us more to work on.