Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

Lady G said:
So, what I am thinking at this point is (LOL ready for this Jmax and HN:silly:).

Anyway, I do not see a BRAND new player being Ash/ly....I don't really see Cat either, Pix...yes possible, not saying he is but if I were a Mod...I could see that one. Jensons, Ogre, RB, Plant, HN or John of the vets. narrowing down from there...Jensons does get questioned and accused alot and many times lynched early, so personally I would not of gone with her. HN, and John...well they get questioned quite a bit and depending on the town they either believe then and follow their thoughts and they make it quite a bit further, or they are lynched...I MAY go with them but I'm not sure...IF I were the Mod, I really would want a player that was maybe going to last at least close to the end, Ogre....well he is a good player another one that is questioned from the start usually for some small thing that gets blown way out of proportion, but ultimately getting him lynched. RB, he is a hard one for ppl to figure out...never really says much talks in circles (confusing) quite a bit and usually can last a while. Plant, well she is a great player also...if she is innocent, usually "hit" pretty early..but the town tends to follow her thoughts.

So of these players IF I were the MOD...I could see myself going with Pix, Plant or RB most likely.
Click to expand...

OMG.... :eek: Coherent thoughts?! You must be drunk.... :laugh:
 
Okay here's my thoughts - I'm a noob so take them with a grain of salt and if I'm out to lunch chalk it up as inexperience.

I don't see entrusting sole evil role to someone new; it would be likely they would slip up and bring the game to an early close.
Don't see it being cat. He could be lynched even if people knew he was innocent. Also he defended RB when it would have been easy to jump on the bandwagon. No potential in the sole evil defending innocents.
Some of the more high profile players (Lady G, JM) are to big a risk of getting lynched early to entrust with sole evil.

You really need an experienced player who is well liked and doesn't garner a lot of suspicion.

My spidey sense says RB.

First tingle was when he told G not to trust anyone.
Second tingle was the big deal over PMing.
Couple of other tingles since.
Inciting the sackless to vote. Could be seeing which way the wind is blowing so he could railroad some innocent.

I could be completely wrong on this, as I said I'm new. This is just a gut hunch. I'll remain sackless for now till I get something a little more substantial in my gut.
 
Chill said:
Okay here's my thoughts - I'm a noob so take them with a grain of salt and if I'm out to lunch chalk it up as inexperience.

I don't see entrusting sole evil role to someone new; it would be likely they would slip up and bring the game to an early close.
Don't see it being cat. He could be lynched even if people knew he was innocent. Also he defended RB when it would have been easy to jump on the bandwagon. No potential in the sole evil defending innocents.
Some of the more high profile players (Lady G, JM) are to big a risk of getting lynched early to entrust with sole evil.

You really need an experienced player who is well liked and doesn't garner a lot of suspicion.

My spidey sense says RB.

First tingle was when he told G not to trust anyone.
Second tingle was the big deal over PMing.
Couple of other tingles since.
Inciting the sackless to vote. Could be seeing which way the wind is blowing so he could railroad some innocent.

I could be completely wrong on this, as I said I'm new. This is just a gut hunch. I'll remain sackless for now till I get something a little more substantial in my gut.
Click to expand...

Really... after a few of his modding games... he's still well liked!??!? ;)

On to real stuff:

BKW: I'm really curious about your vote for me. I said that you jumped on me for the joke... which is true. You commented on it pretty heavily. But that wasn't enough to get you to vote for me. Then I say that you're one of my top two and then I get a vote from you.

I did say that I wanted to see what you were going to say next and there you go voting for me. Wow.

I'd like you to keep in mind that I have been complaining/joking about the 'trap' thing for the last 4 or 5 games I've played. Normally it's in response to Ice, but hooked is guilty of it too. I don't want to reiterate what it is, I will if you haven't been keeping track.

In my mind, BKWs whole argument is nothing and I'm thinking that most everyone else agrees with me.

The only reason that I don't immediately claim him to be EvilAsh is that he could have joined in on the catfish or rb mini-trains and hidden quite nicely. On the other hand, he could be hoping to turn one or both of them later. And, he knows they are innocent and there's no reason to get involved in lynching an innocent.

Two reasons for and one against, not including the shaking logic in voting me.

For now, I retract my vote to lynch catfish and vote to lynch BKW.
 
Chill said:
Okay here's my thoughts - I'm a noob so take them with a grain of salt and if I'm out to lunch chalk it up as inexperience.

I don't see entrusting sole evil role to someone new; it would be likely they would slip up and bring the game to an early close.
Don't see it being cat. He could be lynched even if people knew he was innocent. Also he defended RB when it would have been easy to jump on the bandwagon. No potential in the sole evil defending innocents.
Some of the more high profile players (Lady G, JM) are to big a risk of getting lynched early to entrust with sole evil.

You really need an experienced player who is well liked and doesn't garner a lot of suspicion.

My spidey sense says RB.

First tingle was when he told G not to trust anyone.
Second tingle was the big deal over PMing.
Couple of other tingles since.
Inciting the sackless to vote. Could be seeing which way the wind is blowing so he could railroad some innocent.

I could be completely wrong on this, as I said I'm new. This is just a gut hunch. I'll remain sackless for now till I get something a little more substantial in my gut.
Click to expand...


Well chill I was reading this over and here are my thoughts on it. As of the last few games a newb as been in a PR on good or bads side so it's no so far fetched. Yes it would seem likely that a newb wouldn't be it to newb. But to me it makes perfect sense because the newb has no prior alliances and exp. What a better way to get someone who couldnt be lynched than a newb who no one is looking at.

You may think Rb but IMO he asked the question about the Evil role out in the open for all to see. I don't think he would be for a lack of a better term dumb enough to do that. As for the Pm's and and his statements thats just Rb's style IMO.

But hey thats why we are all here to figure out who is the evil one. I must admit that was a good logic and post for a newb to the game. congrats:grinyes:
 
plantling said:
LMAO, G. IIRC stands for "If I recall correctly".


Hey, just because you like jumping down people's throats doesn't mean everyone else does. Besides I resemble that statement because I don't have any sacks and am proud of it.
Click to expand...


Well....nvm :grinyes:
 
plantling said:
LMAO, G. IIRC stands for "If I recall correctly".


Hey, just because you like jumping down people's throats doesn't mean everyone else does. Besides I resemble that statement because I don't have any sacks and am proud of it.
Click to expand...

LMAO! Thank you Plant...sorry I'm horrible at the ttly, bbl,ty and all that, those I have learned along with a few others, but half the time I have know idea what ppl are saying (LOL, can you tell I don't text msg much!):perv:
 
catfish69hunter said:
Well chill I was reading this over and here are my thoughts on it. As of the last few games a newb as been in a PR on good or bads side so it's no so far fetched. Yes it would seem likely that a newb wouldn't be it to newb. But to me it makes perfect sense because the newb has no prior alliances and exp. What a better way to get someone who couldnt be lynched than a newb who no one is looking at.

You may think Rb but IMO he asked the question about the Evil role out in the open for all to see. I don't think he would be for a lack of a better term dumb enough to do that. As for the Pm's and and his statements thats just Rb's style IMO.

But hey thats why we are all here to figure out who is the evil one. I must admit that was a good logic and post for a newb to the game. congrats:grinyes:
Click to expand...

Anyone else tickled by seeing Catfish repeatedly refer to others as "newb"? :laugh:

This is a weird coin I have to flip... Rb or Cat, Cat or Rb. I get the feeling that Cat is either trying to endear himself to Rb because he's Cat's choice for turn or that he suspects him of being a PR and wants to gain favor.

What to do, what to do?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom