Here's the thing, if we lynch an innocent, there's no next night... the best we can hope for is a tie. If an innocent is lynched, then the elves kill an innocent...it's tied 2-2. The next night comes down to a runoff, with 2 scum on one candidate and 2 townies on another. If the flip goes the elve's way, they win... if not they still kill a townie and its a 1-1 tie. GAME OVER.
We absolutely need to hit scum tonight.
Ok Mad lets say I believe you on the point about Dawg. Its not over tonight if I give the presents to Hooked. This forces him to open them or prove that hes evil. See bob annocned that plant opened the gift 1 1/2 hrs before nightfall plenty of time to switch votes.