Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

Not sure...maybe you???
 
Here's my thoughts on the last 24hrs events. I would rather take Ogre up on their offer to vote for Ogre in lieu of Jensons. My reasoning is this...If Jensons is in fact the Bot we can't afford to lose her as the Bot seems to be the only innocent who knows what EA is thinking right now and/or knows who EA is. If we vote Jensons and she turns out to be innocent we may lose two innocents and a 3rd to a turn or a kill ---> This lynch yourself deal between Ogre and JL66 is ludicrous...I agree with Plant on this one. If we vote to lynch Ogre and they turn out to be evil we know to go for Jensons the next night. If Ogre turns out innocent we should know that Jensons is innocent because why the heck would an innocent be defending an evil? Does this make sense to anyone else?

As of right now I will not place my vote on Ogre or Jensons as I don't feel my vote is needed for the Town to currently get what it wants. Besides I am not sold on the fact that either of them is evil. I'll be keeping my vote where it is unless something new comes up.
 
Here's my thoughts on the last 24hrs events. I would rather take Ogre up on their offer to vote for Ogre in lieu of Jensons. My reasoning is this...If Jensons is in fact the Bot we can't afford to lose her as the Bot seems to be the only innocent who knows what EA is thinking right now and/or knows who EA is. If we vote Jensons and she turns out to be innocent we may lose two innocents and a 3rd to a turn or a kill ---> This lynch yourself deal between Ogre and JL66 is ludicrous...I agree with Plant on this one. If we vote to lynch Ogre and they turn out to be evil we know to go for Jensons the next night. If Ogre turns out innocent we should know that Jensons is innocent because why the heck would an innocent be defending an evil? Does this make sense to anyone else?

As of right now I will not place my vote on Ogre or Jensons as I don't feel my vote is needed for the Town to currently get what it wants. Besides I am not sold on the fact that either of them is evil. I'll be keeping my vote where it is unless something new comes up.
I've thought that too...but a couple problems I see with it.

1) I do not see Ogre as the EA, and IF Jensons IS then they can get another turn and just loose Ogre rather he is innocent or evil it would not gain us anything, unless he IS the EA.

2)Say Jensons IS innocent, if the evil see her as the possible DR, she will be turned.

3) Just because Ogre comes up either innocent or evil truely has NO baring on what Jens is. If he comes up Innocent unless he his the Det and KNOWS she is the Dr. there is no way he knows for sure and it proves nothing except the fact he THINKS she is. IF he is evil it still proves nothing about Jens as he could be protecting his EA OR he could be setting up an innocent.
 
Oh there is one other thing that i don't get,,, ORGE how is G innocent if your and jensons are innocent it doesn't make sence to me. Just because one player is innocent doesn't have any bearings on another.
 
I've thought that too...but a couple problems I see with it.

1) I do not see Ogre as the EA, and IF Jensons IS then they can get another turn and just loose Ogre rather he is innocent or evil it would not gain us anything, unless he IS the EA.

2)Say Jensons IS innocent, if the evil see her as the possible DR, she will be turned.

3) Just because Ogre comes up either innocent or evil truely has NO baring on what Jens is. If he comes up Innocent unless he his the Det and KNOWS she is the Dr. there is no way he knows for sure and it proves nothing except the fact he THINKS she is. IF he is evil it still proves nothing about Jens as he could be protecting his EA OR he could be setting up an innocent.

I can see your point but why would an evil be so adamant about setting up an innocent (Jensons) if Jensons already has several votes and looks like a definite lynch. Why would an evil out themselves if they didn't have to. I just can't see it. I guess Ogre could be accused of the same thing Chill is being accused of...an evil protecting a known innocent to help prove their innocence after the lynch happens. I just see that logic as even more of a reason to lynch Ogre...and why the heck would an innocent ever protect someone else to the level Ogre is unless they had hard evidence. I'm not going to fight for this but I wanted to get my thoughts out there.
 
AquariaCentral.com