Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness
- Thread starter ZSandmann
- Start date
G, I think this was the chain of posts that had you looking more closely at DD. It made me raise my brows also. It was Cap that made that odd post then DD seemed to read a bit into it:
So it's not a lot but just enough to make me wonder. But DD is a good vet player and she should be quite good at distancing. And I recall that she also pushed a bit for RB's lynching.
And it appears here that DD is hesitating some more and perhaps diverting attention Ogre's way.
Here DD voted Jensons a few hours later.
Here she seems to hesitate again throwing doubt about Jenson's being evil.
So it's not a lot but just enough to make me wonder. But DD is a good vet player and she should be quite good at distancing. And I recall that she also pushed a bit for RB's lynching.
Okay let’s assume Plant is telling the truth. If she’s not, she’s evil and there are two innocents who would know she was lying and could easily speak out against her thereby ending the game. So I think it’s a pretty safe assumption. The list below is copied from G’s but I think it’s correct (if it’s not please let me know). I’ve reordered it to make sense to me. The first seven are the possible evil, they are in no particular order.
Dangerdoll
Lady G
johnlarson66
Chill
judgemax
dirtydawg10
plantling - ash
bkw1982 – investigated innocent
pixl8r Uded -Innocent
aquaparadise10-Uded-Innocent
OgreMkV-committed suicide-Innocent
rbishop-Lynched-innocent
Hooked Newbie-Hit-Innocent
Jensons-EA II
catfish69hunter-Lynched EA 1
Dangerdoll
Lady G
johnlarson66
Chill
judgemax
dirtydawg10
plantling - ash
bkw1982 – investigated innocent
pixl8r Uded -Innocent
aquaparadise10-Uded-Innocent
OgreMkV-committed suicide-Innocent
rbishop-Lynched-innocent
Hooked Newbie-Hit-Innocent
Jensons-EA II
catfish69hunter-Lynched EA 1
Of the six. Everyone knows their own nature be that good or evil. Plant can withhold her vote on the bot so that person cannnot be turned with the book. That means even if it was purely random everyone has a 1 in 4 chance of picking the evil correctly.
I'm saying we should agree to ask the holder of the book to use it on anyone we can get a consensus of 7 votes on (the 7 includes bkw's and plant's votes).
In addtion to the turn vote, we pick a second choice for the lynch. If the turn does not end the game, we lynch the second choice tonight and the turned person the next night. That gives us a 50% chance of ending this in two nights.
Not using the book runs the risk of it falling into the deadite's hands and increasing their numbers.
I'm saying we should agree to ask the holder of the book to use it on anyone we can get a consensus of 7 votes on (the 7 includes bkw's and plant's votes).
In addtion to the turn vote, we pick a second choice for the lynch. If the turn does not end the game, we lynch the second choice tonight and the turned person the next night. That gives us a 50% chance of ending this in two nights.
Not using the book runs the risk of it falling into the deadite's hands and increasing their numbers.
Here's what I think of the players left:
Dangerdoll- good pick for the turn b/c had no votes, low suspicion level, low poster, causes no waves, and Mod poweres come in handy.
Lady G-bad pick for turn, had 4 votes at one point, always suspected, oodles of post and many waves
BKW- confirmed villager
JL- he also pushed very hard for RB's lynch but he was the 2nd vote on Jensons lynch train and first after HN pulled off. I'm pretty sure a turn would not be an early vote on their leader, not when there are so many that suspicion can be pushed on, like low posters, and new players. Jensons tried to get him lynched very late last night.
Chill-was the leading vote getter on the night of the turn, also voted by Jensons two nights and her negativity towards him were too severe to be distancing, IMO.
JudgeMax-low votes or suspicion night of turn. Vet player good at laying low, hesitated to vote for JM and was one of the last voters. However she seemed to want Ogre to stay in the game even after Jensons was proven EAII.
Plant- I'm Ash
Dawg- He had two votes the night of the turn. However he was the lone vote on Cap last night and didn't believe Jensons to be evil.
Cap-had no votes the night of the turn, good new player, also good turn. Last to vote Jensons.
Dangerdoll- good pick for the turn b/c had no votes, low suspicion level, low poster, causes no waves, and Mod poweres come in handy.
Lady G-bad pick for turn, had 4 votes at one point, always suspected, oodles of post and many waves
BKW- confirmed villager
JL- he also pushed very hard for RB's lynch but he was the 2nd vote on Jensons lynch train and first after HN pulled off. I'm pretty sure a turn would not be an early vote on their leader, not when there are so many that suspicion can be pushed on, like low posters, and new players. Jensons tried to get him lynched very late last night.
Chill-was the leading vote getter on the night of the turn, also voted by Jensons two nights and her negativity towards him were too severe to be distancing, IMO.
JudgeMax-low votes or suspicion night of turn. Vet player good at laying low, hesitated to vote for JM and was one of the last voters. However she seemed to want Ogre to stay in the game even after Jensons was proven EAII.
Plant- I'm Ash
Dawg- He had two votes the night of the turn. However he was the lone vote on Cap last night and didn't believe Jensons to be evil.
Cap-had no votes the night of the turn, good new player, also good turn. Last to vote Jensons.
