I agree that my vote on 3L put him in the lead, but come on! There was no way I could take out John instead when 3L was so blantantly anti -town. The way he just magically popped in after close to 2 complete days of play time (with pretty lame excuses) and throws a vote on JL for no reason at all seemed really scummy. Apprently others thought so as well, as the fresher prints in the snow were Hooked, DD & Jpappy..........
Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I agree that my vote on 3L put him in the lead, but come on! There was no way I could take out John instead when 3L was so blantantly anti -town. The way he just magically popped in after close to 2 complete days of play time (with pretty lame excuses) and throws a vote on JL for no reason at all seemed really scummy. Apprently others thought so as well, as the fresher prints in the snow were Hooked, DD & Jpappy..........
Noodles, as your responses were embedded in quotes, I can't really show them here... Saying that other people also find another player interesting isn't good justification for a vote. It makes it look like one may be trying to hide in a crowd, or trying to 'spread the blame around' instead of backing up their own vote.
OK...Who's the 1 you suspect the most who voted for 3L? It's interesting to me how you know so much about what the Mafia is thinking.
Wow! this is a big thing. Too bad I came out after nightfall and jumped on DD not Noods. Noods actually dropped down a notch on my list after nightfall. If you look at all the votes last night you will also see that Eddie and JPap had votes on Noodles but retracted before nightfall. Well thanks to you Noodles has dropped another notch on my list. Here's the list in order of suspicion...
1. DD
2. Cat
3. Noodles
I'm 110% sure I will be voting for one of these 3 before nightfall.
I was actually ready to come on this morning and put my vote on DD. But now that Cat has peaked my suspicions I will be holding off until I can look back at some of his posts.
Sorry about the quote thing. Dawg gave me a learnin last night but I guess my news skills were a bit foggy this monrin. I promise I will get it sooner or later! LOL
I understand what you are saying however I did explain why voted JL earlier in the day - that quote you are referring to was a response to dawg not a complete explaination of my vote. I can go back and find all my reasons if needed.......Lord knows I did enough yesterday.
Very interesting points dawg. definitely something worth looking into. Cat "believes" that only one mafia voted 3L -
How and why would a person say that? I do not get the line of thinking unless he is on the inside....
Darnitalltoheck u done found us out! LMAO, Cat. U actually think I would follow a teammate so closely on voting someone on day 1 and then share the same suspect w/them day 2?
I believe the final votes on 3L in order were Mad, JL, JP, Noodles, DD, and HN. JP voted before u so your prints would be fresher than his. And I'm not so sure that DD and HN would jump on a sinking ship if they were evil, though it's not unheard of. Apparently this is the second time u are using others actions to justify yours.
When u made that comment about Mad also being suspicious of JL it did give me a weird feeling also. More justification for your actions when your own reasons should have been enough if you believed JL was evil.
Not necessary noodles. I don't have a problem with your JL vote, just that you drew others in as justification.
Here's another quote where, once again, when defending yourself, you draw others in (HN, DD & Jpap). It definitely seems that you're looking to stand in the middle of the crowd.
Very interesting points dawg. definitely something worth looking into. Cat "believes" that only one mafia voted 3L -
Ok since your folks dont understand my line of thinking, here it is.
1.) First off, having played enough games as both innocent and mafia, I know that for a fact every time some one who pulls a stunt like that one T3L did it would peek the interest of the innocents.
2.)That made him look completely mafia, It even did to me after I read It when I got home last nite.
3.) With what they did, the innocents jumped on what looked to be a blattent noob mafia mistake.
4.)Now as for the mafia they were watching this as well and me believing that the mafia arent stupid they let this train run right over T3L.
5.)If mafia was smart as I believe, they would have just let one of their players on T3L so when it came back that he was Innocent it would make it hard for us to find the lone evil in 6 different people.
6.)It is all about risk negation. Noodles It has been established rather well in this game you have been mafia & as for you there Dawg I have played games with you where you were mafia. So with that established lets look at this. Would you as mafia have jumped all your guys onto that or would you have made some of your guys stay off that because you knew it was a sinking ship?
So tell me what would you folks have done?
DD,you was all over 3l,and for that matter Eddie as well,now i can see your evil plan,i knew it was just a matter of time,two innocents killed and your tring to be soo broken up about it!hmmmmm.maybe i was wrong about JL,time will tell;but for now I retract my vote to lynch Jl and vote to lynch DD
