Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm just going with my thoughts. Scoop's posts were inconsistent and they were the deciding vote. I was big time wrong on DD, but as others have pointed out in past games... my night 1 record sucks. Later nights (when I see them) don't.

 

[Lady G]

CRAP! I hate nights like this!!! So with DD being innocent, what was with all the late night weirdness? I said in the beginning when I first questioned DD, I have been wrong about her before and wanted to hear more from her before I decided on her, instead of coming back as a innocent and trying to help all she did was throw out accusations and excuses.

Very curious too is the fact Driver never came back and posted again or retracted his vote on himself.

Scoop you have me very concerned with all the craziness there toward the end of the night.

RB, I just never know what to think of you....I almost always think you are on the evil side, most of the time you are not as I said I just never know what to make of you.

I really do not see why the bounty hunter used his shot on the person leading in votes...or even in the tie on night one? Although the way nightfall went down DD really did look to be the Don....I just can't imagine it was Driver they were trying to save, I doubt the Don would vote them self.

I just don't know, maybe the ones that were so back and forth really are innocent and really didn't know what they wanted to do, I just don't see them being mafia and looking like it so much if 2 innocents were up? The only logic behind them being mafia would be if Driver IS in fact Mafia...but for them to take such a big risk he would have to be the don, and as I said...I just can't see the Don voting for them self.

Very confusing Night one that is for sure!!

 

[ZSandmann]

Well that stunk guys. I was trying to get home to see if JM ever made it back but I got stuck at work so I apologize for that. Scoop have you forgotten to take your Ridilin? That was some of the best smoke blowing I have ever seen, and I agreed with you about JM so if you think I am Mafia tell me why please. I really would like to know. You are now numero uno on my list.

So we now have 11 players and 4 or 5 of those could be Mafia. We need to try and come together and figure out who the Don is before Night 3. I don't think Scoop is the Don, it would be a stupid ploy.

 

[ZSandmann]

Everyone went to bed I guess.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

More then 1 and less then 5. They also get a chance to add to their team come Night 3 which would be on Sunday night.

Why do people keep thinking there are possibly 5 mafia at this point when Ice had said there are less than 5? I can't think of many reasons other than mafia wanting us to debate the details instead of looking at the obvious.

 

[Lady G]

My mafia list is Lady G, Gunslinger and Zsandman.

I don't know about Dangerdoll.

I have real suspicion about Hooked Newbie.

I will see you all in Mafia 32

I will stand by my suspicions and vote to lynch Dangerdoll I will not make a nothing vote (Zsandman you are on Judgemax I believe).

Scoop, just have a couple questions for you here.

First why DID you wait so long to join in the game? I mean it took 179 posts before Ice could put out a player list.

Then, if you were not sure about DD...why vote her? I know you said you didn't want a wasted vote, but if you are "un" sure of someone and vote them just because...isn't that kind of a wasted vote? I know personally if I do not feel someone is mafia I wont vote them, I would much rather be a lone vote then vote someone I just do not really see a case on?

You said you were "unsure" of DD in one post then turn around and say you are going to stand by your suspicions...even reminding Z where his vote was. You were the deciding vote on her and "nailed her coffin" so to say, why not let it go down to the tie, if you were "unsure"?

 

[Lady G]

Bounty Hunter – You have the ability to negate any lynching any night, no limit..If you think you know a mafia player then you can send a PM/Email to me and say you want to hit so and so, the lynch will not happen and instead your hit will.. The Dr can protect you from a hit or lynch any night EXCEPT on Night 3. That night the Don gets to choose a player to join his team. If you are chosen you die. You will always show as nothing but an innocent unless the Don dies, at that time if you are chosen for investigation your role can be found by the mafia only.

I couldn't for the life of me figure out why the Bounty hunter would take the shot on night one, so I went back and looked over things....I didn't realize they could use it throughout the game, I was thinking it was a one time thing, now I can see why they did what they did.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

I voted Dangerdoll because I believed her to be more likely to be mafia than Driver, so why let it go to a toss. I made a decision and it was wrong. Of course I wish Dangerdoll was not dead now that I know she was innocent. You can say I nailed her coffin I say yah boo that's the game, I have nothing to be ashamed of except with the benefit of hindsight

Of course ultimately I was not the only player who made a decision on Dangerdoll as the Bounty Hunter was taking Dangerdoll anyway it seems. Lady G you spent a good bit of time making a case against Dangerdoll. Are you taking any credit for this ?

And I was wrong on Judgemax. That was more of a hunch based on saying her alias apparently not working where she seemed to imply that she was the fourteenth player etc. and then did not bother to answer any questions.

I am still going on Lady G, then Gunslinger as being mafia. Could I be wrong. Yes. Are they my best suspects, yes. With Lady G shading Gunslinger slightly.

Hooked Newbie is my next consideration. I know he's voting for me which doesn't really concern me at this point. I threw a vote for Hooked who had none at the time, got a bit of a reaction, and then pulled it pronto. This was by no means a scummy move as far as I'm concerned anyway. I think Hooked is over reacting to this and has no real fair case against me.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

Scoop, just have a couple questions for you here.

First why DID you wait so long to join in the game? I mean it took 179 posts before Ice could put out a player list.

...

You said you were "unsure" of DD in one post then turn around and say you are going to stand by your suspicions...even reminding Z where his vote was. You were the deciding vote on her and "nailed her coffin" so to say, why not let it go down to the tie, if you were "unsure"?

Why so long ? Bladda Bladda Bladda why would you care if I didn't post for 179 posts a)this is a red herring thrown out by you. b) are you saying its scummy to post first post late ? c)Do you really want to know why I 'waited' so long, why would you care ?

My vote on Dangerdoll already explained. I can say no more than that between Dangerdoll and Driver I felt more strongly that Dangerdoll was mafia than Driver. I have a vote, I used it. Unfortunately I was wrong.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

I couldn't for the life of me figure out why the Bounty hunter would take the shot on night one, so I went back and looked over things....I didn't realize they could use it throughout the game, I was thinking it was a one time thing, now I can see why they did what they did.

I don't see why they used it on night one when so many of the suspicions are about feelings and other pulled out of the air reasonings.