Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

OgreMkV said:
From Ice:
Day 3

RB-2-Bkw(468)Ogre(481)Zsand(526)Old(538)
Bkw-2-Old3toes(470)LG(476)Ogre(480)Old(546)
scoop-2-RB(482)Zsand(484)Ogre(524)
Z-1-Coler(486)


1) All this might not matter anyway depending on what the BH does.

2) I'm thinking that Coler/scoop is staying out of the limelight by not getting involved in a vote.

2a) Look at it this way, say two of the top vote getters are mafia (rb and scoop), then Coler can't change to himself and he can't change to rb. That means he must change to BKW, which means an innocent gets lynched.
Crap, that would mean we lose regardless.

That being said, then either rb and/or coler are planning a last minute vote change to BKW to kill the last innocent player.

But they might be hesitant to do so because of the bounty hunter's role and then they would be known mafia.

Like RB said, any switchers at this point, will almost be assumed mafia and it might not matter anyway with the BH. I guess it all depends on the BH tonight.
Click to expand...

ZS your thinking is pretty much the same as Ogre's last night on me and RB (known mafia) - and you'll note Lady G sitting there on bkw last night...as was Old3toes before his excellent switch to Ogre, leaving Lady G all on her lonesome. Same rationale applies to why Old3toes is more likely a turn - because he was gunning for bkw, and wouldn't have to shift radically in public to continue to do so. Difference is Old3toes was central to nailing Ogre last night - indicative of Old3toes being innocent at that time.
 
Okey Dokey - I'm probably going to be back on before nightfall but possibly not. So I retract my vote to lynch ZS and vote to lynch Scoop.

Reason - this gives me 2 votes - I am hoping the town will come on board me and protect bkw from being top vote winner. The votes on me are ZS and myself - rb you can add yours and give me 3, and then even if ZS shifts off onto bkw (the death knell for ZS in fairness), bkw can save himself by voting me up to 4 and then bkw cannot be vote leader or tied for vote leader.

I stress again the rationale for the roles which I've described in earlier posts, and also that bkw is a claimed BH, entirely consistent with the action on night 2.

In the event that the mafia spitefully take me out instead of the BH - my turn nominee is Old3toes, turned for already stated reasons (already angling for bkw) and Lady G is my other mafia candidate. If I go, please don't be swayed by the whole 'they killed him because he was wrong and they wanted a smokescreen argument'.
 
well, what you gonna do, bk?
 
Scoop, you sure are trying hard to protect the Don.

I think everyone sees through all of this. I was not turned, maybe you were, but I was not. I am wondering if ZS is mafia and now you are protecting him also.

You do not have us fooled. BKW is the Don.
 
lol gotta go again for a bit.

Look guys its real real simple :

If bkw is the don, who I am protecting, you can all vote me and lynch me and I will be dead...and if the BH is convinced bkw is the don then take the shot; I'm amazed that you people who are campaigning for this have not once said explicitly 'Hey BH take the shot on bkw he's the don'...funny how the small subconscious slips can bit you in the ass; you know bkw is the BH - even ZS knows this.

If bkw is the BH - lets get another vote on me; pretty much talking to you there rbishop as you are my most likely candidate for innocence amongst ZS, Old3toes, Lady g and yourself.

(now we have old3toes saying ZS is possible mafia...why ? I'll tell you why, because when ZS is shot he is going to show as mafia and Old3toes is looking for a bolthole for tomorrow).
 
so if bkw doesn't come back on....?

has he already saved himself once...?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom