Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

[Lady G]

Just a quick check in here....

Glad you wore the cape, wouldn't want to have to pick with you to much, ..lmao!!!

well, if the book holder is evil, and that is a huge if, ..that would have been a smart move to gain another evil....so, again, we are back to wondering who had the book and if they were infact evil.

Jmax...if the holder is innocent, they would of went with the wishes of the town, I'm not sure I believe DD, we will find out at nightfall...IMO, that is why it is important for us to lynch DD tonight, then we will know for sure. If DD shows as innocent we know there are now 2 evils.

 

[ZSandmann]

1 LG: Cap
6 DD: JL, Plant, Dirty, BKW, LG, Chill
2 Cap: JM, DD

All have voted. Emails Please!
A little over 6 hours till Night!

 

[dirtydawg10]

I don't read that in the same way. I see if the book holder was evil, big if, end of statement.

There's no comment on his being innocent and going against the wishes of the town.

If he was evil he could have went against the wishes of the town, but we don't know that he went against the wishes of the town. The smart play is to assume he did as the town directed. If DD was turned she would of course say she wasn't.

Why are you answering for JM? I find that interesting as well.

 

[Chill]

I was wondering how you could interpret this the way you did? As I said before I'm a bit suspicious of you and would not want to see the investigation moved off you this evenings. I'm also a bit weary of deviating from the plan on the assumption that the bookholder might be evil. My thoughts on that, are the book could have been used at any time and if it was in evil hands it would have been used right away. It was a dicey proposition for the good side as they did not know who was evil, however evil knows whose who and would have used it as soon as they got their hands on it.

 

[judgemax]

Why are you answering for JM? I find that interesting as well.

why does it seem to me you are getting more and more desperate to get the investigation switched off you?..your miss reading posts, ...chill had it right, ..i was questioning DD in a round about way, ..since she claimed she got no PM...

 

[Chill]

Don't forget the turn was on night 1. If Jenson's team had the book she would have recruited then and possibly saved herself. There was no turn on night 2 it was blocked. Why would the evil team sit on the book when it had so much value.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I was wondering how you could interpret this the way you did? As I said before I'm a bit suspicious of you and would not want to see the investigation moved off you this evenings. I'm also a bit weary of deviating from the plan on the assumption that the bookholder might be evil. My thoughts on that, are the book could have been used at any time and if it was in evil hands it would have been used right away. It was a dicey proposition for the good side as they did not know who was evil, however evil knows whose who and would have used it as soon as they got their hands on it.

why does it seem to me you are getting more and more desperate to get the investigation switched off you?..your miss reading posts, ...chill had it right, ..i was questioning DD in a round about way, ..since she claimed she got no PM...

I read it wrong, I guess, and so did LadyG. I have no issue with being investigated.

I agree with you Chill, as I was wondering why the evil (if they had the book) would not have used it right away. DD's post saying she hadn't been turned is what caused my concern. The obvious post saying she had not been turned may have been her hint that she was in fact turned. I would guess that she cannot reveal the truth to us.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Just a quick check in here....


Jmax...if the holder is innocent, they would of went with the wishes of the town, I'm not sure I believe DD, we will find out at nightfall...IMO, that is why it is important for us to lynch DD tonight, then we will know for sure. If DD shows as innocent we know there are now 2 evils.

I agree with the first part. We already know there are 2 evils though. The only option is there is 2 evils or no evils. Since the game didn't end there are 2 evils. One of them may or may not be DD.

 

[Dangerdoll]

one of them isn't me, I was never turned.... but since Z says the book was used, it was used on someone.... I'm thinking the holder of the book has to be an evil if they used it and tried to frame me for it, just to get everyone to get me, another innocent lynched out. The plan was laid out way too detailed for the Evils... bnow they are having their way and it looks like I am the skape goat for the night *sigh*

 

[plantling]

Going back to the night of the turn, this was the vote count b4 Jensons voted for Chill and supposedly was gone for the rest of the night:

Jensons: HN, LG
RB: BKW, JM
Chill: JL, RB, Ogre
LG: Dirty, Plant
JM: Pixl
Dirty: Cap

Since it no longer appears that DD was the pick, the only players left without a vote on them that night are BKW, JL, and Cap, and myself. But one of the main reasons Jensons was suspected of being the pick for EAII was that she wasn't suspected before so maybe she picked someone who was a little suspected but not enough to be lynched. So ruling out Chill and G, I would say maybe JM and Dirty should be looked at a little harder.

The thread is quiet, ..Its almost to quiet, ..i just can't help but wonder if someone is sitting smug, in the fact that a train has started down the tracks..

This was posted when Jensons was in the lead with votes.

well, I guess its now a stale mate until jensons is lynched,,,I always hate when so may players are on one person, ..and no one posts, ..

Another post right before nightfall. This appeared like Judge might have been inching her way towards a vote change, but I posted right after this stating I thought any who were changing their votes to John were suspect. Keep in mind that the evils knew or highly suspected me to be Ash at this point.

well, HN, I guess you were right, and should know at this point to not doubt you! congrats on sticking to your guns all!!

So, ..ogre must be number 2, .

why did you go so far out on a limb ogre?..

Right after night Judge points at Ogre.

Sorry, Hooked. I guess they thought you were a PR.

And Dangit Ogre, why'd you have to be so sure of Jensons. I hope you've learned your lesson for future games! But now we're short two villagers.

Hope there is only one left. IMO, it's likely to be Judge, DD, Pix, or Cap. Going back to the night when the turn was turned, Chill, Jensons, RB, LG, and Dawg had 2 or 3 votes. It would have been too daring to pick them as they might have been lynched.

I made a list of who I thought should be looked at.

why7 does it not have to be you lol, ..and i can assure you its not me, ..but I am agreeing on PIX, or DD I think, since it was jensons, ..that maybe she changed DD?..

Judge points to DD and Pix. Well Pix we know is innocent and DD appears to have been.

I am not real sure why any of you would feel I am the turn?..I don't know jensons that well, and have actually never played on a team with her. I can't stress enough for any vet player, it would be dumb to turn me, i never live, ..lmao, ..but feel free to investigate me...

I'll have to go back and check other games, but can anyone dispute this statement by Judge that she's not a good evil because she never lies?