You know what I don't like is the 'lets all pull together and focus on two players'. You know the whole, 'the town is all over the place, we need to pull together'. This line of thinking for me becomes relevant on crunch nights later in the game. Early in the game with some pretty basic but effective manipulation it is a real mafia tactic, by isolating two real innocents and getting every one to focus on them.
I think the reason however in part at least in this game that is has not happened to the same extent on Day 1 is that there are two unconnected Mafia teams who can't co-ordinate with each other.
I'm not sure where that gets us but those are my thoughts. I suppose I am identifying that I think putting out a call to 'lets all come together on a couple of possible lynch candidates' is to me a bit scummy on day one.