Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

[Hooked Newbie]

You know, JMax might be mafia too. The only reason for her to be this quiet is that her mafia team is telling her to slow waaay down. They know she'll put her foot in her mouth quick.

She could be. She's usually evil afterall. This seems to be another ploy to keep DD off the radar though. Did I strike too close to home? Let's see DD, Ogre, and probably one more... I'd guess they'd choose to go with someone using an alias.... Ogre, DD, and Gunslinger?

I vote to lynch Dangerdoll. Yes, it's repetitive.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

ummm.... I thanked toes for the hug.... that's weird?

Yep, weird that you'd slap hands for being touchy feely just a minute prior.

Think what you want. I didn't set a "trap", I was looking for response and what I got told me mafia. You morphed "baiting" into "setting a trap", every vote in the first few days is "baiting" to me. Setting a "trap" is something mafia would do. I did find it odd that she responded to other posts after mine, but not my vote. Right or wrong, that's my opinion and I've voiced it. Why does it seem like you're defending her subtly? Again, I'll stand by my vote. I believe she is mafia and you are maybe #2 on the list. Ya gotta hit me to get rid of me.

Dude I agree with you that she looks fishy but it seems you're playing semantics games.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

She could be. She's usually evil afterall. This seems to be another ploy to keep DD off the radar though. Did I strike too close to home? Let's see DD, Ogre, and probably one more... I'd guess they'd choose to go with someone using an alias.... Ogre, DD, and Gunslinger?

I vote to lynch Dangerdoll. Yes, it's repetitive.

Yep, weird that you'd slap hands for being touchy feely just a minute prior.



Dude I agree with you that she looks fishy but it seems you're playing semantics games.

My bad. Please insert Uhoh where I said Gunslinger...

 

[[AC] Old3Toes]

Crap it seems those pointing fingers about skimming are the ones doing it themselves. There are less than five mafia right now according to Ice. All this talk of there being possibly 5 mafia at this point is pointless.

Yeah I thought OldToes might be Bob because hey the dude has old toes and he isn't the first one to post under both a real name and an alias in mafia (this very game included). Isn't that right Cat, G...? The fact that G pointed it out herself is comical. Ice hasn't posted the final player list so anyone assuming that Bob couldn't have been OldToes etc. early in day one was missing an obvious possibility.

Gunslinger, dude you're sure worried about everyone's post counts. Whatsup? Worried that innocents won't give you enough circumstantial stuff for you to put a mafia spin on?

Driver/Cat, you're either mafia or an innocent that is going to get yourself hanged if you pull stuff like voting for yourself.

DangerDoll, I don't get the thank you for the hug message only one minute after chastising people for acting like they were trying to get invited to a Wednesday night mafia spaghetti dinner.

How UhOh is hiding in the shadows amazes me. This lame attempt at being helpful is, well lame. This post even gives skimming a bad name. Maybe read the thread and then post some thoughts.

First off, having an idea of how many mafia there could be is helpful. I wanted to point out that in no way is the amount of mafia favors the town. There is no reason for a false sense of having an advantage, we out number the mafia, but they can work together. I think that line of thinking is dangerous, but it is good to discuss it, it is not pointless. What is pointless are your thoughts.

Being worried about post counts is valid. I think you had one at this point and it was "Hi Bob" (to me and I am no Bob!)

Thanks for pointing out that Cat/Driver is either mafia or innocent. I was wonder just what he was.

I gave Dangerdoll a hug and she thanked me for it. How does that make her a suspect? I am sure there are way better reasons, but the thank you for the hug?


:nutkick:

 

[OgreMkV]

Think what you want. I didn't set a "trap", I was looking for response and what I got told me mafia. You morphed "baiting" into "setting a trap", every vote in the first few days is "baiting" to me. Setting a "trap" is something mafia would do. I did find it odd that she responded to other posts after mine, but not my vote. Right or wrong, that's my opinion and I've voiced it. Why does it seem like you're defending her subtly? Again, I'll stand by my vote. I believe she is mafia and you are maybe #2 on the list. Ya gotta hit me to get rid of me.

Fine, you want to get picky on semantics.
1) What do you put bait in? A trap. Hence my change, to me, they are interchangeable, because you are forcing someone into a reaction, then judging them on that reaction (or lack thereof), that is a trap. Especially considering that there is no reasoning behind the answers

2) YOU are the one who has not answered my question. I asked "What response that DD gave you caused you to think her mafia?"

3) Please explain where defending comes into it. I implied that your opinion is based on crummy logic. That's not defending DD, it's saying your logic is goofy.

4) Ah, here was what I was waiting for. I knew this was coming as soon as I said what I said. Now, I'm mafia because I question you.

Now, let me state, for the record that I don't think you are mafia at this time. You have however, misconstrued two (maybe three) things that I've said AND accused me of being mafia, JUST BECAUSE I DARED TO QUESTION YOU.

Just my opinion

Anyway, I'm still not sure where to vote. I've put my energy into arguing with Hooked instead of what I should be doing and baiting other players... oh wait... nevermind.

Hmmm... Let's see something...

