Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] Driver8]

*coffithinkLadyGisDwarfPuffersahem*

LMAO!!!

Wow, lots of people calling each other out here...things to note: are they trying to distance each other, is one mafia the other innocent? Now, I know we always say it is a mafia move but in the end the mafia has never done it (calling each other out on a day one)...wouldn't this be a great game to try it out in.

 

[[AC] Driver8]

I offer you no reason why you shouldn't think I'm rude.

I can offer you no reason at this early stage of the game as to why you shouldn't think I'm mafia either. Except to say it is statistically unlikely if that is any comfort.

For your own sake, a thought process which leads to asking someone who you think is a rude mafia person 'give me a reason why you are not mafia or rude' is flawed.

Just one question here....why would it be statistically UNlikely for you NOT to be Mafia?

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

That is a very fair and clever point. Please read my post as if it only had one possible (innocent) interpretation.

 

[[AC] Driver8]

That is a very fair and clever point. Please read my post as if it only had one possible (innocent) interpretation.

So I am to beleive you are innocent because you are saying you are not giving a reason not to think you are rude....or a reason not to think you are mafia...but it is statistically unlikely you are...why because you are thought to be rude?

Sorry to me the post really makes no sense you are talking in circles while trying to be "comforting"

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

I offer you no reason why you shouldn't think I'm rude.

I can offer you no reason at this early stage of the game as to why you shouldn't think I'm mafia either. Except to say it is statistically unlikely if that is any comfort.

For your own sake, a thought process which leads to asking someone who you think is a rude mafia person 'give me a reason why you are not mafia or rude' is flawed.

you are misquoting me which i was just advised is a mafia play. o think your chances of being mafia are higher than the 23.5% of everybody else. you post nothing, i question it, you comeback and call me stupid, i respond, you put words in my mouth. why?

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

you are misquoting me which i was just advised is a mafia play. ?

No, I'm not.

Your choice of words is interesting. 'You were just advised'

Presumably you are referring to this

I didn't say that questioning people wasn't how to play the game. I said, 'your being aggressive'.

Please make sure to quote properly. Misquoting is a mafia play.

So do you need specific advice that deliberately misquoting someone (which would be impossible in a game like this anyway, there is after all a record, perhaps you meant misinterpreting) is evidence of someone being mafia ?

Is your post supposed to show everyone that you are just a poor simple newb who doesn't know anything except what other people tell them ?

Is someone telling you what to say ?

These by the way are rhetorical questions that I'm asking out loud. I don't expect that you will answer them in any unpredictable way.

o think your chances of being mafia are higher than the 23.5% of everybody else. you post nothing, i question it, you comeback and call me stupid, i respond, you put words in my mouth. why?

No, I didn't.

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

I offer you no reason why you shouldn't think I'm rude.

I can offer you no reason at this early stage of the game as to why you shouldn't think I'm mafia either. Except to say it is statistically unlikely if that is any comfort.

For your own sake, a thought process which leads to asking someone who you think is a rude mafia person 'give me a reason why you are not mafia or rude' is flawed.

No, I'm not.

Your choice of words is interesting. 'You were just advised'

Presumably you are referring to this

So do you need specific advice that deliberately misquoting someone (which would be impossible in a game like this anyway, there is after all a record, perhaps you meant misinterpreting) is evidence of someone being mafia ?

Is your post supposed to show everyone that you are just a poor simple newb who doesn't know anything except what other people tell them ?

Is someone telling you what to say ?

These by the way are rhetorical questions that I'm asking out loud. I don't expect that you will answer them in any unpredictable way.



No, I didn't.

you "interpreted" what i said and placed it into quotes = misquoting. no?

no one is telling me anything, nor am i talking to anyone besides you.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

I vote to lynch Doomsday998

The reason is because they have not posted yet and was the first name I came across in the list of players to not post anything yet. I believe the Mafia will try very hard to slip under the radar and be as quiet as possible since it's going to be really hard to read people this round with the anonymous userID's. So this vote is an attempt to get lucky at nailing a lurking mafia, or draw a townie out into the discussion. Nevertheless, it is subject to change since it's still quite early in the game.

 

[[AC] Driver8]

I don't know Tree....I find it hard to believe that with only 4 evils, they would stay that low? I could see them lingering in the middle somewhere...but the low/late posters are usually called out as Mafia, most of the time they are not...yes there are times that they are, but I believe they are not more then they are. Like I said though with only 4 I don't think they are going to be "obvious".

Although I to would like to see some thoughts from Doomsday, I am hoping for no UDs this round!!

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

People who haven't posted:

Doomsday998
Gunslinger
RICKETS
scoop411
Tiburon321
wing nut