Mafia 39... the kids take over.

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Upon further review I'm going to check Pix and Nano off as innocents. I doubt Ogre would give either a role and I doubt either would be chosen. Nano is to new and Pix has a terrible track record, he is often a UD. If either is guilty I think they'll take care of themselves.

Ice I think that someone could argue for just the opposite too. But I do tend to agree with you on this one but no one is clear till they are clear.

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

I appreciate your allowance of me to play my game.

:laugh:

Upon further review I'm going to check Pix and Nano off as innocents. I doubt Ogre would give either a role and I doubt either would be chosen. Nano is to new and Pix has a terrible track record, he is often a UD. If either is guilty I think they'll take care of themselves.

That is assuming he hand picked the roles, it could be completely random.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, so not much has really happened today but I do see some are trying to come up with lists or eliminating who they think might/might not be picked. Obvious choices not to go for are Ice, Hooked, Rb, and yes, even Pappy.... but this brings me to think.... if either one is mafia, or anyone else for that matter... would they think that since these folks are so obvious, most people wouldn't even dare to think they'd be picked or would assume that we wouldn't think they'd be picked because they were "too obvious".... and then pick them on that thought.... ?

 

[IceH2O]

:laugh:

That is assuming he hand picked the roles, it could be completely random.

Nothing in mafia is random. If a MOD randomly ends up on a player they think will UD or is brand new to the game they will fudge it and randomly go to the next player. No one as far as I remember has ever been a DON their 1st game, especially with such low numbers on each team.

ok, so not much has really happened today but I do see some are trying to come up with lists or eliminating who they think might/might not be picked. Obvious choices not to go for are Ice, Hooked, Rb, and yes, even Pappy.... but this brings me to think.... if either one is mafia, or anyone else for that matter... would they think that since these folks are so obvious, most people wouldn't even dare to think they'd be picked or would assume that we wouldn't think they'd be picked because they were "too obvious".... and then pick them on that thought.... ?

and here I thought I'd miss LG not playing, thankfully DD is channeling her.

I hope the Dons did go obvious, it will help the DET find the "kids" easier since the obvious players are usually the 1st investigated.

 

[IceH2O]

Maybe since there are 2 aliases and 2 Dons, its also a clue?

What do you aliases have to say about that? Is that to obvious?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Nothing in mafia is random. If a MOD randomly ends up on a player they think will UD or is brand new to the game they will fudge it and randomly go to the next player. No one as far as I remember has ever been a DON their 1st game, especially with such low numbers on each team.



and here I thought I'd miss LG not playing, thankfully DD is channeling her.

I hope the Dons did go obvious, it will help the DET find the "kids" easier since the obvious players are usually the 1st investigated.

:rofl:

I really think it's too early to fixate on who was potentially picked. Good cases for and against anyone could probably be made. People "floating" theories or only posting to poke holes in them are much mre interesting to me.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Nothing in mafia is random. If a MOD randomly ends up on a player they think will UD or is brand new to the game they will fudge it and randomly go to the next player. No one as far as I remember has ever been a DON their 1st game, especially with such low numbers on each team.

and here I thought I'd miss LG not playing, thankfully DD is channeling her.

I hope the Dons did go obvious, it will help the DET find the "kids" easier since the obvious players are usually the 1st investigated.

LOL it almost hurt when I was trying to explain that thought...

Maybe since there are 2 aliases and 2 Dons, its also a clue?

What do you aliases have to say about that? Is that to obvious?

could have a point there... it is pretty obvious though.... hmmmm

 

[Rbishop]

Crap...4th post after 19th hour of game starting...

I vote to lynch Ice...

 

[IceH2O]

Crap...4th post after 19th hour of game starting...

I vote to lynch Ice...

You might want to take math 101.

The 19th hour after the game started would be at 5:52 PM.

But keep the vote there, I'd hate to have to make sure I post 4th after the time limit put out by you.

 

[IceH2O]

RB,if you'd like to use the time the thread was actually made then the 4th post was by Jpap in post 37. But I prefer you keep it where it is.

Game thread started at 8:59 pm +19 hrs is 3:59 pm. Gun at 4 then jpap then me then Jpap.

Game ON at 10:52 PM + 19 hours= 5:52 PM