I vote to lynch DD.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Fine, you want to get picky on semantics.
1) What do you put bait in? A trap. Hence my change, to me, they are interchangeable, because you are forcing someone into a reaction, then judging them on that reaction (or lack thereof), that is a trap. Especially considering that there is no reasoning behind the answers

2) YOU are the one who has not answered my question. I asked "What response that DD gave you caused you to think her mafia?"

3) Please explain where defending comes into it. I implied that your opinion is based on crummy logic. That's not defending DD, it's saying your logic is goofy.

4) Ah, here was what I was waiting for. I knew this was coming as soon as I said what I said. Now, I'm mafia because I question you.

Now, let me state, for the record that I don't think you are mafia at this time. You have however, misconstrued two (maybe three) things that I've said AND accused me of being mafia, JUST BECAUSE I DARED TO QUESTION YOU.

Just my opinion

Anyway, I'm still not sure where to vote. I've put my energy into arguing with Hooked instead of what I should be doing and baiting other players... oh wait... nevermind.

Hmmm... Let's see something...

I vote to lynch DD.

#1- Many interpretations possible. You put bait in a crab trap, but you also can bait a hook.

#2- She did not respond at all to my vote and questioning of her reasons for it until I again posted. Then she came out with both barrells. Call it a feeling or whatever, but I believe I have called it right.

#3- If my logic is crummy in your opinion, say so. From my perspective you were throwing out anything you could think of (including Jmax) that would defer attention off of DD.

#4- Not because you question me, but because I see you coming to DD's defense. Lat's see where the votes end up.

I do enjoy a good "debate" and it's day 1, but I stand by what I've posted. I could very well be wrong about you, but I have legitimate reasons for my suspicions. Time will tell.

 

[Lady G]

the "disappearance" was in response to you G... you are the one who said "then I disappeared".... aren't you following your own train of thought?

Yep, I said you "disappeared" after jumping on Driver and putting a vote in...I am following my thoughts just fine...not sure you are though. I asked because of the way you chose your wording...here lets see what I meant.

I disappeared G because I was at work and ran into a few things I needed to do... you know, for work. I left work at 4:30, came home. Let the dogs out, vacuumed, tried to nap, couldn't, changed all the garbages in the house, it's garbage night. Went to the store for a couple things, made dinner, checked here. I posted my thoughts about driver and the apology only sealed the deal for me. It was the excuses that caught my eye really... and then the apology... and I will also say also that the whole post that I noted on in the first place is classic for posting without anything to say, if not maybe just to post... yes, a lot of times the first couple of votes are incorrect... but almost every game I have been in, it's been noted on... a note I can take, and explanation... well, we've seen it all before.

I have also found that I believe yours was the one of the first defenses of driver that I was tuned to... which I find interesting in of itself as well... need more?

note... am walking away from the PC for the moment... have a few things to do...

So you started with you disappeared because you were at work. Then you turned around and said...I left work at 4:30...came home....ect...checked here...posted thoughts on Driver. So I was getting at were you saying your thoughts were before or after work, cause it started like it was before but ended with it was after the way it read.

Also find it kinda ironic you say it was the excuses that caught your eye...in the same post that you have chalked FULL of excuses for yourself.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

How UhOh is hiding in the shadows amazes me. This lame attempt at being helpful is, well lame. This post even gives skimming a bad name. Maybe read the thread and then post some thoughts.

First off, having an idea of how many mafia there could be is helpful. I wanted to point out that in no way is the amount of mafia favors the town. There is no reason for a false sense of having an advantage, we out number the mafia, but they can work together. I think that line of thinking is dangerous, but it is good to discuss it, it is not pointless. What is pointless are your thoughts.

Being worried about post counts is valid. I think you had one at this point and it was "Hi Bob" (to me and I am no Bob!)

Thanks for pointing out that Cat/Driver is either mafia or innocent. I was wonder just what he was.

I gave Dangerdoll a hug and she thanked me for it. How does that make her a suspect? I am sure there are way better reasons, but the thank you for the hug?


:nutkick:

Dude, take a look in the mirror because it is you that needs to read the thread better. Ice has already told us that there are fewer than five mafia right now. Discussing that there could be five now makes no sense unless you're mafia and trying to confuse people or you're generally careless. Which are you? And why are you answering comments pointed at DangerDoll and Cat/Driver?

You might have old toes but you aren't playing like the sage you seem to think you are.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

I have been having computer problems and my alias is not working , so i guess i am just me

night fall is tom night right?..i so need to get caught up, and i have to work tom!! I so should probably not have joined, ..am off to read, ..hopefully i can stay connected long enough!!

Old Scoopy wants to put something out there - everyone asking who is the fourteenth player and is there one left to post. The answer is yes someone hadn't posted until now - me. So if I'm thinking straight Judgemax is saying above here that she hadn't posted yet and she is the fourteenth player. Well, that just can't be folks.

I want a convincing explanation from Judgemax on this or I want to be told there are fifteen players. It can't be that an innocent person would post under an alias and then try and jump in under their real name.

rb is case you missed it Ice confirmed there where 14 yesterday

and I dont know how you missed it as Z posted it a few posts above yours and I quoted it after that....

So how many players are there ? And what do you say about this Judgemax.

Anyone wants to call me out on this and say I'm scum for lurking until now go right aheads - this deserves an explanation.

 

[Rbishop]

Ice or Rb, what's it matter? They're the same age and temperament...

:silly: