Mafia 38 "the revenge"

[ZSandmann]

1. Ogre - Most Likely New School
2. HN - Could be New School
3. DD - Likely Innocent
4. NJ - Likely Innocent
5. JP - Innocent

This is the way I order the remaining unknowns. DD and NJ only made sense if they were Old School, since that is now done, I assume them Innocent, of course JP is our known Innocent. One of these four is the Detective. Ogre if you are the Detective tell me now and I will vote for HN. It is 5 to 1 so we have won unless something crazy happens.

I'd like to see everyone elses list too, you can exclude yourself as I have done.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

No it isn't. I have made my case for Ogre and to a lesser extent (because I don't buy it other than by statistics) HN. I can not make a case for myself and not be biased. If you think I am a candidate then please look back and show me where and I will expound on any particular posts or events. I am sure if Ogre posts anymore he will do just that.

The Mafia are hardly putting up a fight this round.

Z- Who'd you vote for last night? I don't believe it was the known (and now dead) mafia Don. Why do you keep trying to bring me into it? I thought that I was pretty sure about you, but you are making it awfully tough to stand by you.

 

[ZSandmann]

I voted for Ogre. I would not say BKW was a known Mafia. And I do not think you are the last Mafia, I think Ogre is but I have to rank everyone and I have more reasons to exclude the rest so you are not as low as some.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I voted for Ogre. I would not say BKW was a known Mafia. And I do not think you are the last Mafia, I think Ogre is but I have to rank everyone and I have more reasons to exclude the rest so you are not as low as some.

I would. Look back on posts and votes.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm not voting until we hear from Pappy since he's the only one that can be trusted completely.

 

[Dangerdoll]

At this point I find Ogre and Bkw athis is the post where pappy did in fact say Ogre and bkw were his top candidates and is the reason I went with the group in voting bkw... I felt Ogre was the better option but since pappy said both, I thought it was safe enough to vote him....

 

[Dangerdoll]

At this point I find Ogre and Bkw as most mafia-ish.

I don't know why the post didnt work... but here it is again...

 

[OgreMkV]

No it isn't. I have made my case for Ogre and to a lesser extent (because I don't buy it other than by statistics) HN. I can not make a case for myself and not be biased. If you think I am a candidate then please look back and show me where and I will expound on any particular posts or events. I am sure if Ogre posts anymore he will do just that.

The Mafia are hardly putting up a fight this round.

Please show me where you made a case for me or hooked.

1. Ogre - Most Likely New School
2. HN - Could be New School
3. DD - Likely Innocent
4. NJ - Likely Innocent
5. JP - Innocent

This is the way I order the remaining unknowns. DD and NJ only made sense if they were Old School, since that is now done, I assume them Innocent, of course JP is our known Innocent. One of these four is the Detective. Ogre if you are the Detective tell me now and I will vote for HN. It is 5 to 1 so we have won unless something crazy happens.

I'd like to see everyone elses list too, you can exclude yourself as I have done.

WHAT?!?!?!?!??


Now, let's look at something actually interesting that happened and its significance.

THE MAFIA DID NOT SEND IN A HIT... Ice said specifically, that the lone mafia attempted, but "did not bring bullets". That means, the mafis did not send in the hit to him.

bkw and Jpap, didn't vote, but neither of them are an issue right now. The big question is WHO DID NOT SEND IN THE HIT?

The only perso to post between Ice's statement that PMs are required and Nightfall was Z. That clears him as far as I'm concerned.

Hooked (and myself for that matter) are way too into the game to miss something like a hit.

Unfortunately, that leaves the ladies. DD and NJ. I would really prefer to vote DD. However, NJ reminded everyone pretty specifically that RB and her did not work well together so he wouldn't pick her.

For now, and until we hear from Jpapm I vote to lynch NeonJulie.

I don't know why the post didnt work... but here it is again...

 

[Dangerdoll]

Please show me where you made a case for me or hooked.

WHAT?!?!?!?!??

Now, let's look at something actually interesting that happened and its significance.

THE MAFIA DID NOT SEND IN A HIT... Ice said specifically, that the lone mafia attempted, but "did not bring bullets". That means, the mafis did not send in the hit to him.

bkw and Jpap, didn't vote, but neither of them are an issue right now. The big question is WHO DID NOT SEND IN THE HIT?

The only perso to post between Ice's statement that PMs are required and Nightfall was Z. That clears him as far as I'm concerned.

Hooked (and myself for that matter) are way too into the game to miss something like a hit.

Unfortunately, that leaves the ladies. DD and NJ. I would really prefer to vote DD. However, NJ reminded everyone pretty specifically that RB and her did not work well together so he wouldn't pick her.

For now, and until we hear from Jpapm I vote to lynch NeonJulie.

wow, you almost had me vote NJ again, Ogre... you hold a pretty good argument BUT where does it say that her and rb don't work well together? I know she said he wouldn't pick her because he had done so before but I just can't find where he "doesn't work well with her".... is this something you threw together from bunching his snide remark posts together? I'm not seeing that either, but please... enlighten.

With 1 team now gone the lone mafia goes out to commit his deed of the night. Its a shame they forgot their bullets. Guess they'll just have to do some research on an intended victim.

Another thing to turn me away from NJ is this bolded area... yes, Ice is usually much more careful than that but a slip is a slip.... Gender of the remaining mafia is in my mind, a male...

last I heard from pappy was that it was down to bkw and Ogre.... so until I hear from pappy otherwise, I vote to lynch Ogre

 

[OgreMkV]

wow, you almost had me vote NJ again, Ogre... you hold a pretty good argument BUT where does it say that her and rb don't work well together? I know she said he wouldn't pick her because he had done so before but I just can't find where he "doesn't work well with her".... is this something you threw together from bunching his snide remark posts together? I'm not seeing that either, but please... enlighten.




Another thing to turn me away from NJ is this bolded area... yes, Ice is usually much more careful than that but a slip is a slip.... Gender of the remaining mafia is in my mind, a male...

last I heard from pappy was that it was down to bkw and Ogre.... so until I hear from pappy otherwise, I vote to lynch Ogre

Crud, I didn't even see that DD.

The thing with NK was an interpretation of what she said... I didn't go look it up. Sorry.

Well, of the two guys left, I would prefer to vote Z.

This ought to be interesting though. I REALLY want to hear from Jpap. If the good guys team didn't investigate me, then I'm dead tonight because Z and hooked will side with DD. That would be a shame.

I retract my vote for DD.