Mafia 40 "Life behind bars" The Play

[Dangerdoll]

Ok, my suspicions come down to (in no particular order):
jbradt - because he seems to "with it" and obnxious for a newbie. Seems to know what he's doing in this game as if there is coaching behind the scenes.
Dawg - The whole flub with him and chill in the beginning is enough to unnerve me, with Chill being somewhat helpful or at least trying to throw thoughts out, Dawg has not. Or not enough that I can see making any kind of solitary thought that holds weight. This thought should not discount Chill, in fact I think that the more he talks, the more we can find out about him... get a feel for where he is.
NJ - seems very protective over the newbies and seems to say a lot of what has said in past games. So, that thought puts me where she realy doesn't have much to say except to see herself posting as to look helpful.

From the list, I guess I will go with Dawg. While it doesn't seem there is too much to go on, this is what I have come to with my suspicions.... yes, they may be weak but it's what I have.
I vote to shank Dawg

 

[IceH2O]

Ok well with the evidence presented and the doubt planted in my mind

I retract my vote to shank Bkw

doesn't mean I think he is innocent but the argument is a fair possibility.

My only other choices would be Dawg or NJ.



Dawg has caught my eye on certain issues that I've posted about and I think if he is a snitch then Bkw is more then likely also one.This has to do with them being side by side on the list and a possible protection ploy by using the list in order.

NJs quick vote,for whatever reason she chooses to use is out of sorts for her normal play. Even if in jest she admits she wouldn't have been around to change it. What if night was when she thought it was and Lg was shanked as an innocent? NJ is usually more careful with her vote.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Convinced? Strong word... advised against using my possible only invest today, absolutety. Not sure I wish to post who I am suspicious of until I have evidence. If my invest. proves correct, I will def. post results. Just riding the coat tails a little til I figure out WTH I am doin! I hope to be more useful than I am ATM. Tomorrow is a whole new day..........

noodles, I suggest not using your investigation tonight... Snitches will appear innocent on day 1.

 

[Rbishop]

Gad!!!! What a read!!!!

 

[noodles62]

noodles, I suggest not using your investigation tonight... Snitches will appear innocent on day 1.

Oh definintely. Just gotta make a decision on who to shank..........ARG!

 

[noodles62]

sorry for the typo - not allowed to edit:cry:
I hate typos.....

 

[NeonJulie]

how funny is this that I was thinking you were one of the quieter ones in games past... tell me, how many times have you been the bad guy?


Your vote confuses me and it may be because you are new... but to vote on someone you started but did not end your thought with? While I agree with both of your thoughts here, I would think Jbrad was the more guiltier one because of the seeming experience he has as a newbie... but then you're a newbie too so just trying to follow your thought here.

Yes well - in the past - that's why Lady G came after me so quickly, because it's TOO innocent, doesn't help the Townies out, and if you're too afraid of lynching someone, it must be because your guilty and have something to be afraid of.

This round, I have to lynch someone, or UD, would you rather I UD? Can you even lynch No One?

And isn't this the same as my normal night 1 votes? To place it on a single vote, rather than endanger someone who got mobbed for in the past, stupid reasons - like miscounting numbers.

It's not like I'm on a train here, and I'm not trying to sway votes towards her - it's my personal vote.[/quote]
Was this copied out of a different mafia game because it seems the same thing is said over and over in each game.

how odd that the train is actually on you at this point.

Sorry I can't reply really to what I can't read... ?

The one question I read ok is how many times have I been mafia. Um, Game no. 4, Game 33 I think, I started innocent, was turned Mafia. That's it, most of the games I ended up Medic, or Detective, or Swat Team - or innocent.

The train comment is pretty weightless - I never said there wasn't a train - I just said I wasn't part of an LG train.

 

[NeonJulie]

NJs quick vote,for whatever reason she chooses to use is out of sorts for her normal play. Even if in jest she admits she wouldn't have been around to change it. What if night was when she thought it was and Lg was shanked as an innocent? NJ is usually more careful with her vote.

What if? What if that, and what if this, and what if you're actually guilty yourself? Anyway, LG was never in danger of a shank, and still isn't, so What Ifs are pretty useless at this point.

I am still very careful with my vote. I'm not switching it, or going along with the crowd over number Seventeen. I feel guilt, it's enough for my conscience to vote for, and it's night one, and I understand there are some risks.

It sure beats the past 6 mafia night one shank reasons though, IMO.

 

[Rbishop]

I admit I am not a big fan of the planned investigations. Too many pitfalls. I think it best to let things play out for now. It may work out better for such an idea around night 3/4, if folks still have them left.

 

[NeonJulie]

NJ - seems very protective over the newbies and seems to say a lot of what has said in past games. So, that thought puts me where she realy doesn't have much to say except to see herself posting as to look helpful. [/B]

Well.. *lol* I've had a lot more to say, than you. I have to repeat myself because people miss so much these days.

Why would you be suspicious if I feel a little protective of our newbies??