Mafia #41 The Play -- 50/50

[judgemax]

I dunno, I still can't shake that nagging feeling about c-note..I think its odd, that after being so forcefully vocal, the he just dropped off the face of the earth?..

I also have to say, It makes me uneasy that so many jumped so fast on noodles..I remember many games where two innocents squabbled , and after lynching one, we did the other, and we don't have that kind of leeway here...

I vote to lynch c-note

 

[plantling]

Just thought I'd paste some things from the rules.

7) The Mafia win, when they outnumber the Innocents, after night #4 or later events.

After night #4, there will be no more investigations, just a nightly Lynch and Hit.

Investigations will reveal only if Mafia or Innocent.

So basically after night 4, the Innocents should have at least equal numbers with the Mafia and hopefully have enough knowns to control the voting and not hit one of their own. I guess the groups each get a hit as long as there are any communicating guys left. So maybe it's best to concentrate on investigating pple who might be innocent to add to the innocent pool. Though the Mafia get a hit tonight, too, so hopefully the Doc's protection comes in handy.

 

[IceH2O]

At the risk of sounding like I am protecting Noodles....Ice you are voting Noodles because they left your name off? Kinda a strange reason there. Sorry to hear you are not "into" the game this time.

Have to admit this makes me wonder about you even more. Not because you voted Noodles but because of your reason..no whats funny, I didn't add Z to the "list" I made and no one even noticed LMAO!!! I forgot he was even playing at the time.

I have to say Z's lack of participation along with Ice's lack has me wondering about them very much.

Thinking her leaving my name off her list might be a setup is the reason I voted her. I'm not so sure my vote will sit there though, I want to see more before I place a final vote.

See below

Fishing for answers is a good thing...the lack of care for playing the game is evident but not sure if that makes you more guilty or less. I think you are typically gung ho about playing this game but you seem to want to drop off the radar this time around. Either it is boredom or you are a mafia scum. In my opinion, either way...I vote to lynch Ice.

The lack of interest, the hypocriticalness, the overlooking of the game format to throw suspicion on Dawg for leaning MC innocent, all that doesn't even raise a brow for you, Z? I mean there are 6 or 7 Mafia left and only 4 or 5 Innocents. Perhaps Ice is a noncommunicating Mafia or possibly the communicating Mafia aren't cohesive this round. Maybe it is truly and simply lack of interest on Ice's part but if he's an Innocent, he is a very poor and unhelpful innocent.

I was hoping to get a reaction like this.

So its better to have a dead innocent then an innocent that isn't into the game at this time? I'd think it would be more protown to keep dead weight just to have the numbers.

 

[plantling]

I dunno, I still can't shake that nagging feeling about c-note..I think its odd, that after being so forcefully vocal, the he just dropped off the face of the earth?..

I also have to say, It makes me uneasy that so many jumped so fast on noodles..I remember many games where two innocents squabbled , and after lynching one, we did the other, and we don't have that kind of leeway here...

I vote to lynch c-note

Yes, I'm alarmed at the long train on Noodles also, but I'm hoping that it's just because she's made one too many errors and they've given her up for lost.

I think C-note, G, and Noodles have not voted yet.

 

[judgemax]

IMHO, since its 50/50 The dead weight helping or not, ..if innocent, we need. If your dead weight mafia, please feel free to just UD tonight ..thanks..

 

[plantling]

Thinking her leaving my name off her list might be a setup is the reason I voted her. I'm not so sure my vote will sit there though, I want to see more before I place a final vote.

See below





I was hoping to get a reaction like this.

So its better to have a dead innocent then an innocent that isn't into the game at this time? I'd think it would be more protown to keep dead weight just to have the numbers.

Ice, I can't claim to that I know how you play but from my experiences playing with you, you are a better player than this. I truly believe that you are a disgruntled Mafia member. Whether communicating or lone evil remains to be seen.

 

[plantling]

IMHO, since its 50/50 The dead weight helping or not, ..if innocent, we need. If your dead weight mafia, please feel free to just UD tonight ..thanks..

:lipssealedsmilie:

 

[judgemax]

Ice, I can't claim to that I know how you play but from my experiences playing with you, you are a better player than this. I truly believe that you are a disgruntled Mafia member. Whether communicating or lone evil remains to be seen.

Honestly, from what I do know of ICE, i think its disinterest in the game, regardless of his role. Its discouraging , When so few are posting. Myself included. Soon , ..it will be winter, and hopefully we can garner more interest again, ..or we will have to watch( painfully as it may be) mafia go to the way side.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, I can't claim to that I know how you play but from my experiences playing with you, you are a better player than this. I truly believe that you are a disgruntled Mafia member. Whether communicating or lone evil remains to be seen.

See that just goes to show you that you don't know me at all. If I were on a mafia team that wasn't communicating I'd just sell them all out and buy everyones confidence. If I were a lone mafia I'd do my best to get them to investigate me to join them as communicating. I wouldn't be playing for the innocents investigation. I enjoy being mafia much more then I do an innocent unless I have a good innocent team with me.

I wouldn't UD no matter what team I was on as it wouldn't be fair to them.


Its disinterest in the game due to the low posting. Its been that way for a handful of games now. It gets boring reading your own posts and making a target of yourself just to try and get reactions from others. I decided I would do as the others and not post as much and just try and garner info from reading rather then making a target of myself. But that doesn't seem to work either because most are used to seeing a lot of posts from me so now if I lay back I'm trying to fly under the radar. I'd be more respectful of someone that names me as a possible mafia due to my gameplay in the past versus laying low. I expect to be a suspect until proven innocent just because in the past I have fooled enough people that I should always be considered as dangerous.But to use an excuse of flying under the radar or laying low makes me mafia is BS. Of all the games I played I've never layed low no matter what my role.

 

[noodles62]

Well, I have had a few minutes at work to review the lastest posts and there still is not much to go on. But honestly at this point where I place my one, little old vote really does not matter. I will certainly vote later tonite after I get home and can devote my full attention to the game. Hopefully by then there will be new developments....