Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

Doomsday has remained VERY low, which yes looks scummy and I wouldn't be surprised if they ended up a UD at some point in the game. I'm just not sure that Mafia would stay THAT low. It has happened though, I would love to see more thoughts from them...but I don't think it will happen.
Wing nut really isn't sitting well with me, the only things they have posted really so far is excuses and "I don't think we can trust anyone" as I have stated before I know RL can make it difficult to play at times, but when you have a chance to post instead of "I'm busy, I have a job" as your only post...getting some actual thoughts out would be the better choice IMO. I find them scummy.


Ummm, Hammer....I am not a low poster???

The above post is part of the reason I'm leaning Doomsday Mafia. Driver had posted something negative about Narwhal and her low posting and I asked Driver what she thought of the other low posters, Dooms and Wingnut. Her response about Doomsday is quite mild in comparison to her response about Wingnut. Plus early in the game she argued with Tree about his vote for Dooms for not posting yet.

I do indeed agree with your post, especially because of Driver's most recent posts. Where you're going, you are not talking about G specifically, but more upon the affect of accusations of being G.



If you'd like to see some of Hammer's more recent posts, he has spoken about more than just how he "knows" you are G. Also, it seems to me when you say "Uhoh posted about bettas and G has bettas" you are trying to get others to make the connection.

I retract my vote for Tree_Hugger and vote to lynch no one. Driver, you have always seemed suspicious to me (and recently, Hammer was as well). You have also been quite agressive recently. I almost voted for you, but I will wait and see what the goings on will be for the next little while.

Though Driver goes after UHOH, he hardly strikes back. Just a mild you always seemed suspicious to me and then a vote for no one. And this was after I had to connect the dots for him about Driver trying to throw suspicion his way at game start.

Interesting that Driver thinks most of the town is mafia. I want to see how Tib posts, as he is high up on my list as well. Tree's vote feels a little scummy to me right now, piled onto what I have already said.

Here he mentions Driver but wants to see how Tib posts and Tree feels scummy to him?? And the no vote stays all the way through nightfall?

I do not think most of the town is mafia, I always have everyone as mafia to start the game...as post come in and thoughts are put out there I move them down the list as to who I think is looking less mafia to me. At this point only a couple people have managed to move me in a way that I feel almost comfortable sayint they look more innocent then mafia.


Sorry to hear that, hope everything is ok for you.

I'll see if I can find it but besides this post and the one below the only other time i remember Driver mentioning Tib is in passing.

You know the more I look at Gun, the more I am seeing mafia, maybe the lone goon...I don't know, but he seem to through insignificant stuff out there when we do get a post from him and his answers to questions are so vauge I do so I am going to vote to lynch Gunslingger

This could switch to Tib or Mael before nightfall at this point I believe I could be comfortable with any of these

I think knowing she is going down Driver would have tried to throw in one of her partners' names. My pick would be Tib.

I'm happy with my vote on Tiburon. I think Dooms just might be the other Mafia. And if there is still the lone Mafia out there atm I think UHOH might be a good pick.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

had a few minutes so thought i check in.

doom was the third vote on driver i don't see why they would vote driver that early if they were mafia, at the time they voted wing also had 3 votes on them. and tree had 1. uhoh also had a vote from driver but i don't have the post number so i'm not sure if it was at the same time as wing and drivers mobs.

wing and narwhal are 2 that were single votes on players plus uhohs vote for no one. everyone else was on driver or narwhal.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

I am sorry I could not participate yesterday. I spent all day long visiting family and did not get home until well after midnight. Today I am suffering from some pretty bad sunburn, so I won't be able to sit at my computer desk very much. Plus, inspite of sleeping until 11am, I am still quite tired.

Hammerhead. I will go with what you recommend. Your posts and voting record seem to show you have the town's best interest at heart. I do not have enough confidence in anyone else to follow them, nor do I have the confidence in myself, although I do still believe Narwhal could be mafia. I can agree on Tib also looking highly suspicious, and Doomsday and Uhoh. I will place my vote on any of them.

I vote to lynch Tiburon.

I will check in a few times before nightfall to see how things are looking and if a vote change is warranted.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

jeez, i just remembered tiburon voted narwhal and with no explanation. doesn't sit well with me. unless they are also mafia and since we have them leaning that way if they are lynched it could look to clear narwhal.also with them being there we would be less likely to vote narwhal.

i don't have time right now i need to get ready but it will be something i will be thinking about all day lol.

This seems to be a valid thought but then because I am still suspicious of you I'm wondering if this is your way of keeping your vote on Narwhal even though Tib also looks suspicious.

And I realize Driver went after you also but she was going down already. It could have been distancing or you could be the lone Mafia. You kept saying how I may have been right about driver and hit the nail on the head, but you seemed to always have others you thought were more suspicious for one reason or another. Tree's vote was early on Narwhal and yours was the last, which looked like an attempt to save Driver.

This is awful wierd! I don't know, but I think LadyG prolly had a blonde moment! This going back and forth is tuff, and the site won't save the skins differently from one name to the next.....btw, hammer, love the avatar!

It's possible this post was to cover-up for G and I thought this at the time the post was made. But Driver grilled narwhal pretty bad about her no-vote, so I don't see them both being Mafia unless Narwhal is the lone Mafia.

Not switching. A switch to save someone would assume that I know who is innocent and who is mafia, as I don't, I'm not switching. I don't like Mael's posts, any more than they like mine. I’m thinking mafia.

For posterity:

I think Tree and Rickets are the communicating townies. This being said, I think Rickets is Mafia (per the rules, Tree wouldn’t know this) and is sneaking by as a townie.

BadHaggis – townie
C-note – townie
Doomsday998 – mafia?
Driver8 – townie
Gunslinger – mafia
Hammerhead 991 – townie
HI IQ – townie
maelstrom – mafia
RICKETS – mafia
Tiburon321 – townie
Tree_Hugger – townie
UhOhChongo – townie
wing nut – townie

xx_Nemesis_xx – killed by Mafia hit
Old3Toes – was the Vig, killed the Doc, that sucks
scoop411 – the dead Doc, double bummer
narwhal – townie


~Good night, and good luck!

This further makes me think Narwhal would not be part of the communicating Mafia. She would not have thrown suspicion on Rickets right before hitting him, imo.

As far as my list I would have to say:
Narwhal
Uh-Oh
Are very high up there for me right now,

Narwhal-The vote for no-one twice has me very concerned, that and the fact they seem to be not helping at all. Yes, I know they have put out a list and made one other post with some actual "thought" behind it, but they can not commet to anything, and IMO are laying low...even though they post they are not, also not sure yet why they say UH-OH is a mafia "vet"

Uh-Oh-That post before night fall just really made me uncomfortable, and the post of "I knew 3toes would show innocent" really added to this.

Wing-nut is looking bad to me also, along with IQ, Tib and Tree, I have way more people looking guilty then innocent at this point.

Here I think her description of Narwhal is a bit severe for distancing, saying Narwhal has almost no posts w/"thought" behind them.
And Tib is mentioned in a long line-up.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

had a few minutes so thought i check in.

doom was the third vote on driver i don't see why they would vote driver that early if they were mafia, at the time they voted wing also had 3 votes on them. and tree had 1. uhoh also had a vote from driver but i don't have the post number so i'm not sure if it was at the same time as wing and drivers mobs.

wing and narwhal are 2 that were single votes on players plus uhohs vote for no one. everyone else was on driver or narwhal.

I'm not so Dooms vote wasn't just for distancing. Others had Driver very high on their list of suspects, so it could be damage control so she could say she voted early and she has said that. However with Wing's lack of posting and push for Tree I am also considering her.

 

[[AC] wing nut]

hey everyone..

I have had to leave town unexpectedly.. was able to log on a computer at a truckstop.
Don't have time to catch up, and do not want to UD so,

I vote to lynch nobody

if I get back before nightfall, Ill catch up.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

Thanks, Hammer. I couldn't have done that better myself!

I really want to hear more about last night's no one vote. It seems odd for a night 2 vote.

Mael's vote pattern today is off, whether or not it was my name. I think it's odd (yes, I know I can be accused of the same thing) to vote someone, then retract, then cast it again, all within a few hours.

I'm going to hold with my previous vote.

I vote to lynch maelstrom.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Mael has kept my attention, as stated before the end of night two...they can state the reason of posting at the same time, but it reads as an attempt to do a save....

I vote to lynch maelstrom....

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

vote subject to change to force a coin flip and watch vote switches...just for entertainment and to get ice excited...

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

I like it when the games do not allow a "no one" vote. Especially in a game as "pro" mafia as this one and not revealing the hit identities.

And even if you forego those reasons, it is not very helpful for a night 3.