Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

johnlarson66 said:
Lady G, why am I suspicious? Why should there be a death from me? Why would I be a suspect? If I was evil, why would I lead the charge to lynch EAII. I would do whatever I could to keep EAII alive. I certainly would not lynch them. The lone deadite has a long and hard battle, once this book stuff is handled, they have no power.

This post is very suspicious. I am wondering when you jumped on the Jensons train. Was it already rolling? If the suspects already listed are cleared, I hope you will be looked into.
Click to expand...
I think you skimmed over her post where she went back and pulled up the deal that you and Ogre made. :) You'd said you'd lynch yourself if Jensons was innocent. And I agree that you probably wouldn't have been among the first to vote your leader. And they would not have cast a lot of suspicion your way and vote you and try to get others to join in the last half hour of the day, not when there were easier targets.
 
Dangerdoll said:
whoa... I have been sick in bed and I come in to seeing that I am the topic of John's plan?? First to clear the air... Jens did not turn me, I am innocent and always have been. I don't have the book, thank God too because I wouldn't even know what to do with it.

for the record, great job on Jensons... just when I was doubting that we were on the right path, I stuck to the plan and she was EA after all!! way to go, us!!
Click to expand...
LOL, DD. Hope you feel better soon, but I guess you must have skipped over the part where I suggested the plan first, not John. I agree he seems very suspicious to a lot of folks and did jump all over RB AND made that deal with Ogre that caused Ogre to forfeit from the game. But he didn't hesitate to lynch Jensons. Actually I went back and saw that he had Jensons as a suspect fairly early on after the role of EAII was given out. But maybe I should investigate him instead of Dawg just to make sure. I think the majority of the town has agreed to turn you though. But if you are innocent now and become evil, be sure to act real mean or something so we can tell.
 
After a nice afternoon of lying in the warm sun, drinking cold beer, and watching the pretty iridescent fish break the stillness of the brook as they leap in the sun, Chill begrudgingly gets to his feet and heads back to town.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I like this idea, but with a twist.

The book is used on DD. If she was evil, the game is over. If the game is not over, that means she was innocent, but we have made her evil. So then we lynch DD. As long as DD does not have the book, this plan is good. Who ever has the book should come out and use it before nightfall.

Does everyone understand why I have added this twist to the plan? Let's discus it if there is any doubt. I could be wrong and my idea is no good. I have not had as much time as I wanted to read up. I fell asleep last night and things are real real busy right now.

I agree that you should investigate Dawg.

I retract my vote on Dawg and vote to lynch DangerDoll

I could see Jensons turning DangerDoll.
Click to expand...

The problem I have with this is if DD is turned we know who she is and can pick her off anytime. I like the odds better on trying another person for the lynch in the hopes of catching the unknown evil quicker. I'm fine either way though and will go with whatever the groups decides.
 
plantling said:
LOL, DD. Hope you feel better soon, but I guess you must have skipped over the part where I suggested the plan first, not John. I agree he seems very suspicious to a lot of folks and did jump all over RB AND made that deal with Ogre that caused Ogre to forfeit from the game. But he didn't hesitate to lynch Jensons. Actually I went back and saw that he had Jensons as a suspect fairly early on after the role of EAII was given out. But maybe I should investigate him instead of Dawg just to make sure. I think the majority of the town has agreed to turn you though. But if you are innocent now and become evil, be sure to act real mean or something so we can tell.
Click to expand...

We said consenus are we going to settle for majority now?
 
Chill said:
The problem I have with this is if DD is turned we know who she is and can pick her off anytime. I like the odds better on trying another person for the lynch in the hopes of catching the unknown evil quicker. I'm fine either way though and will go with whatever the groups decides.
Click to expand...
Well actually there's a saying in this game, "The only good Mafia is a dead Mafia". It makes sense to get rid of someone we KNOW is evil as opposed to someone only we suspect. If we lynch wrong as well as turn wrong there will definitely be two around the next day. What does everyone think?
Chill said:
We said consenus are we going to settle for majority now?
Click to expand...
I doubt we are going to get 100% as the lone evil will most likely not go along. There's still time to decide if folks want to lynch DD or Cap, though. But my pick for turn still remains DD.
 
I now think it was a mistake to tie the three things together. The lynching should remain majority.

Can we get a consensus on turn DD and investigate Dawg. This allows Cap to vote on these two propositions without lynching himself. Dawg shouldn't have any problem with being investigated as he was willing to be turned earlier.

I'd count anyone who voted for the 3 proposals as still being in favour of the turn and investigation, unless they state otherwise.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom