Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

[ZSandmann]

I'm with you HN, I thought JM was being her normal self and slipping her role, and the catch by Scoop seemed to confirm it. But I should have retracted my vote as it was a waste.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Oh no not at all. It is obvious that gunslinger will not be the person to start voting for me because he/she/it knows I'm innocent. I am sure that the best vote to hit a mafia tonight is Gunslinger, however I also think Dangerdoll is a good suspect. Are driver and Dangerdoll tied hah yeah I'm skimming, help me out, please ?

I know you are innocent, hah, I guess that makes me mafia...not. And you admit to skimming...I guess you think that using an alias allows you to hide behind the mask and pretend to be a newb. Unless I am wrong everyone here has played before and everyone knows not to skim. Either you are trying to get people to notice you or you are plain ol' scum.

woah there Newbie. I retracted that vote, after it got a little bit of reaction from Gunslinger and Lady G.

Surely you saw that right ?

So you ask Hn if he missed something but you yourself admit to skimming...

OK I am skimming blah blah blah what is the count

My mafia list is Lady G, Gunslinger and Zsandman.

I don't know about Dangerdoll.

I have real suspicion about Hooked Newbie.

I will see you all in Mafia 32

What did you mean by this?

I will stand by my suspicions and vote to lynch Dangerdoll I will not make a nothing vote (Zsandman you are on Judgemax I believe).

Interesting switch. Not sure what exactly to make of it yet but it doesnt help that she came up innocent and you voted her late after claiming that me and G were more suspicious. I understand not wanting to waste a vote but it was a very late switch.

I voted Dangerdoll because I believed her to be more likely to be mafia than Driver, so why let it go to a toss. I made a decision and it was wrong. Of course I wish Dangerdoll was not dead now that I know she was innocent. You can say I nailed her coffin I say yah boo that's the game, I have nothing to be ashamed of except with the benefit of hindsight

Of course ultimately I was not the only player who made a decision on Dangerdoll as the Bounty Hunter was taking Dangerdoll anyway it seems. Lady G you spent a good bit of time making a case against Dangerdoll. Are you taking any credit for this ?

And I was wrong on Judgemax. That was more of a hunch based on saying her alias apparently not working where she seemed to imply that she was the fourteenth player etc. and then did not bother to answer any questions.

I am still going on Lady G, then Gunslinger as being mafia. Could I be wrong. Yes. Are they my best suspects, yes. With Lady G shading Gunslinger slightly.

Hooked Newbie is my next consideration. I know he's voting for me which doesn't really concern me at this point. I threw a vote for Hooked who had none at the time, got a bit of a reaction, and then pulled it pronto. This was by no means a scummy move as far as I'm concerned anyway. I think Hooked is over reacting to this and has no real fair case against me.

So you mean to tell me that you put the vote on hooked, with no reason, to get a reaction? I dont buy that. And it took you until now to make that clear, which also is suspicious.

I will not have you using my failure to answer this silly question as evidence of me being mafia just to get the retaliation in first.

Basically Lady G you appear 'concerned' about lots of stuff but you are low on the specifics. You ask silly questions, and you say silly things which don't really help.

I love that me not explaining to you why I didn't post until 179 is suspicious but you would have been satisfied if I said 'oh I was reading the thread' or 'I've been really busy'.

I don't think I posted odd at all. But of course you are concerned.

I don't love that you lean me more innocent now. This just means I'm to be nailed doesn't it.

Wow, almost the exact same reason why you have my attention.

Aha I just wanted to pull this one up to clarify. Hooked Newbie quotes my vote, then a post from rbishop saying 'give a reason' and then I posted 'And a predict JM is mafia and will die for not voting' and I don't know whether this is seriously considered to be me giving that as a reason for voting Hooked Newbie. I was not posting that as a reason for my vote and I didn't give a reason for voting Hooked Newbie. And we of course know that Judgemax was not in fact on a team but that's irrelevant. Anyway Gunslinger jumped on it. For that and other reasons I have Gunslinger mafia, with Lady G. I might even go and pull out all of the quotes that tend to show this as well. But you can of course read them very easily yourselves.

I think everyone knows that not posting a reason for voting is scummy. That is why it was asked. Then you said that you think jmax would UD so you are switching. Then I asked why you picked Hn of all people, and instead of giving an answer, you jumped right all over me and G.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Just in case scoops doesnt feel like going through and looking for the events from last night, I guess I will

I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie

Vote for Hn with no reason

well, a reason and a bold...?

Rb asks for reason

and I predict that Judgemax is mafia and will die for not voting

Scoop thinks he/she should switch because Jmax will UD

But yours is single and late





Not really a reason for choosing HN...

why the late votes that do not matter? if you had better reasons, ok, but I think something is up

I said that the vote was wasted and scoops "reason" didnt answer why they pick hooked

Very interesting.

