Mafia #32 LMAO

[[AC] C-note]

Before you start thinking of me as a suspect because of her list please go back to the posts of mine she pulled and tell me why she couldn't understand them. I thought they were fairly simple posts and her not grasping them was an act to try and twist them.

I explained them for her in detail in post 249.She is referring to posts 106 and 162. I think they are pretty self explanatory.

Yes, I saw where she misunderstood your post when you had stated that the Mafia are looking for easy targets like Lady G AND newbs. She thought you were calling her a newb. I had you leaning innocent early on in the game as I agreed with most of your points so you're not the one I'm most concerned about on her list.

 

[catfish69hunter]

Im sorry i made a mistake and didnt look back at the first page for a 3rd time last night to see the colors and the right name but atleast i remembered it off the top of my head that the teams had a color to thier name to look at it. Also as for the 6 mafia idea that came from the fact that on average there are 3 mafia on a team when there are single teams and also there are now 2 team. Do I need to do 2 + 2 math for you here? Or are you trying your damnest to redirect you italian Unstallion.

 

[ZSandmann]

This actually makes more sense then the C-note thing, i dont think rb would make it that obvious, and "sees" sounds more like Zs, plus i bet it talkin bout the color of team harpo. The final nail in the coffin is how Z jumped on the chance to direct the clue away from himself to C-note.



Z how familar are you with Mr. Harpo Marx

I vote to lynch Zsand

if Z is mafia im betting ogre is on his team

maybe i need to rethink what i said about ogre being on Zs team. your voting for him for gettin the team colors mixed up and guessing at the number of mafia there are? I could understand voting C-note atleast you could hide behind the clue, but this reason is just lame.

Cat i think ur right about he Z thing, and i think Z and wing are tryin to redirect it.

I was wondering who would flip it on me but I didn't expect it to be you Bkw. Sees is much more phonetic to C than to Z, but as I said it was a lame reason. If I hadn't brought it up though I am sure someone would have, and I was one of the few that actually stuck around for night and tried to have a discussion. I am not a big fan of the clues, I have said that all along, I think the game should be allowed to run on its own, but if one comes out that seems straightforward I fully intend on exploring it.

I retract my vote on C-Note.

They were upfront about the clue and didn't come out swinging like some (Catfish and Bkw). I will vote based on actions not an obscure clue from Rb. But it has got my attention and I will watch C-Note closer than I was before.

Wing Nut has been in a posting frenzy, it makes me think that they feel they have something to prove.

Pixl has gone quiet since almost getting lynched on Day 1. I wish the majority had stuck to their guns and lynched them. I am still pretty sure those Day 1 posts were a new player trying too hard to blend in. Now I'm not faulting anyone who voted for LG because she was acting off, but I just thought there were better suspects.

Unfortunately the detective never got an invest so looking at JL and LGs posts won't help us that much, we can see who they suspected but they had no hard evidence. I assume from the way it went down that LG was the Doctor and JL was the Detective, because otherwise LG could have came out to save herself hopefully lasted another day. Tough call for her I am sure.

 

[catfish69hunter]

Talk about redirecting.

Why would one assume 6 mafia players unless they know there are 6? I assumed 4 being the safe number. With 6 mafia the game could be over by night 2 if hits and lynchings go correctly.I don't think Bob would set it up to be possible for that quick of a game.

The reason I'm picking up and bringing out the fact he told us the wrong color for the wrong team is because I think he is trying to make us think the team other then his made the hit.

Hey wing guess what mafia are only able to know thier half or do you keep forgetting the rules???? I mean come on if i was mafia how would i know there are 6 HUH? your really pushing now to redirect this another way. Unless you want to put yourself in a bigger hole i suggest you go back and read the rules before you make accusations about the Player knowledge base.

 

[catfish69hunter]

Totally missed that in the rules that Harpo is green. Makes more sense as Bob is showing who got the hit. Now I'm not so sure about the word actually being a clue and that its just the color.

Hey catfish in your post didn't you say groucho was green?

Looks like you did. That together with the post quoted about 6 mafia players 3 on each team is enough for me at this moment to say I Vote to Lynch Catfish.

Talk about redirecting.

Why would one assume 6 mafia players unless they know there are 6? I assumed 4 being the safe number. With 6 mafia the game could be over by night 2 if hits and lynchings go correctly.I don't think Bob would set it up to be possible for that quick of a game.

The reason I'm picking up and bringing out the fact he told us the wrong color for the wrong team is because I think he is trying to make us think the team other then his made the hit.

Sorry some how this didnt attach to my post back on post number #322

 

[ZSandmann]

Hey wing guess what mafia are only able to know thier half or do you keep forgetting the rules???? I mean come on if i was mafia how would i know there are 6 HUH? your really pushing now to redirect this another way. Unless you want to put yourself in a bigger hole i suggest you go back and read the rules before you make accusations about the Player knowledge base.

