Mafia 39... the kids take over.

[IceH2O]

By this post and action, are you saying that you don't think Hi IQ is mafia?

I agree that DD seems "different", but tying it up only forces action IF someone does move. Otherwise it results in no lynch and effectively protects IQ.

At this point No I don't think Hi is mafia. They thought the same thing I've been thinking about all day at work.
It does no good for mafia to want to lynch a UD on night 1. By lynching an innocent UD they lose an innocent.

If you keep a definite UD alive they can get 2 innocents night 1 and 3 innocents night 2

If you lynch a definite UD night 1 then they still get 2 night 1 but only 2 night 2.
It goes from 5 innocents to 4 innocents by lynching the UD night 1.

 

[ZSandmann]

Ok if I believe DD is Mafia (and i do) then I am drawn to her choice of vote. With HiIQ and nano tied, she chooses Hi. This makes nano more likely he team mate should it come down to it.

I am confident in my vote, I will only move it if I must to ensure we get information tonight.

 

[ZSandmann]

OR neither is her team mate. Keep the tie and no one is lynched. But if she breaks the tie (either way) then an Innocent or at least not someone from her team goes away andshe is closer to victory. So they could both be innocent.

 

[IceH2O]

Ok if I believe DD is Mafia (and i do) then I am drawn to her choice of vote. With HiIQ and nano tied, she chooses Hi. This makes nano more likely he team mate should it come down to it.

I am confident in my vote, I will only move it if I must to ensure we get information tonight.

Possible that Nano is a team mate but more likely that she had no reason to vote Hi except by using the bad to vote the UD excuse. I also stated I believed in His' reasoning and DD never said a word about it.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

At this point No I don't think Hi is mafia. They thought the same thing I've been thinking about all day at work.
It does no good for mafia to want to lynch a UD on night 1. By lynching an innocent UD they lose an innocent.

If you keep a definite UD alive they can get 2 innocents night 1 and 3 innocents night 2

If you lynch a definite UD night 1 then they still get 2 night 1 but only 2 night 2.
It goes from 5 innocents to 4 innocents by lynching the UD night 1.

Nano's not exactly participating, but they will not UD tonight. If they were mafia, they'd probably be more involved right? Their Don would be pounding them with PMs, emails, etc. I would and so would you. So, based on that assumption you are CHOOSING to vote off a probable innocent instead of at least taking a chance that could yield us a mafia.

 

[IceH2O]

Nano's not exactly participating, but they will not UD tonight. If they were mafia, they'd probably be more involved right? Their Don would be pounding them with PMs, emails, etc. I would and so would you. So, based on that assumption you are CHOOSING to vote off a probable innocent instead of at least taking a chance that could yield us a mafia.

No they won't UD tonight but they will tomorrow.

Yes I believe Nano to be an innocent. But they will die a UD.

I'd rather lynch an innocent UD then let them just be taken away and giving the mafia an extra death.That is why night 1 is the night to do it. By next night fall we might have a good lead on a mafia and then we still end up giving the mafia an extra death (UD)with no work involved.

 

[Rbishop]

Possible that Nano is a team mate but more likely that she had no reason to vote Hi except by using the bad to vote the UD excuse. I also stated I believed in His' reasoning and DD never said a word about it.

That is odd...wonder what she would gain by ignoring it besides attention?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Possible that Nano is a team mate but more likely that she had no reason to vote Hi except by using the bad to vote the UD excuse. I also stated I believed in His' reasoning and DD never said a word about it.

This caught my attention when Rb quoted it. What gender do you believe IQ to be Ice?

 

[IceH2O]

This caught my attention when Rb quoted it. What gender do you believe IQ to be Ice?

I believe HI IQ is NeonJulie.

The she in that quote is talking about DD.

The His' isn't his, its Hi in the possessive form. I'll just call them IQ so the s no longer confuses you.

 

[Rbishop]

Hmmm..HI could be either from what I read. Gunslinger seems male to me.