Mafia 38 "the revenge"

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm not sure what you think I missed. I'm saying I think Jpap was trying to take the heat off his Don (Rb).

Oh! Sorry... it's late and I've had a few. I read it as you thought Rb was trying to take the heat off the Don.

I would like to see some specifics for you suspecting Jpappy. He hasn't seemed to be acting like he has when he was evil in the past. I was wrong about Rb & Dawg though... I need to review everything once fully sober, but right now I actually think that NJ may be the most trustworthy given her vote. We'll see. Anyone on the Rb train is going to get a partial pass, my fear is that the other mafia team joined in on it. I tend to think that at least one vote on him was from the other team. Figuring out who it is will be the challenge.

 

[Lady G]

Hey guys, I can't do this this round....just way to much happening right now Ice has offered to take over for me, all info has been sent to him and he will be the new Mod.

Sorry, everyone....really I am, but I just can't do it now.

 

[Chill]

That's understandable G. Take care.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

No worries G... take care and like I said, if you want to yell or vent I'm here.

 

[IceH2O]

Hey Guys.

OK according to the rules it was 48 hr 1st day and its 24 hr days from here on out.

so NIGHTFALL at 9 PM EST tonight

PMs as required

 

[ZSandmann]

Ok that was not too much to proccess. Good call on Rb acting different I guess, but he plays so off the cuff that I don't see how anyone ever gets useful info from him.

What I see though is that Rb laid a good bit of doubt against us as he knew he was probably going to be taking a dirt nap. His vote immediately after mine sets me up pretty well. And a vote on NJ pretty much clears her IMO, just like HN said. So I would like to hear comments frtom NJ on her short list and I will be going back to track the votes since we didn't get an updated list before Night.

LG I hope whatever is taking you away gets resolved...

And dang Ice is Mod now, I was sure he was Narwhal, back to the drawing board.

 

[ZSandmann]

Why am I thinking that we have what we almost always have on day 1? A few innocents that pit themselves against one another while the real mafia members never really get mentioned at all. *cough* Z *cough* I'm almost hurt that I'm not in the middle of one of the bickering contests. lol

Lady G will you fight with me even if you are the Mod?

Self preservation my dear Watson. Out of sight, out of mind.
But you won't be getting Hit by me this round, however, you may get lynched if you're Mafia.

 

[OgreMkV]

Oh! Sorry... it's late and I've had a few. I read it as you thought Rb was trying to take the heat off the Don.

I would like to see some specifics for you suspecting Jpappy. He hasn't seemed to be acting like he has when he was evil in the past. I was wrong about Rb & Dawg though... I need to review everything once fully sober, but right now I actually think that NJ may be the most trustworthy given her vote. We'll see. Anyone on the Rb train is going to get a partial pass, my fear is that the other mafia team joined in on it. I tend to think that at least one vote on him was from the other team. Figuring out who it is will be the challenge.

Don't feel bad hooked. I saw exactly the same thing you did... and I've slept.

There are two teams of mafia and they don't know each other, so it could easily have been (in fact, I would say almost surely) there was a mafia on the train.

Hey guys, I can't do this this round....just way to much happening right now Ice has offered to take over for me, all info has been sent to him and he will be the new Mod.

Sorry, everyone....really I am, but I just can't do it now.

Is OK G, life before play. Just remember you owe us a mod when everything is straight.

Ok that was not too much to proccess. Good call on Rb acting different I guess, but he plays so off the cuff that I don't see how anyone ever gets useful info from him.

What I see though is that Rb laid a good bit of doubt against us as he knew he was probably going to be taking a dirt nap. His vote immediately after mine sets me up pretty well. And a vote on NJ pretty much clears her IMO, just like HN said. So I would like to hear comments frtom NJ on her short list and I will be going back to track the votes since we didn't get an updated list before Night.

LG I hope whatever is taking you away gets resolved...

And dang Ice is Mod now, I was sure he was Narwhal, back to the drawing board.

I agree with hooked more than you Z. I don't think anyone on RBs train should get a free pass at all. I also don't think that anyone RB voted for should get any kind of pass either.

RB is definitely good enough to vote for his compatriot and then if she was mafia, he's clear. If he gets voted out, then she's clear.


I'm still not sure about chill's 'slip'. The more I think about it, the more it sounds like another mafia trying to get us to attack who they want. Of course, that could be my paranoid delusions talking too.

I really want to hear more from chill... and narwal.

 

[ZSandmann]

Narwhal: JP(35) Dawg(64) Ogre(136)
Z: HN(38) Z(66)
NJ: Ogre(39) Z(114) RB(116)
Dawg: Narwhal(65)
BKW: Chill(70) Ogre(98) Dawg(127) HN(148)
RB: BKW(99) NJ(110) DD (113) Chill(168)
DD: JP(119)

No vote from Pixl8r.

Now I'd like to be able to clear folks just based on votes, but with two Mafia teams that is impossible. However, I think it would be safe to say that BKW (First vote RB), NJ (2nd vote RB/RB's Votee), and myself (Followed on my heals to vote NJ) are not on the New School team. I might even add Chill to this list as his move from BKW was what broke the tie and sealed it for RB. I will conceed the case for my Innocence is the weakest of these explanations, but yoiu will have to choose to believe or disbelieve me.

Possible New School Mafia: (No particular order)
Hooked
JPappy
DD
Pixl
Narwhal

Of course there is no solid evidence to make likewise lists of Innocent/Old School. Can anyone add insight which might futher refine this list. Also, feel free to rebuff any I have excluded.

 

[ZSandmann]

Don't feel bad hooked. I saw exactly the same thing you did... and I've slept.

There are two teams of mafia and they don't know each other, so it could easily have been (in fact, I would say almost surely) there was a mafia on the train.



Is OK G, life before play. Just remember you owe us a mod when everything is straight.



I agree with hooked more than you Z. I don't think anyone on RBs train should get a free pass at all. I also don't think that anyone RB voted for should get any kind of pass either.

RB is definitely good enough to vote for his compatriot and then if she was mafia, he's clear. If he gets voted out, then she's clear.


I'm still not sure about chill's 'slip'. The more I think about it, the more it sounds like another mafia trying to get us to attack who they want. Of course, that could be my paranoid delusions talking too.

I really want to hear more from chill... and narwal.

Yes I agree I rethought that choice of words once I reread the votes and so forth, I think my post before this one better explains where I was going. With so few Mafia on a team I am not as sure that they would pitch one another onto the railroad tracks.