I don't trust either one of you father than I can throw you but the rules say the Mafia win when they outnumber the Innocents, not when one of the Mafia teams outnumbers the Innocents. I know that is how it has played in the past, but the rules are not specific in this instance as to which is the case. A clarification from Rb would be nice.

 

[ZSandmann]

What the hell

I vote to lynch Pixl.

You've all but disappeared from the game, you had funny early posts and then waited till the last minute to throw in a dumb vote with no explanation on someone that was already standing on the gallows. I know you are new, but you can't hide from the scales of justice. Prepare to meet your maker, the great ceiling cat demands it.

 

[[AC] C-note]

Unfortunately the detective never got an invest so looking at JL and LGs posts won't help us that much, we can see who they suspected but they had no hard evidence. I assume from the way it went down that LG was the Doctor and JL was the Detective, because otherwise LG could have came out to save herself hopefully lasted another day. Tough call for her I am sure.

What makes you think the detective and doctor are gone??? The nighttime narrations clearly stated Lady G and John were communicating innocents. Are you purposely trying to frighten the town? In the sign up thread RB said he would add communicating innocents if enough players joined.

With 16 to start and 2 communicating innocents, it might be more likely that there are 3 mafia in each of the teams instead of 2 like I had thought. That would mean 6 Mafia and 8 innocents (including detective and doc) are left. It looks like we need to get a Mafia soon as there is next to no room for error.

 

[OgreMkV]

Oh, before I forget I saw Ogre and Pix viewing the thread around midnight EST last night.

Ogre and Pix, do you care to share why you didn't care to post anything last night?

1st, I always leave a window with Mafia Games open, so I should always be showing as 'on'.

2nd, I've a got a 16th month old and a wife with a kidney infection, I'mm trying to keep up, but it's not as much fun as it sounds.

I was wondering who would flip it on me but I didn't expect it to be you Bkw. Sees is much more phonetic to C than to Z, but as I said it was a lame reason. If I hadn't brought it up though I am sure someone would have, and I was one of the few that actually stuck around for night and tried to have a discussion. I am not a big fan of the clues, I have said that all along, I think the game should be allowed to run on its own, but if one comes out that seems straightforward I fully intend on exploring it.

I retract my vote on C-Note.

They were upfront about the clue and didn't come out swinging like some (Catfish and Bkw). I will vote based on actions not an obscure clue from Rb. But it has got my attention and I will watch C-Note closer than I was before.

Wing Nut has been in a posting frenzy, it makes me think that they feel they have something to prove.

Pixl has gone quiet since almost getting lynched on Day 1. I wish the majority had stuck to their guns and lynched them. I am still pretty sure those Day 1 posts were a new player trying too hard to blend in. Now I'm not faulting anyone who voted for LG because she was acting off, but I just thought there were better suspects.

Unfortunately the detective never got an invest so looking at JL and LGs posts won't help us that much, we can see who they suspected but they had no hard evidence. I assume from the way it went down that LG was the Doctor and JL was the Detective, because otherwise LG could have came out to save herself hopefully lasted another day. Tough call for her I am sure.

First, let me say that I know RB does 'clues' and I hate them. About 1/3 of the players spend the next day trying to decipher the clues instead of looking for additional evidence one way or another. The whole Cs, Zs thing is just silly. The only thing I'd be willing to entertain (i.e. it seems most reasonable) is that the green mafia team got the hit last night. And that's not really relevent to the game, at this time. [Maybe much later when we start killing mafia, it might be interesting, but probably not useful.]

Now, pixl, his rampant posting early on and subsequent quiet still places him on my mafia list.

Wingnut is still a concern, but looking better.

bkw suddenly appears with his Zsand theory. The only thing that bothers me is that I have a hunch about Zsand. IMO, he's playing much like he has previously as mafia. I think (again, IMO) that I have a pretty good read on him and his style as innocent and mafia and ONLY based on that I'm leaning mafia. Is it enough to vote on, I'm not sure.

My comments about G's role and being useful to finding out others information is interesting. Some others have already mentioned a few things. I'll take a better look when I'm not at work.

On that note, why didn't RB say that they were the doc and the det? He didn't mention other innocents that could communicate.

 

[OgreMkV]

What makes you think the detective and doctor are gone??? The nighttime narrations clearly stated Lady G and John were communicating innocents. Are you purposely trying to frighten the town? In the sign up thread RB said he would add communicating innocents if enough players joined.

With 16 to start and 2 communicating innocents, it might be more likely that there are 3 mafia in each of the teams instead of 2 like I had thought. That would mean 6 Mafia and 8 innocents (including detective and doc) are left. It looks like we need to get a Mafia soon as there is next to no room for error.

He didn't mention them in the first post of the game. I just checked. If he said it in the signup thread... well, I don't take that as gospel.

In a 2 mafia group game, one team of mafia must have more mafia than the remaining innocents. It's not both combined (at least it hasn't been in the past.)