Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

Anyone notice that UhOhChongo posted in thread about bettas? Is there a connection between that and Lady G's "slip"?

I vote to lynch UhOhChongo

C-note votes Chongo...

Hmmmmmm......I think BadHaggis is trying to confuse me.

I vote to lynch BadHaggis.

subject to change without notice.

Tib votes BadHaggis...

I vote to lynch Doomsday998

The reason is because they have not posted yet and was the first name I came across in the list of players to not post anything yet. I believe the Mafia will try very hard to slip under the radar and be as quiet as possible since it's going to be really hard to read people this round with the anonymous userID's. So this vote is an attempt to get lucky at nailing a lurking mafia, or draw a townie out into the discussion. Nevertheless, it is subject to change since it's still quite early in the game.

Tree votes Dooms...

Well seems to me someone was skimming, and missed quite a few peoples posts. Skimming is such a scumtell. Funny it only took you 2 minutes to correct your mistake, but it was 2 minutes too many I'm afraid.

I retract my vote for BadHaggis, and vote to lynch UhOhChongo

Tib retracts vote off Badhaggis and votes Chongo because he incorrectly posts the number of pple yet to post but corrects it 2 minutes later. Really weak reasoning IMO.

Vote count thru post 73

UhOh 2 - C-note 19, Tib 73
Doom 1 - Tree 68

Vote count. At this point I am already smelling something fishy w/two votes on Chongo so early.

I know lots of times in the past a Mafia player would be one of the first to post when the game started so I want to look at narwal and UhOh. UhOh really seemed to want to play, maybe they were excited to have a Mafia role? Does that make sense?

Scoop shows up and posts suspicions on Chongo.

There's already a train starting on UhOh. Why don't you hop on?

I ask Scoop why doesn't she hop on the Chongo train.

I would have to say the ones jumping most out to me right now would have to be...
Hammerhead
Hi-IQ
Treehugger
Really not real huge vibes from anyone at this point and there are others that have raised suspicion in my mind, but these three have raised my brow a little more then others at this point.


For one, yes it would make since especially if YOU are Lady G, really doesn't matter to me if you are or not honestly...as this would not really mean you are mafia just because of that. I really have know idea if Mafia can tell each other their names or not, but being they are team mates I don't know that it would matter if they did know. Quick to think that they can't though aren't ya?


Now, but didn't you just say it was pointless to try and figure who is who at this point...but now it is making you wonder so much that you went back to the sign up thread to check it out?


Since when are 2 votes a "train", just think it is funny you pointing this out that there is a "train" starting....makes me wonder if you NO that UhOh is innocent and you want to be able to come back and say, you pointed out the train and can through suspicion on the two that supposabley started the train? I find it very hard to believe Mafia would vote the same on day one...so which of the 2 "train starters" do you think are the Mafia player?

Driver comes out and blasts me. She seems ticked off that I might be stopping ppl from voting Chongo.


OK, if you didn't follow, this is what I think: Driver, Tibs, and Dooms are the communicating Mafia. Tibs switched his vote to Chongo to protect Dooms. Maybe Dooms is the Don? Driver came out blasting me because not only did I insinuate that G could be evil, I potentially stopped others from voting Chongo.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

To me it was a toss-up between Tib and C-note, but I think G tossed a bit of suspicion his way while she hasn't said much about Tib except that she may vote for him. Plus Tib did not vot Driver last night and voted Narwhal instead. C-note actually voted Driver. I believe Dooms and Driver staged their spat yesterday before night. And I noticed that immediately following night Dooms wanted to go after Tree. Mael wants to go after Tree, too. And though Chongo does, too he may just be a bit influenced. Mael has that *coughIce-leadercough* quality about him, lol.

 

[[AC] C-note]

To me it was a toss-up between Tib and C-note, but I think G tossed a bit of suspicion his way while she hasn't said much about Tib except that she may vote for him. Plus Tib did not vot Driver last night and voted Narwhal instead. C-note actually voted Driver. I believe Dooms and Driver staged their spat yesterday before night. And I noticed that immediately following night Dooms wanted to go after Tree. Mael wants to go after Tree, too. And though Chongo does, too he may just be a bit influenced. Mael has that *coughIce-leadercough* quality about him, lol.

I was able to glance at the thread last night after nightfall, but was not able to post. It is great that we got Driver. There seems to be more after nightfall activity than there was after the first day. Looks almost like damage control.

While I am uneasy about mael and tree at this point, part of me thinks they are being set up. I also am unsure why Hammer has me in a toss-up. He believes that Driver and Dooms staged their spat, well that is how I feel about his fights with Driver. I really expected for Hammer to change his vote before nightfall. Because he didn't change, I am a little more willing to trust him, but very little. I think narwhal and wing nut should be watched. If narwhal is mafia then I think gunslinger is also. That is the only way I could imagine him voting for Driver. In no way do I think last nights voting cleared anyone.

 

[[AC] C-note]

I also find it funny that no one has said anything about DangerDoll posting. What if she was Driver8? I know most people think it is Lady G, but DangerDoll is crafty. I thought scoop was DangerDoll.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I also find it funny that no one has said anything about DangerDoll posting. What if she was Driver8? I know most people think it is Lady G, but DangerDoll is crafty. I thought scoop was DangerDoll.

LMAO, if skimming wasn't a trait of yours I'd be very suspicious, but just a tad now. If you go back and actually read G's posts, I caught G's second post before she deleted it. She was working on a post to answer HI IQ about his supposed noob status. She later resumed the same post w/different wording as Driver8.

I thought it was a toss up between you and tib being on the communicating Mafia side as both of your votes were on UHOH. But as I've explained since you voted Driver and Driver threw suspicion your way, I think it's tib.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I was able to glance at the thread last night after nightfall, but was not able to post. It is great that we got Driver. There seems to be more after nightfall activity than there was after the first day. Looks almost like damage control.

While I am uneasy about mael and tree at this point, part of me thinks they are being set up. I also am unsure why Hammer has me in a toss-up. He believes that Driver and Dooms staged their spat, well that is how I feel about his fights with Driver. I really expected for Hammer to change his vote before nightfall. Because he didn't change, I am a little more willing to trust him, but very little. I think narwhal and wing nut should be watched. If narwhal is mafia then I think gunslinger is also. That is the only way I could imagine him voting for Driver. In no way do I think last nights voting cleared anyone.

Well what do you think about Tib and Dooms?

 

[[AC] wing nut]

Below is a vote tally from last nightfall.. sorry I didn't record the post numbers.

After looking at the count, I realize that both of my top suspects voted for Driver..C-Note and HI IQ..Looks like I was wrong about both of them...
Now I have to re think all the information.

Driver did a last minute vote change to lynch Narwhal.. Makes me think Narwhal might be innocent, the vote was close..
No one changed their votes away from Driver.. nobody tried to save driver...

I must admit, I am not very good at this game... I am pretty sure most of you know who I really am by now ...

Next time I'll do it in MS Word...Not Excel.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

Below is a vote tally from last nightfall.. sorry I didn't record the post numbers.

After looking at the count, I realize that both of my top suspects voted for Driver..C-Note and HI IQ..Looks like I was wrong about both of them...
Now I have to re think all the information.

Driver did a last minute vote change to lynch Narwhal.. Makes me think Narwhal might be innocent, the vote was close..
No one changed their votes away from Driver.. nobody tried to save driver...

I must admit, I am not very good at this game... I am pretty sure most of you know who I really am by now ...

Next time I'll do it in MS Word...Not Excel.

WingNut, we missed playing these games with you. But the way the games have progressed the Mafia are getting smarter. They will vote their own if it looks like their own is going down. Usually it won't be the first couple of votes and usually it won't be the last one who actually determines their fate. So IMO DoomsDay, C-Note, and HI IQ can still be Mafia. My pick would be Dooms.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

Oh and your chart did help me out Wing. Seeing it visually puts more power to my feelings that Tib and Mael are very suspect. Both voted for Old3Toes and both voted for Narwhal. Very interesting. Perhaps O3T was onto something. The votes piled up on him quick, didn't they?

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

And since Tib's contributions to the game have been very limited as well as very questionable, for now I vote to lynch Tiburon.