johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
At least you could find the thread! You sure you weren't helping someone move or at a motocross event?
Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
At least you could find the thread! You sure you weren't helping someone move or at a motocross event?
Yes my thought is that they are part of a communicating group. Yes I know people can comm outside the game. And yes I know that its only part of the answer. IMO if I am correct and this is a group now we have one of the 2 groups. Now here is where I'm having trouble so i brought it to light. I cant for the life of me figure out if they are Innocent or evil. I have been looking back and I'm hoping others have as well. Maybe if others have looked back they could find something I have missed. Thats all I ask.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Or when evil.
Like I said before, you are 100% correct that I normally do not change my vote to save myself. Most often, I rely on the town to save me. Even when I have been evil, I ask my teamates not to defend me or help me.
The way things were going, before 3L showed up. I saw myself pretty much a gone. I expected a few others to move to me. I didn't expect it to even be close. I have posted way more than I ever have in past games and I have been more aggresive this round (and last). I can see how this has made me a good choice to lynch.
my password was numbers,but now i changed it to something i can remeber.
I was going to retract my vote on DD.
I was going to retract my vote on DD.
Glad u realize lone votes do the town no good. So I'll bite, who would u have switched it to?
Ok since your folks dont understand my line of thinking, here it is.
1.) First off, having played enough games as both innocent and mafia, I know that for a fact every time some one who pulls a stunt like that one T3L did it would peek the interest of the innocents.
2.)That made him look completely mafia, It even did to me after I read It when I got home last nite.
3.) With what they did, the innocents jumped on what looked to be a blattent noob mafia mistake.
4.)Now as for the mafia they were watching this as well and me believing that the mafia arent stupid they let this train run right over T3L.
5.)If mafia was smart as I believe, they would have just let one of their players on T3L so when it came back that he was Innocent it would make it hard for us to find the lone evil in 6 different people.
6.)It is all about risk negation. Noodles It has been established rather well in this game you have been mafia & as for you there Dawg I have played games with you where you were mafia. So with that established lets look at this. Would you as mafia have jumped all your guys onto that or would you have made some of your guys stay off that because you knew it was a sinking ship?
So tell me what would you folks have done?
Your point in the bold above makes me think you just slipped. Even you? Do you know something we don't?
Cat, my question to you is why are you so specific about what the mafia knows? Why 1 person only on 3L (you kind of answered that)? But most importantly...Who in the group who voted for 3L is your pick for the 1 mafia you talk about?
No Sir,i did say maybe!!i'm still watching you,waiting for a slip,watch that ice!!!!!maybe it's a trick to see how you react,hmmmm,or DD for that matter.
As for my quote if I would have been here last night my vote would have changed to him because it looked very evil to me. That is what im saying. See I got to read the whole thing because it had already unfolded and I had jumped to nite fall right off the bat and saw he was Innocent. But when I went back and looked at what i missed It looked evil to me as well. See I came to the same statement.
As for how I'm so specific,
First look at my post 549 and quit skimming. this will answer your question as to me being specific.
As for who I think well lets look at that.
T3L (6) mad 204 jl66 338 jpap 410 ndle 416 DD 420 hk 434
Mad- Unsure but leary why vote for a probable UD when it doesnt help the town one bit.
Jl66- Made an effort to tie it up to save himself. Very unlike him mafia or innocent. I think he is pressing to hard and has a few good points that makes me think a renewed vet back and kicking weasels.
Jpap- seemed to jump ship but who wouldnt after what T3L did. Doubt its Him
Ndle- Since You(Dawg) and Plt are the ones Im looking at and she is your prime target this make me lean Innocent.
DD- Not sure may be her because she is going round and round about mostly unimportant stuff (motorcross) and has me worried.
HN- what can I say its always hard to read hooked when he is out and about. He seems like a good laying low evil vote but once again he is got his "outta town" Issue.
Makes it hard this is why I'm looking back on every one today hopefully I find the link that I need to find.
Thanks for answering my questions but it looks like you think 3 out of the 6 could be evil. I thought you said 1. So if you had to pick 1 who would it be? Give me 1 person 1 name just as you stated.
Oh...and I didn't skim. Maybe you should have read my post...
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
so piggy, you you actually name the little guys in your head or what?
good point, I have the same feelings about cat.... until a post or so from him, ago stating that "that's what he means", something about a communicating group... the way his post in regards to the mafia being this way and thinking that way in no way read as communicating groups.... looks more like cat is trying to cover his tracks...
what is the big deal about me picking on the motocross excuse?? All I was stating was that even though eddie was posting links to a motcross site, how are we to know it was actually him. It didn't prove if he was mafia or not... there was no point. As hard as you all (not just you) are saying I was on Eddie, it seems you are all as hard, if not harder on me... and for what reason? Eddie seemed Mafia, there's no two ways about it and I was trying to get him to show that he was by a slip up or whatever... but I was wrong.... and now I am condemned for it? Playing a little heavy handed from behind the chat walls, aren't you? Careful, you're being a little obvious.
