Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] HI IQ]

if your not guilty the only other i can see would be dd and after tonite im leaning towards beliving them over you. narwhals curious, but... not as much as you.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

O3T (4) - maelstrom 147, Tree_Hugger 212, Tiburon 215, scoop411 216, C-note
C-note (3) - RICKETS 114, Doomsday 192, wing nut 208, Gunslinger
HI IQ (2) - Nemesis 132, Driver8 163
Driver8 (2) - Hammerhead 173, BadHaggis 209
wing nut (1) - HI IQ 165
narwhal (1) - UhOh 187
Tiburon (1) - O3T 218
No lynch (1) - narwhal 224

This was the voting from night 1. I realize it would have been too risky to investigate C-Note ore O3T. If I were the detective I would have investigated HIIQ or Driver. Rickets wasn't even up for lynch.

Night 2, UhOh had no votes them.

Night 3, Gunslinger had no votes on him, Narwhal had 2.

I've never been a detective in these games, so I'm no expert but does anyone see the reasoning behind Mael's supposed investigations?

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

O3T (4) - maelstrom 147, Tree_Hugger 212, Tiburon 215, scoop411 216, C-note
C-note (3) - RICKETS 114, Doomsday 192, wing nut 208, Gunslinger
HI IQ (2) - Nemesis 132, Driver8 163
Driver8 (2) - Hammerhead 173, BadHaggis 209
wing nut (1) - HI IQ 165
narwhal (1) - UhOh 187
Tiburon (1) - O3T 218
No lynch (1) - narwhal 224

This was the voting from night 1. I realize it would have been too risky to investigate C-Note ore O3T. If I were the detective I would have investigated HIIQ or Driver. Rickets wasn't even up for lynch.

Night 2, UhOh had no votes them.

Night 3, Gunslinger had no votes on him, Narwhal had 2.

I've never been a detective in these games, so I'm no expert but does anyone see the reasoning behind Mael's supposed investigations?

I explained my reasons.

Everyone agree to lynch me,get it out of the way. Then start looking at who you would lynch when I am found innocent. That way you have a 48 hour window to figure it out and not just 24 hours.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I had to do it guys. I was pretty sure Wing was innocent and that the mafia had 2 innocents on the block so they wouldn't move but i couldn't not get an investigation. It might have been the deal breaker.

Unfortunately..........C-Note is a Townie

If you were pretty sure Wing was an innocent, why did you post this before night?

Originally Posted by [AC] wing nut
Maybe he was trying to hint to the DON he was the BCG.. did a bad job of it and got whacked..?

Still think HI IQ was behind the hit.. Regardless of if Nem was the BCG or an innocent..

I think this post will help. If wings is mafia I think it clears Hi IQ.

Seems like you were saying you weren't going to investigate HI IQ because you thought wing would be mafia.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

HI IQ or C-Note, hopefully one of you are the mayor. I think the investigations WOULD show mayor, it doesn't say it won't in the rules. If you are then you will know Mael is probably not the detective.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

HI IQ or C-Note, hopefully one of you are the mayor. I think the investigations WOULD show mayor, it doesn't say it won't in the rules. If you are then you will know Mael is probably not the detective.

Bah!, It's time for bed. I mean UH-OH or C-Note, LMAO.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

If you were pretty sure Wing was an innocent, why did you post this before night?


Seems like you were saying you weren't going to investigate HI IQ because you thought wing would be mafia.

Pretty sure is not 100% sure.

If wings did show mafia then it would clear IQ,since he showed innocent the post doesn't help. I was worried that I was going to be hit and I wanted to put something I found out there to help since if I was hit you wouldn't get an investigation result.

 

[[AC] C-note]

I was posting from the viewpoint of mafia to show you it made no sense.

While I think it is good to have discussions about who could be mafia. I really think we need to get thru this next night. If wing nut is the Don, then the game could be over or we could be trying to figure out who the lone mafia is. Since there is now a plan in place to put the votes in a tie and let mael choose to either die or vote for wing nut to stop the mafia hit (which only works if the mafia hits him). Which also makes no sense, because the Don comes up innocent, so why does the Don even care about the detective. The Don might want to protect the lone mafia, if they had not already hit them. Besides that, I don't see why the Don would even care about the Detective.

I think a strong case could be made for mael to be the Don. As the Don he could have hit Detective, it is not like he has brought back any mafia. I am not even so sure of his choices of who to investigate. While I felt that there was something strange going on and that I thought that mael was being set up, I still feel that there is more to the story.

If we are still playing tomorrow, which is a big if, then I would like to look more into Mael and Narwhal. It really matters if wing is mafia or not and matters if the lone mafia is still alive. I think wing hit the lone mafia and is going to UD.

I want to bring this forward. I didn't understand the point of the plan. I don't know why he did not keep with it, though. If the mayor was on board, he could have protected mael. (by the way - I am not the Mayor). I really wish he would have "investigated" someone else besides me.

I vote to lynch maelstrom

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote count thru post 807

maelstrom (5) - Doomsday 778, Tree_Hugger 783, Hammerhead 787, HI IQ 789, BadHaggis 791
narwhal (1) - maelstrom 793

No votes recorded: C-note, narwhal, UhOhChongo

 

[[AC] C-note]

I explained my reasons.

Everyone agree to lynch me,get it out of the way. Then start looking at who you would lynch when I am found innocent. That way you have a 48 hour window to figure it out and not just 24 hours.

If maelstrom is innocent, then narwhal would be my top chioce. After that I am not real sure. Mael had asked for three suspects before and I couldn't come up with a solid three. After narwhal, maybe Hi IQ, Tree and Doomsday. I know that is four. There is at the most only two mafia left.

While it will be good to talk about it, I certainly would not vote for narwhal today. Maelstrom late minute switch and then also stating he would not say who he was investigating, but stated it after his switch bothers me. I can see him trying to get votes on me or narwhal.

If maelstrom is mafia, then narwhal would still be my top chioce.