Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] maelstrom]

like i said I was just going by posts to see who she was on most.

i just saw Bad point at tree.

i hadn't looked at my votes record. i agree that clears bad.

i also notice by votes that doom was on driver today also.

i'll look when i have more time to read all the posts in context with what was happening and how hard she was on the players, she could easily name players that had no real heat on them at that time.if no one is looking then it would be a safe mention.

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

Sorry BadHaggis, I keep misspelling your name for some reason. Aren't you glad that's not your real id, lol?

LOL yea, I noticed that... but I thought, maybe because you have to swing your head to the side Hammer, perhaps you got a little dizzy and threw that N in there

and yes, glad that my real UID is not that!

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

I meant swinging it to the side to read Haggis LOL
I wonder if Haggins is something

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

Looks like just a simple last name for people. Haggis is much more interesting, a bit gtoss but something I never knew about.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I've been fighting this all night. i want to believe narwhal is innocent.there is some fighting between her and driver,as much as can be with 17 posts. i just don't know that it got real heated.

her other posts just don't add up tho. her vote for me with no real good explanation after she pointed the finger at 2 other people.then she retracts off me 4 hours before nightfall and votes no one when there was a close vote between old3toes and c-note.then out of the blue she decides to vote for me again the 2nd day.her posts explaining why made no sense as she tried to point out i was being set up but then votes me.

to the lists!

Great narration Mad, this is a really fun round!!! Thank you for all the work you are putting in!

What I’m thinking, as nightfall us occurring and I just logged on:

Someone asked if I was confident that old3toes was innocent, and I wasn’t. I looked back at the votes, and saw 3t on mael and mael on 3t. I chose to vote for no one because I was unhappy with my choice, and I didn’t want to stick with it. Being crunched for time, I wasn’t able to think and read enough to make a new vote. If I were mafia, why would I change a vote and make myself look suspicious? I wouldn’t.

And now, with 3toes being innocent, I look really shady. H-E-Double Hockey sticks, I would probably vote for me now.

My thoughts, for what they are worth:

BadHaggis – no real read, no thoughts
C-note – distancing from Driver8, maybe mafia
Doomsday998 – no good read
Driver8 – aggressive play, goes in circles, maybe mafia (see C-note above)
Gunslinger – short bursts of “you are all doing nothing helpful” (note, this is a
paraphrase, and not meant to be read as a direct quote of anything)
possible mafia
Hammerhead 991 – fixated on Driver8/maybe G saga, possible mafia
HI IQ – too scattered and random, I think, to be mafia – possible townie
maelstrom – maybe 3t was on to something, possible mafia
RICKETS – townie, I think
Tiburon321 – no read as of yet
Tree_Hugger – not feeling you yet – but possible townie
UhOhChongo – quick strikes of pointed, accusatory posting – this probably means
townie, as a mafia vet would be more careful
wing nut – maybe a middle of the road mafia poster?

xx_Nemesis_xx – killed by Mafia hit
Old3Toes – was the Vig, killed the Doc, that sucks
scoop411 – the dead Doc, double bummer
narwhal – townie

My vote, if it had to be cast now, would be for driver or c-note….

I’ll be back on much later tonight, and will update with any new thoughts.

this was an early list ,after first night fall ,she says if she were to vote it would be driver or cnote but it ended up on me


her next list was after before nightfall

Not switching. A switch to save someone would assume that I know who is innocent and who is mafia, as I don't, I'm not switching. I don't like Mael's posts, any more than they like mine. I’m thinking mafia.

For posterity:

I think Tree and Rickets are the communicating townies. This being said, I think Rickets is Mafia (per the rules, Tree wouldn’t know this) and is sneaking by as a townie.

BadHaggis – townie
C-note – townie
Doomsday998 – mafia?
Driver8 – townie
Gunslinger – mafia
Hammerhead 991 – townie
HI IQ – townie
maelstrom – mafia
RICKETS – mafia
Tiburon321 – townie
Tree_Hugger – townie
UhOhChongo – townie
wing nut – townie

xx_Nemesis_xx – killed by Mafia hit
Old3Toes – was the Vig, killed the Doc, that sucks
scoop411 – the dead Doc, double bummer
narwhal – townie


~Good night, and good luck!

we've determined that doom was on driver both nights gun was the kill vote on driver i know i am innocent and i have a good feeling rickets was also.narwhal said in the post that she thinks tree and rickets were the lone mason and mafia.i think she had it backwards

narwhal and wings were single votes and uhoh was on no one.all 3 look suspect but uhoh gets a pass from me for being aggressive in their posting.

i think its narwhal wing and tree if there are 3 left. if there are only 2 i would most likely go with narwhal and wing. tree while not getting talked about by driver much also has been agressive with posts and we all know mafia will latch onto an innocent.

someone explain to me where they see the innocent connection on narwhal.while you are at it talk me into believing wing is innocent also.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

the second list should say after 2nd night fall not her next list was after before nightfall

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

Woot!! Mafia on day 2! Now my suspicion lands directly onto Tree_Hugger. Driver seemed to cushion her(?) on all of her lists, and I'm still thinking mafia from my posts against her(?). I don't think saying that they fought a little is a good enough reason not to vote, Driver fought with and picked at everyone.

I'm watching Mael, but not as closely as TH.

NNNNNOOOOO I didnt get to finish my tank

Awww, poor RICKETS... I'll go over there and finish your water change

:Angel:

Driver, Driver, Driver... Dead mafia on day 2... I'm glad there are people like you around that makes townie life easier

Believe me to be mafia if you want. I haven't been very helpful, so would be no loss and if my death would cause people to find real mafia, then great. I really didn't think Driver was mafia...I really thought Old3Toes was. I have nothing to offer but a lot of uncertainty and there's no telling if I was right about Narwhal or not. I believe that my posts speak for themselves, I've been honest and given my opinions freely, but I've been fooled and I deserve to hang.

Hmmm, so clearing away all of that "honorable innocent" trash, I see that you supposedly thought three toes was mafia, and that Driver was innocent... Now lets see here.

To you, Driver was innocent. He was mafia.

To you, three toes was mafia. He was innocent.

To you, you are innocent...

Seeing a pattern?

I dont know if I would give all her attacks any merit either though, should could have disagreed with even her partner.... especially getting closer to the end.

Crap... sorry... forgot to change

DD :rofl:

Looks like just a simple last name for people. Haggis is much more interesting, a bit gtoss but something I never knew about.

Yes, very interesting... Mmmmm, sheep stomach :drool: erv:

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I've been fighting this all night. i want to believe narwhal is innocent.there is some fighting between her and driver,as much as can be with 17 posts. i just don't know that it got real heated.

her other posts just don't add up tho. her vote for me with no real good explanation after she pointed the finger at 2 other people.then she retracts off me 4 hours before nightfall and votes no one when there was a close vote between old3toes and c-note.then out of the blue she decides to vote for me again the 2nd day.her posts explaining why made no sense as she tried to point out i was being set up but then votes me.

to the lists!



this was an early list ,after first night fall ,she says if she were to vote it would be driver or cnote but it ended up on me


her next list was after before nightfall



we've determined that doom was on driver both nights gun was the kill vote on driver i know i am innocent and i have a good feeling rickets was also.narwhal said in the post that she thinks tree and rickets were the lone mason and mafia.i think she had it backwards

narwhal and wings were single votes and uhoh was on no one.all 3 look suspect but uhoh gets a pass from me for being aggressive in their posting.

i think its narwhal wing and tree if there are 3 left. if there are only 2 i would most likely go with narwhal and wing. tree while not getting talked about by driver much also has been agressive with posts and we all know mafia will latch onto an innocent.

someone explain to me where they see the innocent connection on narwhal.while you are at it talk me into believing wing is innocent also.

Dooms was only on Driver night 2. We determined that BADHAGGIS was on Driver both nights.

I agree Narwhal is one to watch, but she would not be a first pick for me for a vote.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

And though Tree is suspicious as well, if you'll click on the spat that I quoted, this was early on Day 1. The tone is too severe for distancing IMO, and too early b/c IMO Mafia would not want to draw attention that early unless it was for distracting b/c one of them was in trouble. Tree insinuated that Driver might be trying to protect Driver, a fellow teammate. There was also a disagreement about whether Driver answered that question to Tree's satisfaction. Driver was evasive in her answer, saying something like Mafia would not be that obvious.

But thinking on that conversation and the timing of it, I've got a scenario I want to share in a bit.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

correction, driver might be trying to protect doomsday (who tree had voted)