Mafia 38 "the revenge"

IceH2O said:
Ok guys, my bad. I should have looked over the rules better. How often does a tie result in no lynch?

I can't see anyway to bring Jpap back, it makes him a known innocent. If I move the DR role to another player it gives the DET another known innocent.

Deal with it. Game continues as is.
Click to expand...

Take away the Mafias hit tonight then. That will get us back up an Innocent.
 
Chill said:
Oh no doubt I'm scr**ed and I expect to be swinging come night

but the town should still be watching for slips or clues cause there's more than one mafia to worry about - I expect to go but I'm going to stick around and try to figure out who's who before night - I suggest everyone else do the same
Click to expand...

So let me ask why your going to figure out who is who before your gone? Yes there is more mafia to find yet but are you trying to say to watch out for your partner so we lynch them too?? If thats the case just tell us their name and we can lynch them after you.
 
ZSandmann said:
I dunno is that right Blackmailer?
Click to expand...

Sorry no blackmailer here. And why are you working so hard for nailing me to the wall. I make one press for Hooked and you jump all over me. Your a better player than this Z and you and I both know it but this is very outta character for you. So are you trying your hardest to protect chill or something? For all I know your the blackmailer.
 
[AC] narwhal;1534091 said:
How much more do you need? All I was trying to get to was the fact that IMO with chill being the one to die tonight that now IMO that leaves 2 noncommunicating mafia left. Isn't that right?
Click to expand...

That's not what you seemed to be saying to me... see below.

[AC] narwhal;1533528 said:
Holy Crap I missed alot.

First Jpap sorry to see you go
Second yes It was a tie and I agree that the rules state it so count it bring the Pap back.
Third Chill I have to say you are scr**ed

I vote to lynch Chill.

Forth just for my own records and for anyone else the blackmailer IMO is the henchman and chill is his/her don. That means we have found both teams IMO and the remaining 2 mafia wouldn't be able to communicate. Am I wrong in this thought?
Click to expand...

I'd just like to know your train of logic in the statement in red.

ZSandmann said:
Meh.

Looks like Chill and Narwhal are Old School.

Pappy man we miss you here... I could make a long post but no one wants to listen to me.

I vote to lynch Chill for concensus, but would prefer Narwhal.
Click to expand...

It's bold statements like that that make me nervous. Basically, you are saying that chill and narwal are both mafia, but you're only voting chill to go with everyone else. What difference does it make? There's no more new mafia coming in. If it is them, then the investigations can't really hurt the town either.

I don't get it.

ZSandmann said:
Take away the Mafias hit tonight then. That will get us back up an Innocent.
Click to expand...

This statement is the only reason I don't switch my vote to you right now Z.


I'm getting nervous about the chill vote now.
 
OgreMkV said:
Narwal and Z distancing?
Click to expand...

Actually, from reading the interactions I'm growing a bit less suspicious of Narwhal and more suspicious of Z. I actually follow his logic and thought the same thing in regards to the blackmailer. There is no doubt whatsoever in my mind that the blackmailer saved Chill and we know that the blackmailer role was given to the mafia. So, surmising that Chill is mafia is a given for me. I'll stand by my vote. It won't be moving.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Actually, from reading the interactions I'm growing a bit less suspicious of Narwhal and more suspicious of Z. I actually follow his logic and thought the same thing in regards to the blackmailer. There is no doubt whatsoever in my mind that the blackmailer saved Chill and we know that the blackmailer role was given to the mafia. So, surmising that Chill is mafia is a given for me. I'll stand by my vote. It won't be moving.
Click to expand...


Yes there's no doubt the blackmailer saved me. The question you all should be asking is why?
 
[AC] narwhal;1533528 said:
Forth just for my own records and for anyone else the blackmailer IMO is the henchman and chill is his/her don. That means we have found both teams IMO and the remaining 2 mafia wouldn't be able to communicate. Am I wrong in this thought?
Click to expand...

OgreMkV said:
That's not what you seemed to be saying to me... see below.



I'd just like to know your train of logic in the statement in red.
Click to expand...

Ok Ogre here is my train of thought on this.
First Ice said the blackmail went to the mafia.
Second at nightfall chill gets saved by it.
Third my thought is there are 2 mafia teams of 2 players at the start. Forth RB is a dead mafia leaving 1 mafia player all alone.
Fifth there is a second team with 2 players still.
Sixth once again chill saved by the blackmail.
Seventh the lone mafia wouldnt know the other 2 mafia.
Eightth This means the lone mafia wouldn't know to save chill
ninth this means it would have to have been his teammate
tenth I may not be right that is the don but close enough
eleventh that means we found both teams IMO

there is my train of thought if you have any more questions please ask


OgreMkV said:
Narwal and Z distancing?
Click to expand...

As for distancing from Z wouldn't that be a little TOO obvious?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom