Mafia #41 The Play -- 50/50
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Good game, guys.... I was Driver, btw. And thanks for the early exit from the game.... does anyone bother to read what people say before deciding that they're scum? 
I mean, c'mon, noodles shows up at the thread and doesn't bother to even say 'Hi.' Instead she posts 'Hi' five hours later because she admittedly wanted others to post first....that's called trying to blend in.
I agree somewhat... actually 4 were lurking for the whole game (judge, mal, c-note, and z). In future games, though, you can't just go by number of posts...you have to judge the content, too. Focusing solely on the number of posts when lynching can lead to bad things for the town.
The CIs were felt pretty good that you were mafia by that point...and things like 'I am the puppet master' and 'everyone voting for me is scum' seemed to confirm it :grinyes:. Since we were pretty much convinced, it seemed wrong to let you dictate the terms of your own death.
When you claimed doc, we didn't believe it. The fact that on Day 3, before any heat real heat came your way, you proposed 'hit me, but don't lynch me' seemed anti-town for a doc. It would have tied the CIs hit up on you (when they would have been better hitting mafia). Obviously, though, you had inside info that knew the lynch would end badly (as did I on night 1).
On a separate note, I've got the next game (Mafia 41: Assassin in the Palace). I'll try to post a sign-up thread by next weekend. I can't see people jonesing to play the next game already, as a lot of folks barely posted this game.
I mean, c'mon, noodles shows up at the thread and doesn't bother to even say 'Hi.' Instead she posts 'Hi' five hours later because she admittedly wanted others to post first....that's called trying to blend in.I agree somewhat... actually 4 were lurking for the whole game (judge, mal, c-note, and z). In future games, though, you can't just go by number of posts...you have to judge the content, too. Focusing solely on the number of posts when lynching can lead to bad things for the town.
Plant was the choice, as she was clearly an innocent. As I had been lynched by then, the plan was to bring her in to help shore up the communicating innocents.
The CIs were felt pretty good that you were mafia by that point...and things like 'I am the puppet master' and 'everyone voting for me is scum' seemed to confirm it :grinyes:. Since we were pretty much convinced, it seemed wrong to let you dictate the terms of your own death.
When you claimed doc, we didn't believe it. The fact that on Day 3, before any heat real heat came your way, you proposed 'hit me, but don't lynch me' seemed anti-town for a doc. It would have tied the CIs hit up on you (when they would have been better hitting mafia). Obviously, though, you had inside info that knew the lynch would end badly (as did I on night 1).
On a separate note, I've got the next game (Mafia 41: Assassin in the Palace). I'll try to post a sign-up thread by next weekend. I can't see people jonesing to play the next game already, as a lot of folks barely posted this game.
LMAO!! Soooooo, I was completely backward on Chill and Dawg:headshake2: The reason I was so sure Dawg was innocent was because of him and cichlids saying they thought the other to be innocent for some reason after cichlids was lynched and reveled innocent I thought they were CI's
Soooooory Ice....I so wanted to believe you and I came so close to switching so many times
Soooooory Ice....I so wanted to believe you and I came so close to switching so many times
Cichlids was hit by the CIs... If he were a CI, himself, he probably would have mentioned to the others in the CI group that killing him was a bad idea
The reason I switched off Dawg after the Noodles fiasco was because I thought him and Plant might have been CIs. He followed her pretty closely.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
LMAO.... what's good dawg, is "most" times, I am able to separate each game. I don't know how but I do it... the only game I remember of you is your first and you were quite active... everything else.... blur...
some might consider that stupid, I say it gets me along each game.
I'm in your game Mad
Cichlids was hit by the CIs... If he were a CI, himself, he probably would have mentioned to the others in the CI group that killing him was a bad idea
LMFAO!!! I spose that is true....to bad I didn't think of that
erv:
Rutro! Before I made that post saying maybe the CI's should investigate someone they think should be innocent I realized that ya'll might pick me but then since I get hit alot wasn't sure if that was a good idea so I added that bit about maybe the Doctor could come in handy. Guess Ice wasn't paying attention or he'd marked me for Mafia already somehow.
One other reason I thought you must be Mafia was that since the innocents were down at least two, I expected the Innocents and especially the veteran players to post more. I guess you had something to hide though it wasn't what we thought, LOL. If it makes you feel any better, after I was hit I realized you probably were set up.
You didn't see me going after Dawg and calling him a Dirty Scum Dog after Driver was lynched? Quit skimming, LOL. He was next on my unpublished list after Noodles and yourself.