Your reason for voting for me (or attempting to) is because your team mate is going to UD? LMAO

Hn comes in and comments

Scoop...I looked back and didn't notice you mention anything about Hooked in prior posts...so why vote him, if you see mafia please let me in on what you see. Is this a new trend....just vote someone random??? Wow, I'm really not understanding what is going on here.

G then steps in and questions scoops choice of voting Hn

Ok the 3rd person's gettin old...

and I am not trying to get you onto a train, just wondering why the heck you picked hooked out of everyone to vote for

I ask again

OK easy call. Lady G and Gunslinger are mafia, so is Judgemax but she will likely not vote and die

Scoop jumps to the conclusion that G and I are mafia.

Oh just in case I forget I retract my vote to lynch Hooked Newbie

Then leaves Hn...must have got the "reaction" they were looking for, or maybe felt the heat.

yeah I retracted on Hooked Newbie.

Gunslinger is mafia, Lady G is mafia, and I think Dangerdoll is mafia too but I am less sure.

Scoop sounds pretty sure G and I are on a mafia team together, then throws DD in there

so lets see if I have this straight...

Me and lady G are mafia because we questioned why you voted hn for no reason (which you have yet to answer exactly why) and then you say DD is mafia...probably just to go with the flow and say that you are right if she turns up mafia tonight...

I dont know if you are in fact scum or just really confused

I ask why he thinks that we are all mafia

No you and G are mafia because that's what your PM from Ice said.

I get this answer.

Ha Ha. Read Gunslinger's posts tell me they do not reek of scummy mafia stuff. The other person who I am thinking of as mafia would be Zsandman. So Gunslinger, Judgemax, Lady G I am pretty sure are mafia, and Dangerdoll and Zsandman are really up there for the scum.

Suddenly adds Zsand to his/her mafia list without stating why

Honey you ARE going to confuse yourself there, you best quit trying to look so out there, before long you wont even know what you are saying.

You think Z is mafia...but have Z and DD really up there???

I think you are trying to get under someone skin to force them off DD and on to you really. Not going to work dear. You could be great for tomorrow, but all your doing is making me feel more and more better about my vote.

G asks what is going on

so you have a whole bunch of names but no reasons other than I have been questioning you, lady g asked why you voted hn, jmax messed up with logins and you happened to catch it, dangerdoll is on almost everyones shortlist, and zsand is another random person you are trying to throw suspicion on...


lady g...I am not bob so why did you quote me? i think you meant his other post

Then I comment on what his/her reasonings are for think G, Zsand, DD, and I are mafia.

There are other posts in between that IMO are not of importance. Feel free to go back and read those, mostly babble from scoop.

My shortlist:

Scoop- see above, putting people on thier mafia list for questioning him/her, not contributing just confusing
Rb- the late switches last night, dday is gone and was the doctor, possibly a set up though
HI IQ- the whole thing with cat/driver still seems suspicious
UhOh- was not thrilled about the responses to why he thought old3toes was bob but nothing else seems scummy yet

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

I might as well get this in now.

I vote to lynch scoop

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Poor JM, the chick gets no respect.

You sure are quick to vote Hooked. I'm going to wait, Gunslinger will be by before long to boss us all around and tell us how we're all stupid blah blah blah. Oh help us great one, lead us to the door of the mafia hideout. If you're short on time just paste the latest chat from the mafia hideout.

So I am mafia and bossy. I may be too puhy for some but only trying to get a goo read on people instead of standing on the sidelines like some people...

 

[ZSandmann]

I am looking for the Don, they have the power to add another Mafia on Night 3 so we need them gone before then.

Hi Bob

This has been discussed to death but here in UhOhs first post they claim that Old3Toes is Bob when Bob was the first to post and clearly said he would not use an alias. This is the first of several instances of scimming I have seen from them, but with only 8 posts it is hard to follow.

Crap it seems those pointing fingers about skimming are the ones doing it themselves. There are less than five mafia right now according to Ice. All this talk of there being possibly 5 mafia at this point is pointless.

Yeah I thought OldToes might be Bob because hey the dude has old toes and he isn't the first one to post under both a real name and an alias in mafia (this very game included). Isn't that right Cat, G...? The fact that G pointed it out herself is comical. Ice hasn't posted the final player list so anyone assuming that Bob couldn't have been OldToes etc. early in day one was missing an obvious possibility.

Gunslinger, dude you're sure worried about everyone's post counts. Whatsup? Worried that innocents won't give you enough circumstantial stuff for you to put a mafia spin on?

Driver/Cat, you're either mafia or an innocent that is going to get yourself hanged if you pull stuff like voting for yourself.

DangerDoll, I don't get the thank you for the hug message only one minute after chastising people for acting like they were trying to get invited to a Wednesday night mafia spaghetti dinner.

I've already made comments about this post but a few additions. Ice said in the start up that these names were drawn at random and they were made for last round so trying to tie Bob to a particular name is a waste. Also, most of UhOhs posts are about the number of Mafia. Yes, it would be nice to know but we can speculate on it till the cows come home, the best way to find out is to lynch some.

Yep, weird that you'd slap hands for being touchy feely just a minute prior.

Dude I agree with you that she looks fishy but it seems you're playing semantics games.

Dude, take a look in the mirror because it is you that needs to read the thread better. Ice has already told us that there are fewer than five mafia right now. Discussing that there could be five now makes no sense unless you're mafia and trying to confuse people or you're generally careless. Which are you? And why are you answering comments pointed at DangerDoll and Cat/Driver?

You might have old toes but you aren't playing like the sage you seem to think you are.

The use of "dude" aside UhOh is focused on O3T and the number of Mafia.

Ice, how about that? A list of who is in or an updated total number of players? For now, because of the scummy twisting of facts I vote to lynch [AC] Old3Toes

Ice had clearly stated 14 players, I agree that Scoop called out JM and still wish we had gotten more info from her. Plus a vote for O3T here for "scummy twisting of facts" which is talking about the number of players.

Poor JM, the chick gets no respect.

You sure are quick to vote Hooked. I'm going to wait, Gunslinger will be by before long to boss us all around and tell us how we're all stupid blah blah blah. Oh help us great one, lead us to the door of the mafia hideout. If you're short on time just paste the latest chat from the mafia hideout.

So here UhOhs list has become: O3T, Gunslinger, and HN. Name calling but no help.

Why do people keep thinking there are possibly 5 mafia at this point when Ice had said there are less than 5? I can't think of many reasons other than mafia wanting us to debate the details instead of looking at the obvious.

**Yawn**

I don't see why they used it on night one when so many of the suspicions are about feelings and other pulled out of the air reasonings.

Scimming the rules of what the BH can do.

Because they are being dense and the town doesn't need dense people. Ice did not say there was a range of 1-5 people. He said more than one and less than 5...LESS THAN FIVE so that would mean 1-4. Mafia loves to misquote and lead the town in different directions to create chaos. Which one are you dude? Are you being dense or are you mafia?

This was directed at me when I tried to rationalize our stats. But in fact UhOh can't even keep their own facts straight. If you follow Ices words literally there would be 2-4 Mafia. Regardless I think I have 1 of them.

I vote to lynch UhOh (Spaghetti O's)

Nothing but arguing and semantics, misdirection, and posts that are made to look helpful but do nothing to help us find Mafia. Also, one of the lowest post counts, I believe Scoop may be another Mafia but after the sideshow before Night fall I do not think they are the Don. If Scoop is Mafia and was trying to draw votes off someone it would have to be Driver but I do not really think Driver is evil, so either Scoop is Innocent and is just a little overexcited or is trying to screw with us.

 

[Rbishop]

Well, last night sucked.Maybe the bodyguard took a chance and wasn't around near nightfall to see how things were progressing...? Who has been absent for a considerable time prior to the nightfall....? and after....?

And Driver really disgusts me....at least if they were going to wimp out and play pouty, they could have pit their vote on no one.

I am leaning Uh Oh and Gunslinger as scum bags right now.

 

[Rbishop]

Driver hasn't even bothered to post since the 15th in the afternoon....maybe they knew things were well in hand.....

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Well, last night sucked.Maybe the bodyguard took a chance and wasn't around near nightfall to see how things were progressing...? Who has been absent for a considerable time prior to the nightfall....? and after....?

And Driver really disgusts me....at least if they were going to wimp out and play pouty, they could have pit their vote on no one.

I am leaning Uh Oh and Gunslinger as scum bags right now.

LOL rb at least get the name of the pr right...bounty hunter?...though I dont think we should be discussing who that person could be as they are on the towns side and any possible ideas could help the mafia, just a thought

though I do agree with you about driver...I really dont like the no-show so far today, and I dont know if this would be considered chaeting but cats profile says that he was on this morning so he should have checked about what happened last night. either he is lying low because he is in fact mafia or is just being a poor sport about what happened

and I have to ask, exactly why are you leaning me towards mafia?

 

[Rbishop]

Well..bodyguard/bounty hunter...what the hey....

I lean you mafia for what I feel is distancing yourself from Lady G....