Mafia 38 "the revenge"
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
Well I guess everyone votes for me now eh? Because that is obviously why the Mafia picked Narwhal.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
I don't believe either Z or NJ is mafia. It's between DD, Ogre, and bkw for me...
I vote to lynch bkw.
Ok let's rewind to my original logic exercise from Day2. After I excluded people that I did not think could be RB's team mate I was left with HN, Ogre, DD, Pixl, Narwhal. We can scratch Pixl and Narwhal which leaves HN, Ogre, and DD. Now I personally don't think DD would vote for RB on Day 1 with only 2 people on their team. So I am going to exclude her from my New school list, your mileage may vary.
That in my opinion leaves HN or Ogre as the other New School Mafia.
The fact that both HN and I are still in the game puzzles me. And Ogre has not posted enough for me to get much intel. So I don't know which way I would lean right now. I am going to go back and try the same for the Old School, but I think Chill has probably distanced himself as much as he could. One point is that Chill kept accusing HN of being the other New School but I wouldn't put much weight in it.
That in my opinion leaves HN or Ogre as the other New School Mafia.
The fact that both HN and I are still in the game puzzles me. And Ogre has not posted enough for me to get much intel. So I don't know which way I would lean right now. I am going to go back and try the same for the Old School, but I think Chill has probably distanced himself as much as he could. One point is that Chill kept accusing HN of being the other New School but I wouldn't put much weight in it.
![[AC] narwhal](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83431.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
:tombstone::tombstone: PLease Town go get them. And I just want you all to know that the game is much better IMO using these ID's and it makes it more of a thrill again I hope more people choose to use them in the future.:grinyes::tombstone::tombstone:
Ok I looked back on the Old School Mafia based on knowing Chill (even though Ice didn't say his specific role like LG did 
)
Contenders: Ogre, NJ, me, HN JP, DD, BKW. I am omitting me because what's the point, you believe me or you don't.
Ogre was the second vote on Chill on Day 2 after JP (the known Dr.)
HN was all over Chill Day 2 and 3, a bit too much to be simple distancing in my opinion.
BKW was the first to vote for Chill on Day 1, a weak alibi but something to go one.
That would leave NJ and DD. DD voted with Chill on JP on Day 2.
So my top two for Old School Don would be DD followed by NJ. You can sub BKW for NJ if you are so inclined.
I haven't decided yet but I will likely vote for DD or Ogre today pending further information.
)Contenders: Ogre, NJ, me, HN JP, DD, BKW. I am omitting me because what's the point, you believe me or you don't.
Ogre was the second vote on Chill on Day 2 after JP (the known Dr.)
HN was all over Chill Day 2 and 3, a bit too much to be simple distancing in my opinion.
BKW was the first to vote for Chill on Day 1, a weak alibi but something to go one.
That would leave NJ and DD. DD voted with Chill on JP on Day 2.
So my top two for Old School Don would be DD followed by NJ. You can sub BKW for NJ if you are so inclined.
I haven't decided yet but I will likely vote for DD or Ogre today pending further information.
Ok I looked back on the Old School Mafia based on knowing Chill (even though Ice didn't say his specific role like LG did
Contenders: Ogre, NJ, me, HN JP, DD, BKW. I am omitting me because what's the point, you believe me or you don't.
Ogre was the second vote on Chill on Day 2 after JP (the known Dr.)
HN was all over Chill Day 2 and 3, a bit too much to be simple distancing in my opinion.
BKW was the first to vote for Chill on Day 1, a weak alibi but something to go one.
That would leave NJ and DD. DD voted with Chill on JP on Day 2.
So my top two for Old School Don would be DD followed by NJ. You can sub BKW for NJ if you are so inclined.
I haven't decided yet but I will likely vote for DD or Ogre today pending further information.
I am so inclined. As much as she's tried to call me into doubt, I really don't believe she is mafia. I likewise, don't believe you are. Jpap is proven and the only known we have. I'll follow his lead, but IMHO it's got to be between DD, Ogre, and bkw.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
lets clear this up, I voted for pappy initially because I felt he was pushing too hard on me for no reason at all. I voted rb afterward, rb was deemed mafia don and then he continued to come after me... again for no reason, even blaming me for suspecting rb in the first place. That makes me guilty? Come on...
if I were to pick between Ogre and bkw, I would vote Ogre.... for one because he was pretty adament in saying he was out to get low posters..... that kind of attitude would lead me to believe he'd be one of the highest posters yet.... we hear less and less of him as the game goes on.
If I were to go by the list of Ogre and bkw, I would definitely go for Ogre.
if I were to pick between Ogre and bkw, I would vote Ogre.... for one because he was pretty adament in saying he was out to get low posters..... that kind of attitude would lead me to believe he'd be one of the highest posters yet.... we hear less and less of him as the game goes on.
If I were to go by the list of Ogre and bkw, I would definitely go for Ogre.
