Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] RICKETS]

Well, honestly, I didn't feel that way, because i wasn't there watching as the posts fell. I sat and refreshed and watched this conversation form. This was very creepy, and the timing and tone just screams collaboration to me.
FOR THE RECORD: looks to me like your trying to defer even more attention from yourself with the last part of that paragraph. Why so defensive?...

Im sorry! If you see that as defensive i didnt mean for it to come across that way im just trying to bring out a point to get to the bottom of this. Why if i was mafia would i try and turn the attention onto three different people. If i was mafia wouldnt i try for one person and ride them into the ground. Now if you look back you can see where my opinion changes with the development of information. I really think that it was just a fluke of luck we started to get to the same conclusion at the same time and we happened to work it out together. Once again im sorry if you saw it as defensive i really wasnt trying to be that way

 

[[AC] Driver8]

Well, honestly, I didn't feel that way, because i wasn't there watching as the posts fell. I sat and refreshed and watched this conversation form. This was very creepy, and the timing and tone just screams collaboration to me.
FOR THE RECORD: looks to me like your trying to defer even more attention from yourself with the last part of that paragraph. Why so defensive?...

Now if they were able to chat elsewhere...why do you think they would do it on here? Does that not sound a little, well not so smart? Really do you think that if they were mafia..and maybe they are, they would say "Hey I know what we should do...lets go on the game and say the same things"? I believe it was more you made that post while they were both on, and I'm sorry I have to agree...the post does not make alot of since. They both read it and commented at the same time IMO.

Has he had alot of attention to defer from? You were talking to Ricket right? I just really haven't seen much toward him to say he is trying to "defer" attention from himself?

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Right now I don't trust anyone as far as I can throw that pig of yours, Dooms. Do you have anything else to add about all the other players?

I am taking my time formulating opinions, and just trying to call what I see as odd. I find this extremely difficult not knowing who is who. It is always easier for me to judge the players based on play style verses actual words. I do have some opinions, but not enough I am afraid to give a list. Although if you have any one person in particular you would like my opinion on, I will gladly give it.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Now if they were able to chat elsewhere...why do you think they would do it on here? Does that not sound a little, well not so smart? Really do you think that if they were mafia..and maybe they are, they would say "Hey I know what we should do...lets go on the game and say the same things"? I believe it was more you made that post while they were both on, and I'm sorry I have to agree...the post does not make alot of since. They both read it and commented at the same time IMO.

Has he had alot of attention to defer from? You were talking to Ricket right? I just really haven't seen much toward him to say he is trying to "defer" attention from himself?

First question driver:

1) why are you defending them?.esp when my vote is already on you? Doesn't make much sense to me. Are you now the sacrificial lamb?

2) I was saying they were orchestrating their comments in order to have other people feel they ( magically) came to that conclusion. I know when i was mafia, several times, we conversed in our chat, as to what to say. So it looked like we were just "saying" .

He is diverting pretty well, Personally, if you were here, and watched how long between posts, and read them, you would understand. It was quite creepy.

I can just imagine how it played out( for those that have been in a mafia den, you know what i am implying).

 

[[AC] Driver8]

Good Luck! I'm sorry you're going thru all that now. Perhaps I have been wrong about you and if I have been then I'm sorry I've misunderstood you. I'm gonna need to review the thread a bit more and perhaps look more into the others on my list.


So why are you voting Mael if you think the mafia killed O3T to make Mael look bad???

Thanks for the luck wish! I went down and talked to them but you have to have 1yr. experience, and well I don't so I wont be getting that one.

good thoery but the reason i used it was because i couldnt find anything that fit the name hi iq when i googled. only one was a mensa logo and that seemed lame. i already had this one on my computer and it represented brains over braun to me. to each their own though. i do find it kinda weird that with eberything thats gone on the best info you have to vote with is my avatar.

as for my vote, driver accused me of contradicting myself and never responded to me when i asked her to show me. i think shes glossing over a false accussation.

i retract my vote to lynch wing nut and vote to lynch driver 8

Nope no "false accusation here...here are a few things I am talking about...

i feel abit better about chongo after that last post. that puts driver and wingnut at the top of my list because i dont think theyd (driver & uhoh) go after each other if they were team mates. i dont want to make it one sidedd so i vote to lnch wing nut.

So if you do think I'm mafia...why pick wing nut, if you are so confident about me why would you NOT want it one sided? Isn't that kinda be the point, to vote off the ones you see as most scummy?

ok, while i have a few mnutes i'll post my thougts on every1. A is innocent B is looking innocent C is even d is looking evil F is evil to me.

haggis- B. few posts but they seem to be helpful.
c-note- b. their posts seem to connect some dots for me.
doomsday- D. nothing really to go by
driver8- d-. i dont care who they are but they seem to be defensive unless theyre instigating poeple.
gun- D, i get a weird feeling from the posts.
hammerhead- C+. not sure here. i like thei post style but i'm afraid of believing them for soe reason.
maelstrom- C, i need to relook at their posts in context of last night.
narwhal- D. im not at all comfortable with them right now
rickets- B-. same as hh.
tib- b-. keeps going from b to d back and forth for me
tree- c. was a b but im nervous of the repeatd claims of inncent
uhoh- F. probably where my vote will land unless something changes my mind on them or someone else.
wingnut- D-. i wish they had more to say. i do understand being busy but still.

Yes, you posted a list which is great...but my lord could you of made it any more confusing?

i was refferring to the post above from 3toes. I didnt mean to, but looking at it afterwards i did kinda reword his wording in my reply.

i need to read todays posts again. everyone looks guilty somewhere and i need to get a good vote in before tmw since i have to work after class. someone want to help me out and just admit to guilt? pleeze...

This is the second time you "miss worded things"

sorry, missed this the first time i read thru the posts. please show me where i "played the noob card" or said that i am new. i've played before, but not as much as most people and not for awhile.

right now, i'm going back and forth on wether to vote nemesis or wing nut. now i have to add you to my possible list for making things up.

Here is another "miss worded one for you. I didn't make it up and actually the quote I was referring to was in my question...here is the post I questioned you about.

that's pretty rude nemesis. why play if it boresyou?

from what I read of the other games questioning people that didn't state an opinion and posted just to post seemed to be how to find out people 3toes. maybe i should watch and read more.

But it was just "miss worded" like the other post.

Although these are not in themselves big deals...putting them together paints another picture, I do think others look more scummy and is why I just had you as looking Mafia and not in my top picks.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

I am taking my time formulating opinions, and just trying to call what I see as odd. I find this extremely difficult not knowing who is who. It is always easier for me to judge the players based on play style verses actual words. I do have some opinions, but not enough I am afraid to give a list. Although if you have any one person in particular you would like my opinion on, I will gladly give it.

Please do not keep your opinions on people to yourself. We need all of us working together to snuff out the mafia. I would absolutely love to see everyone give their thoughts on everyone else. It is helpful to see who's got similar thoughts on people to try and figure out who's on the same side.

It is harder to read people, which makes all the more important for everyone to post as much as they can to get the information flowing. Plus you may have spotted something the rest of us have over looked.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Driver, please stop skimming, rickets tried to insinuate I was mafia after that comment was made. read the last part of the paragraph as i had stated in my comment .

 

[[AC] Driver8]

First question driver:

1) why are you defending them?.esp when my vote is already on you? Doesn't make much sense to me. Are you now the sacrificial lamb?

2) I was saying they were orchestrating their comments in order to have other people feel they ( magically) came to that conclusion. I know when i was mafia, several times, we conversed in our chat, as to what to say. So it looked like we were just "saying" .

He is diverting pretty well, Personally, if you were here, and watched how long between posts, and read them, you would understand. It was quite creepy.

I can just imagine how it played out( for those that have been in a mafia den, you know what i am implying).

1) I just said it as I saw it, not defending..just adding my opinion there. You know as many games as I have played I really can't recall one where there was actually a "sacrificial lamb" everyone talks about it...but I don't really ever remember seeing one.
2)I'm sure it was "creepy" for you as they were discussing you out in the open. I have been on teams also...but never on one where we told each other what to say, so maybe...but I don't think so, I will go back and see the time line of their postings though.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

First question driver:

1) why are you defending them?.esp when my vote is already on you? Doesn't make much sense to me. Are you now the sacrificial lamb?

2) I was saying they were orchestrating their comments in order to have other people feel they ( magically) came to that conclusion. I know when i was mafia, several times, we conversed in our chat, as to what to say. So it looked like we were just "saying" .

He is diverting pretty well, Personally, if you were here, and watched how long between posts, and read them, you would understand. It was quite creepy.

I can just imagine how it played out( for those that have been in a mafia den, you know what i am implying).

All of the mafia teams I've been on have pretty much just done their own thing and only really chat to decide on who to hit and investigate. I've never been on a team that actually worked on real plans and made up conversations and really worked together as a team and it always worked out pretty good. I always hear people mention all these well laid plans and traps and mafia set ups and psychological warfare and stuff, but it never seems to actually happen. It always seems to me, that everyone just tries to look as normal as possible and react to whatever happens and hope they can last until the end.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Oh no Driver and I posted something similar within 2 minutes of each other...we must be in chat coordinating our posting efforts!