Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[IceH2O]

What about Neon and Jmax...we have NJ on BH, and Jmax on RB...:grinyes::grinyes:

NJ made it 3-1 in favor of BH being lynched I think she is cleared IMO.

 

[Lady G]

Oh MY! I am so stuck on what is going on!




Glad I got BH right. but them quitting? thats odd.



For once G makes sense...but this is pretty elaborate. By going with this you would have to assume that Rb and pix didn;t just say to hell with the game and leave. If they really wanted their team the win wouldn't they have just stayed in the game and deal with whatever happened???







This makes sense too...though I think someone already brought up that it would be obvious if a few people out of nowhere brought up a case randomly one after another on the leader of your team.



this just made me laugh

No, for what ever reason they wanted to quit the game....I don't think they wanted to "hurt" their team..but BKW instead. If they had just quit, they hurt their team mate(s), if they UDed like they did and their team mate(s) knew they were going to..that gave them to the oppertunity to but their votes on BH and or RB thus making them look "innocent" to the town, because they were voting what is now Known evils.
As for the case on HN...well, I think there was enough doubt out there already that any case brought up would not of looked random. I believe FULLY if Ogre had investigated Hooked and found him terrorist there would of been a much bigger push for him.

 

[Lady G]

NJ made it 3-1 in favor of BH being lynched I think she is cleared IMO.

I think you are blinded right now and are thinking what they wanted you to think Ice. Yep, I could definitely be wrong...but something is telling me I'm not.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

NJ made it 3-1 in favor of BH being lynched I think she is cleared IMO.

I truly hate agreeing with you, but in this case I do.

Here's something to get some thoughts going... I retract my vote for JM and vote to lynch Z.

You can look at the posts for yourselves...

 

[IceH2O]

I say we vote HN and JM.

Both of their posts after nightfall read as if they aren't part of the town.

HN claims sarcasm when he posted great shot sniper. Sniper is a terrorist,how does the sarcasm relate?
Then JM doesn't understand how 2 terrorists UDing helps the town.

Here are the posts:

well...that was interesting. OK, so, ..I assume, buy how that went down, ..and by personality change and attitude, ..we can pick who else was guilty, now that we lost two terrorists. so, who was pushing NJ ??

Are we Game On?

Does that mean that there is only one left?

Woohoo! Great job Sniper! lmao

?????? we lost 2 terrorists????

The town didn't lose 2 they gained an advantage.

I am failing to see how they gained an advantage?..please explain it for me , its been a very long day in the sun...

and, my vote will next go to HN, .as per my post, that i felt him and RB the most guilty.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Wonder why the Sniper hit Ogre? It's a weird play to me. He wasn't saying much at the time (now we know why), and how likely is it that the sniper's first shot would the SWAT leader? Talk about unlucky. Why would someone take out Ogre anyway?

Good question so I went back and looked...The following is the only reason I can see why the sniper would pick off Ogre...

hmmm...

In my opinion, the ones that we should be looking most closely at are those that are singleton votes.

LG(1)-Cap(89) HN(122) HN(263)
Cam(1)-RB(170)
Pappy(1)- DD(236)
BadHaggis(1)-JL(177)
Mad(1)-NJ (349)
Jmax(1)-Firedancer(467)

Those being hooked, RB, DD, John, Neon, and Firedancer (AKA Jensons AKA Brandi AKA Teacher-O-the-Year)

And don't forget our none voter Rickets...

At this point, I'm very suspicious of hooked. His play for the suicide pact was very strange for the point in the game and the conditions under which it was offered.

Ice pushed hard for chill, but he's like that.

DD, still seems to be hiding in plain sight.

Not sure about the others on that list.

Huh? How do you mean? All the train votes?




I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie. Reason: strange behavior yesterday and skimming today. It's already been said that cam was an innocent.

It's not that I don't see anyone else as suspicious, but I think we should look to those first.

Skimming?! Who wasn't confused about what exactly happened? Maybe the sniper huh?

Is this a little foreshadowing, HN?

I still vote to lynch HN

 

[NeonJulie]

No, for what ever reason they wanted to quit the game....I don't think they wanted to "hurt" their team..but BKW instead. If they had just quit, they hurt their team mate(s), if they UDed like they did and their team mate(s) knew they were going to..that gave them to the oppertunity to but their votes on BH and or RB thus making them look "innocent" to the town, because they were voting what is now Known evils.

*italics mine

Well how do you explain this potential contradiction?

Yesterday I said he was on my radar, and then the first thing I did was put my vote on BH (because maybe I have a pretty good radar for mafia). Do you think they had planned to quit as early as 24 hours ago? Seeing as I was one of the first to put a vote on him?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I say we vote HN and JM.

Both of their posts after nightfall read as if they aren't part of the town.

HN claims sarcasm when he posted great shot sniper. Sniper is a terrorist,how does the sarcasm relate?
Then JM doesn't understand how 2 terrorists UDing helps the town.

Here are the posts:

You really think I'm that dumb? Go to Walmart, I hear they have humor on sale this week.

I retract my vote for Z and vote to lynch Ice.

 

[NeonJulie]

Rats. Let's try that again...

No, for what ever reason they wanted to quit the game....I don't think they wanted to "hurt" their team..but BKW instead. If they had just quit, they hurt their team mate(s), if they UDed like they did and their team mate(s) knew they were going to..that gave them to the oppertunity to but their votes on BH and or RB thus making them look "innocent" to the town, because they were voting what is now Known evils.

*bold mine

Well how do you explain this potential contradiction?

Yesterday I said he was on my radar, and then the first thing I did was put my vote on BH (because maybe I have a pretty good radar for mafia). Do you think they had planned to quit as early as 24 hours ago? Seeing as I was one of the first to put a vote on him?

 

[judgemax]

I say we vote HN and JM.

Both of their posts after nightfall read as if they aren't part of the town.

HN claims sarcasm when he posted great shot sniper. Sniper is a terrorist,how does the sarcasm relate?
Then JM doesn't understand how 2 terrorists UDing helps the town.

Here are the posts:

I am ok to be put up for a vote, i misread what you wrote, ..and assumed you meant the terrorists gained an advantage, which is why i questioned it.