Mafia 38 "the revenge"

If everything has been given to us correctly by JP, there is only one other option besides NJ. That is that HN is the Detective and the last henchman. Is it possible RB could have picked the Det as his henchman? Maybe, but my vote is staying on NJ and we will see how this M. Night Shymalan twist plays out.
 
I kinda feel that way too, z...

question.... can't Ogre show innocent the first night if in fact he is on the first night but is a chosen henchman, therrefore wouldn't be considered "mafia" until night two and on after that?
 
ZSandmann said:
If everything has been given to us correctly by JP, there is only one other option besides NJ. That is that HN is the Detective and the last henchman. Is it possible RB could have picked the Det as his henchman? Maybe, but my vote is staying on NJ and we will see how this M. Night Shymalan twist plays out.
Click to expand...

Dangerdoll said:
I kinda feel that way too, z...

question.... can't Ogre show innocent the first night if in fact he is on the first night but is a chosen henchman, therrefore wouldn't be considered "mafia" until night two and on after that?
Click to expand...

I'm nothing but the detective, but I'm starting to get confused and starting to even doubt myself. DD brought up the only other possible scenario I can think of. If G didn't "count" a turn until nightfall. Hopefully the game is solved and over tonight.

OT- Check out the mafia games thread. I need feedback on the format I'm planning for 40 (my first attempt at modding).
 
OgreMkV said:
I don't know what's going on, but I'm still an innocent. Either NJ is playing us or hooked is the last henchman and the detective.

I guess it's NJ tonight and hooked tomorrow.
Click to expand...

If I were mafia I would have lied to Pappy about who I investigated and just said that I investigated the people that are already dead. I've pretty much gone with his choices since each night, our lists to investigate have matched.

If NJ doesn't end the game, it's you IMO. You're the last plausible possibility, but I think we got it tonight.
 
While writing her PM, NJ is grabbed by the town folk. Is she the last remaining mafia?

Bala reaches down and lifts NJ above his head.Throws her into the air and opens his mouth wide. NJ disappears into Balas mouth.

Bala declares she tastes of innocence.

NJ was an innocent
 
Guess the mafia doesn't want Z to enjoy the last nights of the marathon, are they afraid he will really figure out who is what?

Z is found with his mouth taped shut and his fingers missing.

Z was an innocent.
 
Game on

Night Fall at 9 PM EST SAT

remaining players

Ogre
DD
HN
Jpap
 
Hooked Newbie said:
If I were mafia I would have lied to Pappy about who I investigated and just said that I investigated the people that are already dead. I've pretty much gone with his choices since each night, our lists to investigate have matched.

If NJ doesn't end the game, it's you IMO. You're the last plausible possibility, but I think we got it tonight.
Click to expand...

Hooked, you said I was an innocent. You said DD was innocent. So if you are innocent, then the only one left is Jpap... but was declared mafia when he was killed. You're the only one left.

I vote to lynch hooked.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom