Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] narwhal]

Go, town, go!!!!!

Gun, if you are the Lone Mason, why did you get so nit-picky when I made the "communicating townies" comment, instead of ignoring it (as most innocents would have done, to protect yourself as a pr, so early in the game) or pointing out my error (the second isn't necessarily a townie) helpfully? Your reaction there (before I was a royal b****) has me concerned now.

My vote tonight will either be with whoever Mael votes (sorry 'bout the votes there buddy) or on Gun.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Go, town, go!!!!!

Gun, if you are the Lone Mason, why did you get so nit-picky when I made the "communicating townies" comment, instead of ignoring it (as most innocents would have done, to protect yourself as a pr, so early in the game) or pointing out my error (the second isn't necessarily a townie) helpfully? Your reaction there (before I was a royal b****) has me concerned now.

My vote tonight will either be with whoever Mael votes (sorry 'bout the votes there buddy) or on Gun.

Cause I don't view the Lone Mason as a power role; they can communicate with some one, who may be mafia. You were obviously confused on the technicalities of the rules and I pointed it out. I still don't think any of us are in the clear.

There is nothing that says anything for sure, just individual's belief in people's statements.

So far, one has directly claimed to be the Lone Mason, one has kind of said they are the Detective.

There could be one or two mafia left.

For now, I will let the person I am communicating with stay a mystery. They are welcome to come out and say so, doesn't bother me.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

I am not feeling comfortable about tiburon....and the lack of the Don hitting anyone. The Don may have decided not to, but i doubt it, more likely a case of RL getting in the way.

Tib posted before the end of day 2 at 2 PM..

I vote to lynch Nawhal

After a long winded post designed to confuse the reader, you actually did the opposite of what you said. Thats pretty scummy to me.

RL issues will prevent me from being on again until well after nightfall. If I'm not hit or lynched, I promise to be a better townie starting tomorrow. I'm sorry I haven't been as helpful as I would have liked to be the last couple days.



next post is at 8 PM Friday....

sorry, i just got back from a funeral.
I vote to lynch narwhal


Tib could be the Don, and the RL issues prevented him from sending in a hit, or being her to shift his vote to save last nights Mafia scum.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

Cause I don't view the Lone Mason as a power role; they can communicate with some one, who may be mafia. You were obviously confused on the technicalities of the rules and I pointed it out. I still don't think any of us are in the clear.

There is nothing that says anything for sure, just individual's belief in people's statements.

So far, one has directly claimed to be the Lone Mason, one has kind of said they are the Detective.

There could be one or two mafia left.

For now, I will let the person I am communicating with stay a mystery. They are welcome to come out and say so, doesn't bother me.

this bothers me. as does the vote for narwhal. you wanted me to hang for voting narwhal and now you think she is mafia?

you won't tell us who you are communicating with? why not? we have them outnumbered for sure and everyone we know is innocent is only a plus.if you tell us who you are talking to then the mafia is forced to use the next 3 hits on me you and them leaving the others open to narrow down possible suspects.

even if Tib was the don the other mafia players could have sent in a hit. i know I would have pmed Mad and asked if a hit was sent in if my don was mia.so if we are going with that thought we need another mia player as mafia.

gun has raised my suspicion a lot, until someone comes forward as their partner i have to assume mafia. it will be interesting to see who comes to their rescue.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

This part concerns me -

Of the three - Rickets was hit, I doubt the mafia would hit their own Don, Uh Oh voted for Tibs, gunslinger voted for mael.

Gunslinger is claiming to be the lone mason. Just maybe Gunslinger is the Don and he hit the lone mason. He would come up innocent, plus he would know that no one else would claim to be the lone mason. The only problem with this is that the lone mason does have a partner. As far as I can tell, without hearing from the lone mason partner, gunslinger can't be cleared.

I think wing nut is the Don, but it still seems very odd that there was not a hit. Maybe the Don is trying to frame wing nut.

I am also a little "bothered" that more than one mod has been viewing the thread and posting with their mod account. While in mod mode, they can see who is invisible. I think the very fact they are viewing the thread with a mod account is against the spirit of the game. Someone who can see invisible players would know if someone was online and posting before nightfall. The more I think about it, the more I can see gunslingerb as the Don and setting wing up. I hope I am not thinking too much into this.

You are thinking too much into this. Gunslinger was the kill vote for Driver. If he was the Don he could have easily left his vote on Narwhal and let Mael take the blame. Although I'm now wondering if Narwhal may be the lone Mafia...

Go, town, go!!!!!

Gun, if you are the Lone Mason, why did you get so nit-picky when I made the "communicating townies" comment, instead of ignoring it (as most innocents would have done, to protect yourself as a pr, so early in the game) or pointing out my error (the second isn't necessarily a townie) helpfully? Your reaction there (before I was a royal b****) has me concerned now.

My vote tonight will either be with whoever Mael votes (sorry 'bout the votes there buddy) or on Gun.

If you don't know who Gun is by now you should know he is nitpicky about details. He and Mael both, actually. That's why I had and still slightly have suspicions about Mael. How could Mael not have read or remembered the Don's description when he made that post about the Big City Goon? But you coming out less than half an hour after C-note makes that post saying he suspects Gunslinger makes me worried about you. Makes me wonder if you are trying to save Wingnut by picking on someone who you know has pple concerned.

So explain to me Narwhal, why did you not vote Driver night 2 if she so got under your skin? Was it because you knew the outcome would be about the same for the bad guys and actually better if Driver stayed because she was with the team and you weren't? Is that why you were so sensitive and irritated that night? I really thought it was all fun and games those comments between you and Gun until you said you felt really bad and wished it would be you that went.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

this bothers me. as does the vote for narwhal. you wanted me to hang for voting narwhal and now you think she is mafia?

you won't tell us who you are communicating with? why not? we have them outnumbered for sure and everyone we know is innocent is only a plus.if you tell us who you are talking to then the mafia is forced to use the next 3 hits on me you and them leaving the others open to narrow down possible suspects.

even if Tib was the don the other mafia players could have sent in a hit. i know I would have pmed Mad and asked if a hit was sent in if my don was mia.so if we are going with that thought we need another mia player as mafia.

gun has raised my suspicion a lot, until someone comes forward as their partner i have to assume mafia. it will be interesting to see who comes to their rescue.

RELAX Mael an Everyone! Gunslinger contacted me on day two because he thought I looked the least Mafia, lmao. I had posted in the thread that I was leaning him more innocent because of his vote on C-note night 1. If you can't tell by my vote record what my alliance is you aren't paying attention.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I also know i said c-note looks to be helpful.but their insistence that they think tree and me were being setup has me a bit nervous.

yes they voted driver but at the time it looked like it would be a runaway train on driver. they were the 4th vote on i wish i had the posts numbers of retractions so i could track the moves better but i don't and i have to leave soon so they'll have to wait till this evening. but its possible c-note saw the tide turning and moved there for distancing.

wing and gun as previously mentioned are suspects.

last suspect would be UhOh, came back as a townie but we know that means nothing with this darn rule.they weren't around for the day 2 vote and voted no one with a tight race, voted Narwhal night 1 no one night 2 and tib night 3,early on tib but his name had been thrown around a lot too.

if anyone has the time to look through their lists or who they have been on the most and compare it to the known innocents maybe we'd get a better read.

i wish i hadn't come out last night, but i really expected a last minute vote for myself and if i lost the tie breaker i didn't want what i knew to go with me.

we could vote a suspect mafia player and myself and keep it tied up. there are 11 players left so the vote will be 6-5, i will vote no one and 5 sit on me and 5 on wings. this way they can't waste a hit on me because i will let the coin flip decide my fate or save myself.it pretty much forces them to send in a hit on someone else or risk hitting me and me being lynched thus wasting a hit. if i do make it thru the night i have another investigation. or we keep it tied and the mayor,if still with us sends in a pardon for me so if the coin flip does kill me the pardon saves me.
if the mayor is still with us don't tip your hand, the more they are kept guessing the better. we need them to be worried that the hit will be wasted.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

RELAX Mael an Everyone! Gunslinger contacted me on day two because he thought I looked the least Mafia, lmao. I had posted in the thread that I was leaning him more innocent because of his vote on C-note night 1. If you can't tell by my vote record what my alliance is you aren't paying attention.

why would vote records tell me how you feel about Gun.

but i believe you and Gun is no longer a suspect as i do trust you.

i just wanted to make sure all bases are covered.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

why would vote records tell me how you feel about Gun.

but i believe you and Gun is no longer a suspect as i do trust you.

i just wanted to make sure all bases are covered.

no, my vote records should let you and gun and the town know what i am. lol, last night gun had the nerve to tell me that if he got hit i needed to come out and let everyone know he was the mason IF I was not Mafia. We thought you were cooking up a plan. I'm still not totally sure about you Mael, but you seem to be on the up and up. It would make sense that the Mafia would want you gone first if you can investigate so I and the town should be a bit worried if Gun and I go first and you still can't find us a Mafia. I think you should investigate Narwhal next if we are voting Wing. I also have suspicions of C-note, but not as much. Sometimes I think he's trying to help others not so sure.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I also know i said c-note looks to be helpful.but their insistence that they think tree and me were being setup has me a bit nervous.

yes they voted driver but at the time it looked like it would be a runaway train on driver. they were the 4th vote on i wish i had the posts numbers of retractions so i could track the moves better but i don't and i have to leave soon so they'll have to wait till this evening. but its possible c-note saw the tide turning and moved there for distancing.

wing and gun as previously mentioned are suspects.

last suspect would be UhOh, came back as a townie but we know that means nothing with this darn rule.they weren't around for the day 2 vote and voted no one with a tight race, voted Narwhal night 1 no one night 2 and tib night 3,early on tib but his name had been thrown around a lot too.

if anyone has the time to look through their lists or who they have been on the most and compare it to the known innocents maybe we'd get a better read.

i wish i hadn't come out last night, but i really expected a last minute vote for myself and if i lost the tie breaker i didn't want what i knew to go with me.

we could vote a suspect mafia player and myself and keep it tied up. there are 11 players left so the vote will be 6-5, i will vote no one and 5 sit on me and 5 on wings. this way they can't waste a hit on me because i will let the coin flip decide my fate or save myself.it pretty much forces them to send in a hit on someone else or risk hitting me and me being lynched thus wasting a hit. if i do make it thru the night i have another investigation. or we keep it tied and the mayor,if still with us sends in a pardon for me so if the coin flip does kill me the pardon saves me.
if the mayor is still with us don't tip your hand, the more they are kept guessing the better. we need them to be worried that the hit will be wasted.

Sounds like a good plan. I will vote you to start w/and others can move around to even things out.

I vote to lynch Maelstrom