Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] RICKETS]

Here is the kicker, "The role of your victim will only be revealed to the Mafia, and not to the town."

So only the mafia knows what Nemesis was. Any assumptions on his role or not is just that, an assumption. If he was mafia, he was the lone mafia. The fact is that the mafia hit him, did it mean anything or was it just to confuse us. Again, all we can do is assume. Whatever he was, he is dead. While I hope he was the lone mafia, assuming that there is one less mafia is dangerous.

OOO I read this a different way see my other prior post.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I am going to watch all those on O3T carefully as I'm sure there is a Mafia in that line-up somewhere. Typically it would be the 3rd voter, a pretty safe spot for Mafia, so I would say Tiburon is most suspect. Also C-Note's vote for O3T is suspect. Gunslinger's vote for C-Note makes him less Mafia to me, but just a tad. Hope to see more thoughts from him, though.

i disagree with this,gunslinger was the last vote of the night. at that time it was 5-3 in favour of old3toes. why not vote for c-note since it made no diffrence and later he can point back to say look i voted c-note earlier.


lots of discussion on if LG is driver and if she is trying to pawn off herself as someone else. I want to lean that driver is mafia but i'm not sure yet. its possible she could be and narwhal isn't.

I think at the moment I vote to lynch c-note

i think we might have let one slip thru our fingers last night

 

[[AC] C-note]

Driver8, you think the whole town is mafia? Then you give hammerhead a 5! What in the world is going on. So now you are going to make up with him.

I retract my vote for wing nut and vote to lynch Driver8

While I think wing nut is a good suspect, I think Driver8 has caused enough confussion.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

Here is the kicker, "The role of your victim will only be revealed to the Mafia, and not to the town."

So only the mafia knows what Nemesis was. Any assumptions on his role or not is just that, an assumption. If he was mafia, he was the lone mafia. The fact is that the mafia hit him, did it mean anything or was it just to confuse us. Again, all we can do is assume. Whatever he was, he is dead. While I hope he was the lone mafia, assuming that there is one less mafia is dangerous.

well crap, it could go either way. nemesis could be innocent or the big city goon.thanks for nothing mad,as if the game wasn't hard enough without not having hit information.

 

[[AC] C-note]

i disagree with this,gunslinger was the last vote of the night. at that time it was 5-3 in favour of old3toes. why not vote for c-note since it made no diffrence and later he can point back to say look i voted c-note earlier.


lots of discussion on if LG is driver and if she is trying to pawn off herself as someone else. I want to lean that driver is mafia but i'm not sure yet. its possible she could be and narwhal isn't.

I think at the moment I vote to lynch c-note

i think we might have let one slip thru our fingers last night

This only true if gunslinger is mafia. Also, remember, Old3Toes wanted the town to rally around his plan to pile votes on 2 (or maybe 3) players to see who was who. Once he started getting votes, he still sat on Tib. Now we know that Old3Toes was the vigilantte and he hit scoop. The only reason I can think he hit scoop is that scoop was voting for him. Old3Toes could have followed his OWN suggestion and placed a vote on me and make it tied up. I still have no clue why he did not vote for me and why in the world he took out our Doctor.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

Originally Posted by [AC] xx_Nemesis_xx
Oh bless.

So, does anyone else see at least a good case to be made of players who are communicating in the posts 101 to present.

come on guys. Too obvious.

players that were posting at this time

c-note
tree
rickets
badhaggis
hammer
doom
old3toes (innocent)
driver
uhoh
hi iq

not posting in that time frame

maelstrom
scoop (innocent)
gunslinger
narwhal
tiburon
wingnut
nemesis till that post.(most likely mafia)

Since i think nem was mafia and they were looking to get something started with that post that its a good chance most of the innocents are in group 1 and the mafia are in group 2. if nemesis was one then there are 3 out of the 7 in the bottom group that have a good chance of being mafia.

if i had to choose 3 from that group it would probably be gunslinger narwhal and not sure on the third.c-note bothers me even tho they are in first group and at this time would probably be my third choice.

Yeah, I wondered about that post from Nemesis, too. A couple of posts later though, he posts this:

Originally Posted by HI IQ
i need to read todays posts again. everyone looks guilty somewhere and i need to get a good vote in before tmw since i have to work after class. someone want to help me out and just admit to guilt? pleeze...

This has nothing to do with me being rude to HI IQ (hah) earlier.

I vote to lynch HI IQ

And then when prodded he answered with this post:

well clearly nothing to do with the quote that I quoted of what HI IQ said already that must be completely unrelated.

I think he was being sarcastic about that quote from HI IQ being completely unrelated to what he was talking about. I think he was trying to say HI IQ's post looks like HI IQ was trying to communicate his thoughts to his fellow Mafia about having to place a vote and needing help maybe?

So I agree that this does make HI IQ lean very innocent, doesn't necessarily clear everyone else. Though I liked your theory 'cause I was on the top list, lol.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

This only true if gunslinger is mafia. Also, remember, Old3Toes wanted the town to rally around his plan to pile votes on 2 (or maybe 3) players to see who was who. Once he started getting votes, he still sat on Tib. Now we know that Old3Toes was the vigilantte and he hit scoop. The only reason I can think he hit scoop is that scoop was voting for him. Old3Toes could have followed his OWN suggestion and placed a vote on me and make it tied up. I still have no clue why he did not vote for me and why in the world he took out our Doctor.

i don't know why it played out that way either.

my post was made with you being mafia in my opinion. i still have almost 24 hours to think diffrent but at this time i am staying.the posts aginst uhoh and your later explanations don't sit well right now.

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

I still have no reasons other than the ones I've already posted in regards to Hammer and Driver. I almost even changed my vote today.... if only hammer and driver hadn't had the same ol' argument over Lady G... neither one would drop it as they accused each other of bringing it up... still, if it is so important, I consider it a diversion... my thoughts and my next tactic is to find just what is going on around the times these driver vs hammer posts are rolling, perhaps they are trying to take the heat off of someone else... for now, my vote remains... At this point, I don't feel convinced that there is enough to move my vote from Driver to vote no one.... plus, that helps us 0 to do that anyway.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I voted for UhOh for posting in a thread about bettas. I think I stated thay you might be Lady G. My reason for voting for UhOh was not very solid and I retracted it. It was more of a vote to get people talking and besides UhOh disappearing, no one really talked about UhOh. So I don't think you remember correctly, good thing you started your statement with an out from the start.

this is the post that bothered me about the earlier vote on Uhoh. how could they have disappeared by post 19 when the vote was placed.or are you trying to say you retracted off uhoh because no one was following you on the vote?

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

i disagree with this,gunslinger was the last vote of the night. at that time it was 5-3 in favour of old3toes. why not vote for c-note since it made no diffrence and later he can point back to say look i voted c-note earlier.


lots of discussion on if LG is driver and if she is trying to pawn off herself as someone else. I want to lean that driver is mafia but i'm not sure yet. its possible she could be and narwhal isn't.

I think at the moment I vote to lynch c-note

i think we might have let one slip thru our fingers last night

Gunslinger brought the vote close to a tie. If Old3Toes would have switched to C-note then it would have become a tie. I don't think the Mafia would risk a tie just to look innocent.