Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] C-note]

Tree, I thought you were the lone mafia, HI IQ was my other choice.

btw, HI IQ was the lone mafia.

I liked the format, I think the mayor and detective should have had a little more power.

 

[Madcrawdad]

OMG, WE PULLED IT OFF!!! GREAT JOB.....BOSS!!!

I can't believe I got off to watch law and order come back and the game ended!!!

WOW, what a game....it was a GREAT, I'd of been sooooo nuts if I was an innocent this round!!

Awesome game!!!! Thanks Mad, for modding, and thanks to all for playing!!!!!!

Thanks, guys...and good night.

 

[[AC] C-note]

Fun game everyone.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Tree, I thought you were the lone mafia, HI IQ was my other choice.

btw, HI IQ was the lone mafia.

I liked the format, I think the mayor and detective should have had a little more power.

If we played it again, at some point, I might tweak it based on suggestions. The overall plan, however, was to make it as balanced as possible between the two teams. The fact that it ended up 1 v 1, with the game being decided by a coin flip, somewhat confirms that the roles were fairly balanced..

Also, while I'll take credit for the alternate ID aspect along with the storyline, I did borrow heavily from a game on another site, with regard to the roles.

 

[Lady G]

If we played it again, at some point, I might tweak it based on suggestions. The overall plan, however, was to make it as balanced as possible between the two teams. The fact that it ended up 1 v 1, with the game being decided by a coin flip, somewhat confirms that the roles were fairly balanced..

Also, while I'll take credit for the alternate ID aspect along with the storyline, I did borrow heavily from a game on another site, with regard to the roles.

Well, what ever you did it worked!! I think it was cool as heck that it was down to 1-1!!!

Hey...thought you were going to bed

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

As the Mafia's kills were kept secret, here's who was who:

Doomsday998 - Mayor
maelstrom - Detective
scoop411 - Doctor
Gunslinger - Lone Mason
Old3Toes - Vigilante
RICKETS - Townie
xx_Nemesis_xx - Townie
BadHaggis - Townie
narwhal - Townie
Hammerhead 991 - Townie (picked to communicate w/ Lone Mason)
Tree_Hugger - Townie
wing nut - Townie
UhOhChongo - Townie

C-note - ACville Mafia Don
Driver8 - ACville Mafia Goon
Tiburon321 - ACville Mafia Goon
HI IQ - Big City Mafia Goon

GRRRRRRR. Great Game Everyone. And good job evils, though I'm weeping because I was so close, if not spot on. WTH, Doomsday, didn't you listen to anything Mael and I had to say? LOL, Nice last minute save, though.

And I agree it was a good format, Mad. Perhaps like Mael stated maybe the id's of those who were hit could be revealed after the 4th nightfall or so. Or the night after or two nights after they are dead they are discovered and id'd during the nighttime narrations like DangerDoll in game 6. Thanks for modding. Had fun going crazy!

 

[IceH2O]

The reason I didn't wait for the mayors save was because I didn't know if the mayor was still alive. I couldn't chance being killed off and not getting the investigation. Real shame I didn't investigate Hi IQ instead of c-note though as that would have carried me another day.

My guesses at who played what role

Coler-c-note
Ice- maelstrom
Ogre - old3toes
Catfish-Rickets
DD-doom
LG- driver
Charlie-UhOh
RB-gunslinger
JM-Bad
Zsand-HH
Plant-Tree
JL-Nemesis
Zig-Tiburon
Tachete-scoop
Jensons- narwhal
DP-wing
????-Hi IQ ** want to say Hooked

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Tree, I thought you were the lone mafia, HI IQ was my other choice.

btw, HI IQ was the lone mafia.

I liked the format, I think the mayor and detective should have had a little more power.

That's hilarious. You could have won it (without the coin flip) if you'd hit me instead =) I wish I had been the BCG instead of a completely mixed up Townie.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

GRRRRRRR. Great Game Everyone. And good job evils, though I'm weeping because I was so close, if not spot on. WTH, Doomsday, didn't you listen to anything Mael and I had to say? LOL, Nice last minute save, though.

And I agree it was a good format, Mad. Perhaps like Mael stated maybe the id's of those who were hit could be revealed after the 4th nightfall or so. Or the night after or two nights after they are dead they are discovered and id'd during the nighttime narrations like DangerDoll in game 6. Thanks for modding. Had fun going crazy!

I did listen, the issue was that Since i didn't know who was who, and all my good guys were gone, i couldn't protect myself, i really thought you tow were the bad guys playing me along! had mael not changed his vote, I wouldn't have pushed for him.

and, i could only save each player once, so, i used it the first night because thats what he wanted, when he changed his vote, he wasted my save.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

The reason I didn't wait for the mayors save was because I didn't know if the mayor was still alive. I couldn't chance being killed off and not getting the investigation. Real shame I didn't investigate Hi IQ instead of c-note though as that would have carried me another day.

My guesses at who played what role

Coler-c-note
Ice- maelstrom
Ogre - old3toes
Catfish-Rickets
DD-doom
LG- driver
Charlie-UhOh
RB-gunslinger
JM-Bad
Zsand-HH
Plant-Tree
JL-Nemesis
Zig-Tiburon
Tachete-scoop
Jensons- narwhal
DP-wing
????-Hi IQ ** want to say Hooked

I was only sure of a handful of players until I consulted w/Gunslinger and his syntax thing. Then who was who finally made sense, lol. I'll let him put up a list if he cares to.

And I came so close to switching my vote from you Mael, to C-note. I actually started typing it but had to get going and didn't know if anyone else would follow or listen to me, so I left it. Now I wonder if anyone else would have followed me, lol.

I did listen, the issue was that Since i didn't know who was who, and all my good guys were gone, i couldn't protect myself, i really thought you tow were the bad guys playing me along! had mael not changed his vote, I wouldn't have pushed for him.

and, i could only save each player once, so, i used it the first night because thats what he wanted, when he changed his vote, he wasted my save.

I understood the feeling betrayed by Mael, I felt that way, too. I was referring to C-Note. I think at the end almost everyone had him leaning Mafia and I'd stated a few times why I thought Tree was innocent. But then I also stated a few times that I thought you were Mafia and thought so until my final day, lmao. I guess it was the PR I was sensing.